My husband left me for a woman eleven years younger and told me why: “Look at you. You quit trying the day the twins were born.”
So I paid a man $400 to play my boyfriend at his parents’ Labor Day pool party.
Mitch laughed at him with everyone watching, and twenty minutes later his girlfriend was crying in the driveway.
He said it from our bedroom doorway with his gym bag already zipped, while Giulia and Luca ate cereal downstairs.
“There’s somebody else,” he said. “I’ve loved her since March.”
His eyes went down me and came back up slow, like he was checking a price tag.
“Look at you, Ileana. You quit trying the day the twins were born.”
I’ve forgotten most of what the lawyer said.
I haven’t forgotten that.
Seventeen years married.
Two babies at once, and I was the one up with both of them every night.
And what he saw at the end of it was the forty pounds I never got off after carrying them.
Her name was Kaitlyn.
She ran the front desk at his insurance office.
She was thirty-two, and her Instagram was rooftop bars and his hand on her hip in every other picture.
At his parents’ Easter, with our kids at the table, he raised his glass and called her “my second chance.”
Sheri set the ham down and didn’t look at me.
I quit using the hallway mirror after that.
I’d walk past it with my eyes on the carpet so I wouldn’t hear him say it again.
Seven months went by.
Then, nine days before Labor Day, Giulia got in the car after volleyball and didn’t buckle her seatbelt.
“Grandma’s doing the pool thing Monday,” she said. “Please come, Mom.”
“Honey, I don’t think Grandma wants me there.”
“I asked her. She said she’d love it.”
She picked at the tape on her finger.
“Luca won’t say it, but he wants you there too.”
I kept both hands on the wheel.
“Your dad’s going?”
“Yeah.”
“And Kaitlyn?”
Giulia looked out her window and took a while.
“She’s bringing a cheesecake.”
Everything in me said no.
My mouth said okay.
That night, after both of them were asleep, I did something I’m still a little embarrassed to type.
I paid a stranger $400 to play the man in my life for a day.
He was on an app people use when they need a date for a wedding.
During the week he modeled for department store catalogs.
He went by Donovan.
Monday only. Four hours.
Hold my hand, and leave when I said so.
Pathetic, right?
I thought so too.
But seven months of being furniture in my own life had done something to me.
I needed Mitch to look across that pool and see a woman who kept going after he walked out with his gym bag.
Monday morning the doorbell rang, and I almost texted him to forget the whole thing.
He was standing on my porch like an ad for something I couldn’t afford.
Six-foot-two.
Easy shoulders.
That calm you only see on men nobody has ever talked down to.
I laughed, and it came out wrong.
“We can still call this off. I’ll pay you anyway.”
“I’m not calling anything off,” he said.
He studied me a beat longer than a stranger should.
“Can I ask you something? Is today about making him jealous?”
I opened my mouth. Nothing.
“Or is it about you remembering that somebody would pick you on purpose?”
I didn’t have an answer for that.
I still don’t.
We pulled up to Bruce and Sheri’s place in Fresno a little after one.
Cars lined both sides of the street.
Motown was coming off a speaker on the patio roof, and kids were cannonballing into the deep end while the grown-ups stood around with paper plates of corn.
Sheri waved from the folding table, saw Donovan, and left her hand up in the air a second too long.
Mitch was at the grill in the gray trunks I bought him two summers ago, the ones with the drawstring he never once tied.
He saw me first.
Then he saw Donovan’s arm come around my shoulders, and the spatula stopped.
Giulia was sitting on the edge of the pool with her feet in the water.
She looked at Donovan, and then she looked at her dad.
Mitch handed the spatula to Bruce and came across the concrete with Kaitlyn half a step behind him.
“Well, well,” he said.
He looked Donovan over the way he’d looked me over in that doorway.
“So this is the new guy?”
Donovan put out his hand. “Donovan.”
Mitch left it hanging in the air.
He laughed instead. Big. A laugh aimed at a whole yard.
“Come on, man. Seriously? This is bullshit.”
The people by the cooler turned around.
“WHAT’S SHE PAYING YOU? By the hour? Does she get a receipt?”
Kaitlyn put her hand on his arm and giggled into his shoulder.
“Babe, stop,” she said. “Be nice. She tried.”
“No, I want to know. Where’d you find him, Ileana? Same place you found the guy who did the gutters?”
Somebody’s uncle snorted into his beer.
A woman by the diving board had her phone up.
“Buddy, you can drop the act,” Mitch said.
“She’s got twins and a minivan. Nobody’s grading the arm thing.”
Then he looked from Donovan to me, smiled, and let the yard finish the sentence for him.
“Mitch.” That was Bruce, from the grill. “Enough.”
