She Waited at the Altar for Hours. Then Another Woman Called Him Her Husband.

Daniel Foster

The scent of fresh peonies filling the small church sanctuary slowly turned sickening as the minutes dragged on.

At 67, Martha had spent ten years grieving her late husband before she found the courage to love again. Her groom, Arthur, was a retired schoolteacher known for his absolute punctuality and gentle heart. But as the organist finished the prelude for the third time, the center aisle remained completely empty. Two hundred guests shifted uncomfortably in the pews. Martha stood in the vestibule in her ivory dress, her hands trembling as the pastor gently suggested they send everyone home.

Four hours later, Martha sat frozen in her living room when the phone finally rang. It was a nurse from the county hospital. Arthur had collapsed from a severe cardiac event on his way to the church and was currently in the intensive care unit.

Martha didn’t bother changing out of her wedding dress. She drove straight to the hospital, her heart pounding with a mixture of terror and profound relief that he hadn’t simply abandoned her.

She hurried down the sterile, brightly lit corridor of the ICU, following the room numbers until she reached Arthur’s door. She pushed it open, expecting to see him resting alone.

Instead, a woman in her early sixties was sitting in the chair beside his bed, tightly holding his unconscious hand.

The woman looked up, her eyes narrowing at Martha’s white dress. “Can I help you?” the stranger asked, her voice thick with exhaustion. “Because my husband just got out of surgery, and he needs to rest.”

Forty-Two Years, Give or Take

Martha didn’t move.

She was aware of the door against her palm, the heavy kind with a steel plate at the bottom, and she was aware that if she let go it would swing shut on her train. So she held it. That was the whole of what she could manage.

“I’m sorry,” she said. “I think there’s been a mistake. I’m looking for Arthur Pruitt.”

“That’s Arthur Pruitt.”

It was. Even with the tube taped at the corner of his mouth and his hair flat on one side, it was him. His glasses were folded on the tray table next to a cup of ice chips. Somebody had folded them properly, earpieces crossed.

“I’m Martha,” she said. “Martha Kowalski. We were supposed to be married at two o’clock.”

The woman laughed. It was a short, ugly sound, and she seemed embarrassed by it, because she put her free hand over her mouth afterward.

“Well,” she said through her fingers. “He’s already married. To me. Since June of 1979.” She lifted the hand off Arthur’s and turned it so Martha could see a thin gold band, worn down at the bottom where it would knock against a steering wheel. “Carol. Carol Pruitt. You can check the chart if you want, I’m the next of kin. They called me.”

The monitor beeped. A cart rattled by in the hall.

Martha did the thing she’d done for thirty-one years at Hatch Feed & Supply whenever the numbers came out wrong. She started from the top.

Arthur had told her he was divorced. Arthur had told her the year: 1999. Arthur had told her, on their fourth date, at the Chinese buffet out on Route 9, that he and his ex-wife had “just stopped being kind to each other” and that he didn’t speak ill of her and wouldn’t start now. Martha had liked him for that. Walt used to call his own brother a son of a bitch at Thanksgiving, in front of the grandkids.

“He said you were divorced,” Martha said.

“He would.” Carol looked at the floor, at Martha’s shoes, which were satin and dyed to match and had cost sixty dollars at a bridal place in Harrisburg. “We were supposed to be. It didn’t take.”

How Martha Got to the Buffet in the First Place

She’d met him at the library book sale in March, two years ago. Paperbacks a quarter, hardcovers a dollar.

He’d been the volunteer at the cash box. She’d handed him a five for three dollars’ worth of mysteries and he’d counted the change back to her the old way, from the price up. Three, four, five. Nobody did that anymore. Walt hadn’t even done that.

“You were a teacher,” she’d said.

“Thirty-four years. Eighth grade civics.” He’d looked pleased she’d guessed. “How’d you know?”

“You’re doing it like I might fail the test.”

Her daughter Pam had not been thrilled. Pam was forty-four and lived in Columbus and called every Sunday at four, and her first question about Arthur had been whether he had money, and her second had been whether he had kids, which in Pam’s mind was the same question. He didn’t. Then Pam had asked about the ex-wife, and Martha had said, “Divorced a long time. They don’t talk,” and Pam had said, “Mom, everybody talks,” and Martha had changed the subject to Pam’s gutters.