Mitch didn’t even turn around.
“Seventeen years,” he said, “and THIS is what you come up with.”
The Motown kept playing.
Nobody else made a sound.
Sheri put down a pan of foil-wrapped potatoes and stayed bent over it.
Giulia pulled her feet out of the water and gripped the edge with both hands.
My face burned all the way up to my ears.
Every part of me wanted to turn around and walk back to the car.
Then Donovan’s thumb pressed once into the back of my hand.
And stayed there.
His eyes never left Mitch.
“You’ve got this turned around,” he said.
Mitch grinned with all his teeth. “Oh yeah?”
“Nobody paid me to stand here.”
His eyes came to me for a second, then went back to Mitch.
“I’m the one who ASKED TO COME.”
Mitch’s grin slipped.
Seventeen years, and I had never seen that grin slip.
He looked at Kaitlyn.
Kaitlyn looked at her nails.
Twenty minutes later, Donovan did what I never managed to do in all my years married to that man.
Kaitlyn came through the side gate crying, her sandals in her hand.
Mitch stood by the deep end with his mouth open and nothing coming out of it.
And the whole of Sheri’s backyard was looking at him.
Not at me.
The side gate
Donovan had asked him to repeat a sentence.
That was all. He’d made Mitch turn toward Kaitlyn and say it directly to her, instead of throwing it across the pool at me.
Mitch said it again.
Now the gate was swinging against its latch, and Kaitlyn was on the other side.
I reached over and caught the gate before it hit a third time.
My hand left a wet mark on the wood.
I’d been sweating enough to irrigate something.
Mitch took one step toward me.
“Go talk to her.”
There it was. The first complete sentence he could manage, and it came with a job for me.
Donovan moved aside. He didn’t answer for me.
“What would you like me to say?” I said.
“Don’t start.”
Behind him, Bruce put the spatula down.
Sheri stood beside the patio door, both hands flat against her dress.
Nobody needed potatoes anymore.
Mitch looked toward the driveway.
“She’s upset.”
“Yes.”
“You know what I meant.”
I did. That was part of the trouble.
I knew the version he used around other people and the version he saved for a bedroom doorway.
For once, they’d come out the same.
He rubbed his forehead with the heel of his hand.
“Just tell her you’re fine.”
I wanted to ask whether I should also bring her cheesecake out.
Perhaps put it on the hood and cut everybody a slice of whatever this was.
Instead, I took my hand off the gate.
“No.”
He stared at me.
Through the opening, Kaitlyn bent to put on one sandal, then stood again without fastening it.
Her phone was in her other hand.
She wiped her face with the back of her wrist.
Mitch lowered his voice.
“The kids don’t need to see this.”
“They’re inside with their grandmother.”
Sheri had just come back out. She could hear me.
So could the people who’d heard him ask what I was paying Donovan.
For seven months, I’d imagined Mitch being embarrassed before a crowd.
I’d been embarrassingly thorough about it. Better hair on me.
Better man beside me.
A drink in his hand that he forgot to swallow.
None of my little bedroom productions included this part.
His girlfriend crying, his father looking at the ground, and me being asked to clean up after him again.
He put his hand against the gate.
“Move, Ileana.”
I stepped back and let him go through alone.
The yellow dress
On Monday morning, before Donovan rang the bell, Giulia stood in my bedroom doorway while I tried to pull the yellow dress away from my stomach.
“You’re going to stretch it,” she said.
“That’s the general hope.”
“It fits.”
“It fits everywhere at once. That’s different.”
She came in and took my hand off the fabric.
Thirteen years old, and she was already tired of arguing with a dress on my behalf.
My swimsuit lay on the bed.
I’d taken it out, folded it, put it away, and taken it out again.
It was getting more exercise than I was.
“Are you swimming?” she said.
“Probably not.”
“Luca said you’d say that.”
“Tell Luca to mind his business.”
“He wants you on our side.”
“Your side of what?”
“The pool game. Against Grandpa.”
I tucked the swimsuit into my bag before I could have a committee meeting about it.
Giulia smiled. Then her eyes went to my phone.
“Is that your friend?”
Donovan’s message was on the screen. He was on his way.
“Yes.”
“Is he your boyfriend?”
“We’re getting to know each other.”
The sentence came out easily. I’d practiced it while brushing my teeth.
That should have told me something.
“Okay,” she said.
She didn’t ask his job or his age.
She wanted to know whether he minded getting splashed.
“I haven’t asked.”
“You should. Grandpa cheats.”
She went downstairs. I sat on the bed with my phone in my lap.
The booking was right there. Four hours. Four hundred dollars.
A little picture of Donovan in a sweater nobody in our town could wear before November.
Under the booking was a button to end it.
I’d read that part twice.
If I ended the outing early, he still got paid.
I’d agreed to that.
He’d saved the afternoon for me, and I wasn’t going to argue over minutes like a woman returning a melon.
I almost pressed it.
Then the bell rang.
After the conversation on the porch, Donovan stepped inside while I found my bag.
“One thing,” I said. “My children don’t know.”
“About the app?”
I nodded.
“What did you tell them?”
“That we’re getting to know each other.”
He looked at the bag in my hand.
“We are. But if they ask me a direct question, I won’t lie to them.”
I didn’t like that. I liked it even less because he was right.
“They probably won’t.”
“All right.”
“And if I want to leave, we leave.”
“Of course.”
“No persuading me to remain because I paid for four hours.”
He grinned.
“I don’t make people finish parties.”
I could have hugged him for that sentence.
I settled for putting my keys in the wrong pocket.
At the door, he held out his hand, then stopped short of taking mine.
“Here?”
“Not yet.”
“Okay.”
He waited while I locked up.
Then he said, “Can I come with you even if you decide you don’t want the boyfriend part?”
I looked at him.
“That might be a very boring afternoon.”
“I’ve modeled bathrobes in July.”
I laughed properly that time.
He hadn’t promised to fool Mitch. He hadn’t promised to make anyone jealous.
I’d supplied those services in my own head and charged them to his account.
Across town, the twins were already at their grandparents’ house.
Giulia had asked Sheri to save me a chair.
When we reached the pool, I let Donovan put his arm around me.
Then Mitch came over.
The cooler
After Donovan said he’d asked to come, Mitch looked at me as if I’d moved something in a room he owned.
“What does that mean?”
I could have answered. I could have told him about the porch.
Instead, I said, “It means say hello and let us get a drink.”
A small request. Practically decorative.
Kaitlyn pulled at his arm.
“Come on. The burgers.”
“He’s got them,” Mitch said.
Bruce was still holding the spatula. He looked at his son.
“Take a walk, Mitch.”
Mitch lifted both hands.
“I’m welcoming them.”
“You missed,” Bruce said.
A couple of people looked down at their plates. I wanted to laugh.
My mouth wouldn’t cooperate.
I took Donovan toward the cooler. His hand stayed loose around mine.
I could have let go without a struggle, which was becoming a remarkable feature in a man.
Mitch followed.
Of course he did. The welcome had legs.
“Where’d you two meet?”
“Online,” I said.
“Which site?”
“Mitch.”
“What? That’s how people meet now. I’m being interested.”
Donovan bent to open the cooler.
“Water?” he said to me.
“Please.”
Mitch leaned against the fence.
“So what do you do, Donovan?”
“Catalog work, mostly.”
“Like a model?”
“Yes.”
Mitch looked at me and smiled again.
“Sure.”
Donovan handed me a bottle.
He didn’t explain his work, list clients, or produce proof that somebody had paid him to wear trousers.
I loved him a little for that.
In the ordinary, temporary way you love a person who doesn’t make a bad room worse.
“Can I talk to you?” I said to Mitch. “Just you.”
His eyebrows went up.
“Already?”
I walked a few steps toward the side of the house.
Far enough to lower my voice. Not far enough to be trapped.
“Stop,” I said.
He glanced past me at Donovan.
“You brought him here.”
“I was invited.”
“By my mother.”
“By our daughter.”
“Same thing.”
“No.”
He took a drink from his can.
“You’re making a production out of nothing. People are having fun.”
“I am asking you to stop talking about my body and our children like they’re a joke.”
“I didn’t say anything about your body.”
“You didn’t have to.”
“Then don’t put words in my mouth.”
There was the familiar little turn.
We could spend the afternoon discussing whether he technically said the thing everyone heard.
I knew that road. It ended with me apologizing for my tone.
“Just leave us alone,” I said.
“Fine.”
I waited.
“Fine,” he said again. “Go enjoy your friend.”
He said friend as if it came in a package marked unsuitable for children.
I walked back to Donovan.
“Everything okay?” he said.
“No. But it will be if he stops.”
Mitch raised his can toward us.
“Sorry, everybody. Apparently I don’t get to ask questions.”
Heads turned again.
The woman near the diving board still held her phone at chest level.
I couldn’t tell whether she was recording.
I hated that I had to wonder.
I pointed toward it.
“Please put that down.”
She did.
Then Mitch said, loud enough to reach the patio, “I guess nobody gets a picture of the happy couple.”
My first attempt had bought me less than ten seconds.
Sheri appeared beside the cooler and touched my elbow.
“Come inside a minute, honey.”