There was also a dog in all this, a beagle mix named Chester who’d belonged to Arthur’s neighbor and spent most afternoons on Arthur’s porch, but Chester has nothing to do with anything. He just comes to mind.

Arthur proposed in October on her back step, with a ring that had been his grandmother’s. He was always on time. He showed up to their dates at 6:00 when he said 6:00, which meant he’d been sitting in his Buick down the block since 5:50. She’d caught him at it once and he’d been mortified.

So when 2:00 came today, and 2:15, and 2:40, Martha had known. Before the pastor said a word. Arthur Pruitt did not run late. Something had happened to him or he’d decided he didn’t want her, and she’d stood in the vestibule with her bouquet going limp, honestly not sure which one she was praying for.

That was a thought she’d keep to herself for the rest of her life.

What He Was Doing at Six-Forty in the Morning

A nurse came in. Heavy woman, scrubs with cartoon cats on them, a badge that said DONNA. She looked at Martha’s dress and then at Carol and then checked a bag of something on the pole like neither of them were there.

“He’s doing better than he was,” Donna said, to the room in general. “They put two stents in. He’s sedated, he’s gonna stay sedated a while. One visitor at a time in here, ladies, I’m sorry.”

Neither of them moved.

“I’ll get some coffee,” Donna said, and left.

Carol rubbed her eyes with the heels of her hands. Up close she looked rough. Not old exactly, sixty-one, sixty-two. But gray in the face. Her ankles were swollen over the tops of her sneakers and she had a gauze patch taped inside her left elbow, the kind you get after they draw blood.

“He came to my house this morning,” Carol said. “Six-forty. I know because the news was on. He was wearing the suit.”

Martha sat down then. There was a second chair, a hard plastic one by the window, and she sat in it in a dress that wasn’t built for sitting, and the bodice pinched her under the arms.

“Why?”

“Because two weeks ago he went down to the courthouse for your marriage license and the girl at the counter couldn’t find a final decree.” Carol said it flatly, like reading a grocery list. “There’s a petition. From ’99. There’s a separation agreement. There’s no final. His lawyer was a man named Burke who died of a stroke in 2000 and apparently never filed the last piece. Arthur’s been living like a divorced man for twenty-five years, and on paper he’s been my husband the whole time.”

“He never said anything.”

“No. He came to me instead.” Carol’s mouth bent. “He called me eleven times in two weeks. I didn’t pick up. He sent new papers to my house, certified mail. I didn’t sign for them. So this morning he drove over in his good suit and stood on my porch and rang the bell like the Jehovah’s Witnesses.”

“And you let him in?”

“I opened the door. I didn’t let him in.”

The Part Carol Didn’t Want to Say

Martha waited. She had always been good at waiting. Walt died over eleven months, pancreatic, and she’d learned you could sit in a room for six hours without saying a word and it counted as something.

Carol looked at Arthur’s hand. She hadn’t picked it back up.

“I told him no,” she said. “I told him I wasn’t signing. And he stood there with the envelope and he said, ‘Carol, I’m getting married at two,’ and I said, ‘Well, you can’t.’ And I shut the door.”

“Why would you…”

“Because I’m on his insurance.”

It came out of her fast and loud. Then quieter.

“I’m on his teacher’s plan. As his spouse. I have been since the day we got married and nobody ever took me off, because nobody ever finished the divorce. And I’ve got polycystic kidneys. Stage four. I do dialysis three days a week at the place across from the Sheetz.” She touched the gauze on her arm without looking at it. “You know what dialysis costs without insurance? Because I do. I called once. I wrote the number on the back of an envelope and then I threw the envelope away.”

Martha didn’t say anything. She thought about Walt’s last hospital bill, the one with the line item for a box of tissues, \$14.

“If he divorces me, I lose it. That’s it. I’m sixty-two. I don’t qualify for Medicare for three years. I worked at a dry cleaner for nineteen years and they never had a plan.” Carol sniffed hard. “So I shut the door on him. And I stood there in my kitchen, and maybe a minute later I heard something hit the porch. Like a bag of mulch.”

She stopped.