Sheri’s kitchen
I followed her because she’d called me honey for seventeen years.
That was the whole stupid reason.
Donovan stayed by the patio door.
Sheri shut it behind us, carefully, as though the noise outside might spill.
“I am so sorry,” she said.
I put my water on the counter.
“Thank you.”
“He gets carried away.”
My hand was still on the bottle.
“Sheri.”
“I know. Bruce will talk to him.”
“Bruce told him to stop.”
“Well, he needs to cool down.”
I waited for her to say something else.
Something involving her son being the person who went somewhere.
She picked at the corner of a paper towel.
“Maybe today was a little soon.”
“For what?”
“Bringing somebody.”
I looked through the glass at Kaitlyn, who stood beside Mitch with a hand against his back.
Sheri followed my eyes.
“That’s different.”
“How?”
“I didn’t mean different like that.”
“Then how did you mean it?”
She folded the paper towel in half.
“I don’t want the children caught in anything.”
“Neither do I.”
“They were having such a nice time.”
There are sentences that come dressed as concern and still manage to shove you toward the door.
I picked up my water.
“You want me to leave.”
“Just for today.”
“You told Giulia you’d love me here.”
“I would. You know I would.”
“Alone.”
“I didn’t say that.”
“You didn’t have to.”
There I was using the same sentence I’d used on Mitch.
I was doing a family tour.
Sheri’s eyes filled.
“Please don’t make me choose between you and my son.”
“I asked you to tell him to stop.”
“I did.”
“No. Bruce did.”
She pressed the paper towel against her mouth.
I wanted to comfort her. My arm actually moved.
Seventeen years of reaching for this woman when she cried, and my body hadn’t received the change of address.
I put my hand against the counter instead.
“He stood in this house at Easter and called her his second chance. You were right beside me.”
“I remember.”
“You didn’t say anything then, either.”
“What was I supposed to do? Throw the ham?”
Under other circumstances, that would have made us both laugh.
“Say my name,” I said. “You could have said my name.”
She sat on the stool by the counter.
“I thought if we kept things friendly, you’d all find a way.”
“He’s friendly when I’m not here.”
“I don’t know what you want me to say.”
Briefly, I didn’t either.
I wanted her to be the woman who’d held Luca while I got Giulia latched, then switched babies without making me ask.
I wanted that woman to walk outside and say enough with a period after it.
Instead, she looked at my dress.
“You look lovely. You really do. Take your things home before this gets worse.”
The yellow dress was fine for a compliment.
Apparently it couldn’t stay for the afternoon.
I took my phone out of my bag.
The app was still open from that morning.
Four hours.
I’d used hardly any of them.
Sheri stood when she saw the screen.
“Oh, honey.”
I turned it toward my body.
Too late.
She looked through the door at Donovan.
“Does Mitch know?”
“No.”
The answer came out too quickly.
Sheri reached for my wrist.
“Then let’s get you out of here before he finds out.”
The patio door
I pulled my wrist back.
Not hard. Hard would have let her worry about my temper.
“You don’t get to hurry me out because you’re embarrassed.”
“I’m worried about you.”
“I know.”
And she was. That made it worse.
She could be worried about me and still decide I was the easiest person to remove.
Through the glass, Donovan stood alone near the cooler.
Mitch was talking to him again.
I couldn’t hear the words. I could see the smile.
Sheri put her hand on the door.
“Let me take care of this.”
“What are you going to say?”
“I’ll say you aren’t feeling well.”
“No.”
“Nobody will think anything of it.”
“I said no.”
She opened the door anyway.
I followed her out.
“Ileana’s had a difficult few months,” she said.
The patio went quiet in pieces.
First the people close to her, then the others.
My stomach dropped.
“Sheri.”
“Let’s all give her a little room.”
Mitch turned from Donovan.
“I am giving her room. She’s the one who came over to me.”
“That’s enough,” Bruce said.
“But it is.”
Sheri put her arm around my shoulders.
“She’s going to head home.”
I stepped out from under it.
“No, I’m not.”
Giulia came up the pool steps. Luca was behind her.
“Mom?”
She’d heard home. Of all the words scattered around that yard, that was the one she’d picked up.
“I’m staying,” I said.
“You can go if you want.”
She tried to make it easy for me.
I could hear the work in it.
I wanted to sit right down on the concrete and cry.
Instead, I took the towel she held out and put it around her shoulders.
“I’m not leaving because somebody else thinks I should.”
Mitch made a sound through his nose.
Nobody laughed.
Luca stood beside his sister, water dripping from his shorts.
“Are we still doing teams?”
“Yes,” I said.
“Now?”
“In a little while.”
He looked at Donovan.
“Are you on ours?”
“If your mom says so.”
Both children turned to me.
I couldn’t say it.
I couldn’t add one more little brick to the stupid thing I’d built.
“We’ll sort it out,” I said.
Mitch came closer.
“That’s a good question, actually.”
Bruce moved between him and the pool steps.
“Leave the kids out of it.”
“I didn’t bring him.”
“Neither did they.”
That stopped him for a second.
Donovan held out my water.
I took it because my hands needed a job.
“You want to go somewhere else?” he said.
Mitch heard.
“Yes, please. Somewhere you can explain who you actually are.”
Kaitlyn came to stand beside him.
She’d stopped giggling, but her fingers were still hooked through his elbow.
“He’s just asking,” she said.
I looked at her.
“What would you like to know?”
She shifted her weight.
“Nothing. I don’t want to get involved.”
“Then don’t.”
Her hand slipped off Mitch’s arm.
Sheri said my name.
Of course she did now.
I put the water on the nearest chair.
My bag was open beside it, the phone faceup inside.
Mitch glanced down.
He didn’t need to read the screen. Sheri’s face did the work.
“What?” he said.
Nobody answered.
He looked from his mother to me.
“Oh, come on.”
“Mitch,” she said.
“You know something?”
“Stop.”
He reached toward my bag.
I picked it up before he got there.
That made him smile.
Donovan stepped nearer, but I held up my hand.
I’d spent the morning rehearsing how to introduce him.
I’d practiced a story about talking online, leaving the important part out.
Now my daughter was waiting for me to answer a question about pool teams.
I took the phone out myself.
“Yes,” I said. “I paid him.”
Four hours
Mitch clapped once.
One sharp slap of his hands, right before me.
“There it is.”
I wanted the concrete to open. Nothing useful happened.
Concrete is very reliable that way.
“Four hundred dollars,” I said.
Sheri shut her eyes.
Mitch turned toward the patio.
“Four hundred.”
Donovan moved beside me.
“Ileana, you don’t owe anybody the details.”
“I know.”
I only realized it when I said it.
Until then I’d been behaving as though Mitch had a right to inspect anything that might make me happy.
But the children were there.
I’d let them believe this man was something he wasn’t.
I bent to pick up the other end of Giulia’s towel.
“I should have told you before we came.”
She looked at Donovan, then back at me.
“He’s working?”
“Yes. I booked him to come with me.”
Luca frowned.
“Like when people hire someone to sing?”
“Sort of,” I said.
Mitch laughed.
Donovan looked straight at him.
“Don’t.”
That one word took the laugh down a notch.
I stayed facing the twins.
“I was nervous about coming. I made a choice I should have explained to you.”
“Are you friends?” Giulia said.
“We’ve been kind to each other,” I said. “We only met today.”
Her eyes filled, and she rubbed them with the towel before I could reach for her.
“I thought you were happy.”
There it was.
Not a question about whether I’d fooled her father.
Not whether Donovan was handsome enough to count as a victory.
She’d been glad for me.
I put my arms around her, and she let me.
“I’m glad I came to see you.”
“Okay.”
“I am.”
Luca leaned against my side without saying anything.
I held both of them while people looked at us, and I hated the looking.
“Bruce,” I said. “Would you take them inside for a minute?”
He set down the spatula.
“Come on. Help me find the ice.”
They went with him. Giulia looked back once.
“I’ll be here,” I said.
Mitch waited until the door shut.
“That was healthy.”
I turned.
“You don’t get to comment on that.”
“Really? You brought a rented boyfriend into my parents’ house and lied to our children.”
“I did lie about how we met.”
“So we’re agreed.”
“No.”
He pointed at Donovan.
“Does the money cover this part? Standing around while she cries?”
Donovan’s hands stayed at his sides.
“Enough.”
“You said nobody paid you.”
“I said nobody paid me to stand here and take this from you.”
“You said you asked to come.”
“I did.”
Mitch spread his arms.
“Then give the money back.”
I wanted Donovan to tell him no.
I wanted him to defend the money because, for one awful second, it seemed to be the only thing keeping him beside me.
That was the bottom of it.
I could admit the lie. I could survive Mitch laughing.
But I’d put four hundred dollars between myself and the possibility that a person might simply leave.
Sheri came toward me.
“We can still go inside.”
“We?”
“You and me.”
Now she wanted to hide with me.
It was an improvement, but I was out of cupboards.
Kaitlyn looked at my phone.
“Did you really think he’d believe this?”
She said it without the giggle. That didn’t make it kinder.
“No,” I said.
Mitch’s smile widened.
I could have left then. Donovan would have come. We’d agreed on it.
I could have sat in the minivan and kept the last little scrap of company I’d bought.
Instead, I opened the booking.
Under his picture, the clock was still running.
The cancel button
I held the screen toward Donovan.
“I want to end it.”
Mitch gave a little bow.
“There you go.”
I kept looking at Donovan.
“Not because he told you to give the money back.”
“I know.”
“You came when you said you would. You did everything we agreed.”
He nodded.
“I want to stop pretending.”
“Okay.”
My thumb landed on the button.
The app asked whether I was sure.
Even my phone wanted me to reconsider before an audience.
I pressed it again.
Done.
Four hundred dollars for an afternoon I’d barely started.
Donovan took out his phone.
“Keep what you earned,” I said.
“I know.”
He tapped the screen, then put it away.
“The refund request is in.”
Mitch laughed again.
“Best money you never earned.”
Donovan didn’t turn.
I could have grabbed his hand. I wanted to.
Every person in that yard would have understood what I was asking him to prove.
Instead, I stepped away from him.
“You’re free to go.”
“I was free before.”
“Yes.”
He waited.
I took a breath through my mouth because my nose had stopped being useful.
“Would you stay?” I said.
“As my guest. No arm around me unless I ask.”
“Yes.”
“There’s a pool game. Apparently we’re short a person.”
“Then yes.”
Mitch looked toward the patio for a laugh.
Nobody supplied one.
I put my phone in my bag.
Donovan stayed where he was. A few feet away. No touching.
Nothing for Mitch to point at and call fake.
I was still standing in the yellow dress. Still forty-three.
Still the same size I’d been when I paid him.
Mitch lifted his can.
“Well, that was a lot of money and trouble for nothing.”
I wanted to tell him about every night with two babies.
The feeding, the washing, the mornings when he’d gone to work while I was still wearing yesterday.
I’d said those things before.
He’d treated them like excuses submitted after a deadline.
So I didn’t give him the list.
“What was funny?” I said.
He frowned.
“What?”
“Before you knew I paid him. What was funny?”
“The whole performance.”
“You didn’t know about the performance then.”
“I could tell.”
“Why?”
He looked at Donovan.
I moved half a step, enough to bring his eyes back.
“He’s over there. I’m asking.”
Kaitlyn folded her arms. Sheri stayed beside the patio door.
Bruce came back outside.
“They’re getting the ice,” he said to me.
“Thank you.”
Mitch rolled his eyes.
“Are we really doing this?”
“You started it.”
“I made a joke.”
“Explain it.”
He looked around the yard again.
Then he put his can down.
“Fine. You want honesty?”
The deep end
Mitch stood with his back to the pool, his feet planted as if somebody had given him a microphone.
“Everybody knows what this is,” he said.
“I bring Kaitlyn. You show up with him. You want a reaction.”
“I wanted to come to the party.”
“Then come to the party. Don’t put on a show.”
Sheri opened her mouth.
Mitch pointed toward my bag.
“She admitted it, Mom.”
“I heard.”
“So don’t start acting like I’m the bad guy because I said what everybody was thinking.”
Bruce pulled a chair away from the pool edge.
He didn’t sit in it.
“Speak for yourself.”
“I am.”
“No,” Bruce said. “You keep saying everybody.”
Mitch rubbed his palms down the front of his trunks.
The drawstring still wasn’t tied.
I could have recited the little argument we’d had about that two summers earlier.
He’d called me fussy. I’d bought them anyway.
“You want me to believe a man who looks like that just picked her?” he said.
Nobody moved.
I let him finish.
“Come on. We’re adults. There’s no point pretending attraction doesn’t matter.”
Kaitlyn looked down at her hands.
Sheri said, “Mitch, please.”
“What? She asked.”
He turned back to me.
“You didn’t care when we were married. I asked you to make an effort, and somehow that made me a monster.”
“An effort,” I said.
“Yes. An effort. You used to like going out. You used to buy clothes. You used to care how you looked.”
I touched the side of my dress.
He glanced at it.
“Well, now you do.”
That little glance had cost me seventeen years of explaining myself.
I almost told him what the dress cost.
I almost said I’d tried it on three times, that Giulia had helped, that the yellow was the first color I’d bought since he left.
More receipts for a man who’d never intended to reimburse me.
I dropped my hand.
Kaitlyn said, “This wasn’t the place for that.”
He turned to her with relief.
“Exactly.”
“I meant you.”
His mouth stayed open for a second.
She looked toward me, then away.
“You could have said hello.”
“He was lying to us.”
“So were you when you said you were just welcoming them.”
Mitch took a step toward her.
“Babe.”
She stepped back.
“Don’t.”
He lowered his voice, but the yard had become quiet enough to hear him anyway.
“Don’t let her put you in the middle.”
“She didn’t ask me anything.”
“This is what happens. We can’t have one afternoon without it becoming about her feelings.”
I stayed where I was.
He’d said that in our kitchen. In the car.
Once while I was holding a laundry basket against my hip and asking him to come home before the twins’ bedtime.
He said it now with his mother listening.
Sheri sat down.
Kaitlyn pressed her lips together.
“Would you talk about me like this?”
“No.”
The answer came quickly. Too quickly to carry much.
“Then why are you talking about her like this?”
“Because you’re different.”
“How?”
Mitch made a gesture toward her, almost proud.
“Look at you.”
She didn’t smile.
He tried again.
“You take care of yourself. You care about us. I never need to ask.”
Kaitlyn’s face changed. I knew that sentence.
Being congratulated for doing something you hadn’t known was a condition.
“And if I didn’t?” she said.
“Why wouldn’t you?”
“That’s not what I asked.”
He looked at me.
I didn’t help him.
“You’re letting her turn this into some test.”
Kaitlyn held up a hand.
“Would you still want to be with me if I looked like her?”
For a second, I wished she’d chosen different words.
Then she looked at me.
“I’m sorry,” she said.
I nodded once.
Mitch rubbed the back of his neck.
“This is ridiculous.”
“Answer me.”
“Of course I would.”
She didn’t move toward him.
“So you could want her,” she said.
“And you’re making fun of the idea that somebody else could.”
Mitch looked across the pool at Donovan.
There was one more chance for him. He could have stopped.
He could have picked up his drink and gone inside.
He wanted the laugh back.
“I’m not going through that twice,” he said.
“She knows I wouldn’t stay if she let herself go like Ileana.”
Donovan stepped forward.
Not between us. Beside me.
“Tell her,” he said.
Mitch stared at him.
“She’s standing right there,” Donovan said. “Say it to her.”
“This doesn’t concern you.”
“You keep telling us what she knows. Tell her.”
Kaitlyn’s hands dropped to her sides.
“Go on,” she said.
Mitch looked from Donovan to me.
He still seemed to think the argument was with us.
Then he turned to Kaitlyn.
“You know I wouldn’t stay if you let yourself go like she did.”
He said it clearly.
No joke around it.
No laugh to make everybody else responsible for understanding him.
Kaitlyn took off her sunglasses.
“Oh.”
Mitch reached for her hand.
“Don’t do that.”
She pulled it away.
“You asked me.”
She nodded, and the first tears came.
“Yes,” she said. “I did.”
He looked irritated before he looked worried.
I hated that I knew the order.
“You’re taking it wrong.”
“What part?”
“You know I love you.”
“You just told me when you’d stop.”
She bent for her sandals beside the chair.
Her fingers missed one strap, and she had to try again.
Nobody moved to do it for her.
I wanted to. I stayed still.
Mitch followed her toward the gate.
“We’ll talk in the car.”
“I drove here.”
“I know. I’m saying we’ll go somewhere.”
“No.”
He stopped.
She turned back in my direction.
“I laughed.”
I swallowed.
“Yes.”
“I’m sorry.”
“Don’t do it to the next woman.”
She covered her mouth, nodded, and went through the gate.
Mitch stood by the deep end.
For once, there was no wife hurrying to explain what he’d meant.
The empty chair
When Mitch came back from the driveway, he came alone.
I was beside the chair where I’d left my water.
Donovan stood near the fence, far enough away that nobody could mistake him for a barrier.
Mitch looked at him first.
Then at me.
“She’s leaving.”
I waited.
“She says we’re done.”
Bruce put the grill lid down.
Mitch turned toward him.
“Are you happy now?”
“No.”
“Then say something.”
Bruce wiped his hands.
“You need to go home.”
“This is my family’s house.”
“Yes,” Bruce said. “And you’re done insulting people in it.”
Mitch looked at Sheri.
She got up from the stool by the patio door.
For a second, I expected her to ask me again.
Take the dress home. Be the reasonable one. Make it easy.
She walked past me to her son.
“Get your things.”
“Mom.”
“You heard your father.”
He stared at her, then pointed at me.
“She hired him. She admitted lying to the kids. And I’m the one leaving?”
“We’ll talk about what I did,” I said. “Without you laughing through it.”
“You’ve made a complete fool of me.”
I picked up my bag.
“You spoke.”
He waited for more.
I had nothing else for him.
Bruce walked with him to the gate. No hand on his shoulder.
No fatherly pat to help him out of the consequences.
Mitch left the trunks untied. Even then.
Sheri came back to me.
“I’m sorry,” she said.
I didn’t say it was fine.
She looked toward the guests, then back at me.
“I asked the wrong person to leave.”
I nodded.
“I need you to say that when I’m not standing here, too.”
“I will.”
“To Giulia.”
Sheri pressed her hand against her mouth, then lowered it.
“Yes.”
She went inside.
I sat on the chair she’d wanted me to empty.
My knees had started doing something unpleasant. Apparently they’d been waiting for permission.
Donovan crouched a little so I didn’t have to look up so far.
“You want me to go now?”
“No.”
“Okay.”
“I don’t mean you have to stay.”
“I heard you.”
He pulled another chair over and sat with a space between us.
For a while, neither of us said anything.
Then I started crying.
Ugly crying. The kind where you try to wipe one cheek and somehow spread everything to your ear.
Donovan handed me a napkin from the chair beside him.
It stuck to my face.
“Very glamorous,” I said.
“I’ve worked with worse.”
I laughed through my nose and immediately regretted it.
He handed me another napkin.
Beyond the fence, a car started.
Nobody in the yard went to persuade Kaitlyn to come back.
Sheri opened the patio door.
The twins were behind her.
Our side of the pool
Giulia came straight to me.
“Grandma said you didn’t want to leave.”
“I didn’t.”
“She said she was wrong.”
Sheri stayed in the doorway. She didn’t try to improve the report.
Luca looked toward the grill.
“Where’s Dad?”
“He went home,” I said.
“He was being unkind, and Grandpa asked him to leave.”
“Are we going?”
“No.”
His shoulders dropped.
“Good.”
Giulia sat on the arm of my chair.
“Are you really okay?”
“I will be.”
She leaned against me.
Her hair was still damp, and it made a patch on my dress.
I put my hand over hers.
“I’m sorry I lied about Donovan.”
She looked at him.
“Are you still here because of the money?”
“No,” he said.
“Then why?”
“Your mom invited me.”
She thought about that.
“Can you swim?”
“Yes.”
“Grandpa cheats.”
“I’ve been warned.”
Luca grinned.
“He says touching the bottom doesn’t count if nobody sees.”
“That’s because it doesn’t,” Bruce said from the grill.
I laughed. The sound surprised me enough that I stopped halfway through.
Sheri brought my bag over.
“Your swimsuit’s in here, isn’t it?”
I looked at the opening.
“Yes.”
She held it out without giving me a speech about confidence.
I was grateful. Another speech and I’d have climbed into the cooler.
I went inside to change.
The bathroom mirror was above the sink, exactly where mirrors tend to insist on being.
I looked.
The same stomach. The same legs.
A red patch under each eye from crying into party napkins.
I turned sideways, reached to pull the swimsuit down, and stopped.
From outside, Luca shouted that Grandpa was making up rules again.
“Coming,” I said.
When I walked out, I carried the dress instead of wearing it over the suit.
Nobody applauded. Thank goodness. I wanted to swim, not open a hospital wing.
Donovan took the dress when I held it out and laid it on my chair.
“Hand?” he said.
“Not for the stairs. I can manage those.”
“Okay.”
He went down ahead of me.
The water reached my knees, then my hips.
I hadn’t been in that pool since before Mitch left.
I’d spent so many afternoons beside it keeping track of towels that I’d nearly forgotten it was for getting in.
Bruce threw the ball to Luca.
“Teams,” Giulia said. “Mom’s with us.”
“That’s three against two,” Bruce said.
“You cheat,” Luca said.
“Unproven.”
Sheri sat beside the chair with my yellow dress.
She took out her phone.
“Can I get a picture?”
For seven months, I’d stepped out of pictures or stood behind whoever was widest.
I put one arm around Giulia and the other around Luca.
“Wait,” I said.
I moved the twins away from the ladder so it wouldn’t be between us.
“Now.”
Sheri took the picture.
Later she sent it to me, without cropping my stomach out or asking if I wanted a different one.
I kept it.
The refund arrived three days later: $400.00. Donovan hadn’t kept a fee.
I thanked him, and we agreed that if we saw each other again, nobody would book anything.
But that afternoon, he was simply on the other side of the pool with Bruce, trying to convince a thirteen-year-old that adults could count.
Giulia rested her head against my shoulder for a second.
“I’m glad you came, Mom.”
I kissed the top of her head.
Then Luca threw the ball too high, and it landed behind us.
I pushed off the wall.
“I’ve got it.”
If this one stayed with you, send it to someone who’s been standing outside the picture.
There should be room for her in it, too.
For more family betrayals and hard-won comebacks, read the son who gave away his mother’s cabin and the daughter who let her email answer her parents. There’s also the husband who changed the garage code while his father was dying.