“He went down on my front steps. In his wedding suit. And I’m the one who called 911, and I rode in the back with him, and when they asked who I was I said ‘his wife’ because I am. Legally I am.” She finally looked at Martha. “I’m not proud of the door. But I’m not gonna pretend I’d do it different.”

Martha found she was holding the hem of her dress in both fists, wringing a tight little twist of ivory satin into it. She let go. It stayed wrinkled.

The Jacket on the Hook

The suit jacket was hanging on a hook behind the door, inside a clear plastic bag stamped PATIENT BELONGINGS. They’d cut the shirt off him in the ambulance; Donna said so later. The jacket they’d only pulled off.

Carol saw her looking at it.

“His wallet’s in there. His keys. I didn’t go through it,” Carol said. “I’m not that kind of person.” Then, “I thought about it.”

Martha got up. Her knees cracked. She untied the plastic bag and took the jacket out. Navy, a little shiny at the elbows, the one he wore to the retirement dinner where he got the plaque. He’d told her he’d buy a new one for the wedding and she’d said don’t you dare.

The inside pocket was thick. A manila envelope folded in thirds. A smaller white envelope tucked behind it with her name on the front in his handwriting, which leaned backward, because he was left-handed and the nuns had tried to fix it and failed.

She opened hers first. She’d decide later if that was selfish.

M.

If you’re reading this I’m late, and I have never been late to anything in my life, so you know something’s wrong. I’m fixing a thing I should have fixed in 1999. I’ll explain all of it tonight, I promise, every piece, and if you want to call the whole thing off after you hear it, I’ll understand.

But I’ll be there. Keep the pastor talking. He likes the sound of his own voice anyway.

A.

She read it twice. Then she folded it on the original creases, exactly, and put it in the little satin purse that hung from her wrist on a loop.

“What’s it say,” Carol said.

“That he was coming.”

Carol nodded, like that was about what she’d figured.

Martha held out the manila envelope. “This one’s for you, I think.”

What Burke Never Filed

Carol didn’t take it right away. She wiped her hand on her pants first, a strange formal little gesture, like she was about to sign for a package.

Inside were the divorce papers. Martha could see the top sheet from where she stood: COURT OF COMMON PLEAS, a case number, the words FINAL DECREE in a box. Little yellow sticky arrows down the margins where Carol was supposed to sign. Arthur had flagged every single one.

“I’ve seen these,” Carol said. “These came certified.”

But there was more under them. A stapled packet on heavier paper with a blue logo in the corner. And a check. Carol pulled the check out and held it up to the light from the window, as if it might be fake.

Martha could read it from four feet away. Arthur’s handwriting again.

Pay to the order of: Keystone Health Partners. Twenty-three thousand, four hundred and twelve dollars. In the memo line: Carol, premium thru age 65.

The packet was a private policy. Carol Pruitt, policyholder. Coverage effective the date the divorce was entered. Pre-existing conditions included. Renal care. Dialysis. There was a printout paper-clipped to the back from some website comparing plans, with three of them crossed out in pen and one circled, and in the margin he’d written covers the place by the Sheetz, called to check.

Carol sat with it in her lap for a long time.

The monitor beeped. Somebody laughed at the nurses’ station, a big honking laugh, somebody’s birthday maybe; there’d been a sheet cake out there when Martha came in.

“He didn’t say any of this,” Carol said finally. Her voice had gone thin. “On the porch. He didn’t say one word about this.”

“Did you give him a chance?”

Carol made a noise. Not a laugh this time.

“I said ‘no’ and shut the door. I didn’t even let him get the envelope out.” She pressed the papers flat against her knees with both hands, smoothing them, though they weren’t wrinkled. “Twenty-three thousand dollars. That’s his whole savings, probably. He was always cheap. He reused tinfoil when we were married. He’d wash it.”

“He still does that,” Martha said.

They looked at each other, and something almost happened on Carol’s face, and then she bent over the papers and it was gone.

“You got a pen?”

Martha opened the satin purse. Inside: the letter, a lipstick she hadn’t used, a folded twenty, two Tums, and a pen from the bank. She’d put the pen in that morning without knowing why. Walt used to say she’d bring a pen to her own funeral in case somebody needed to sign for the flowers.

She handed it over.

Carol signed every yellow arrow. Seven of them. She pressed hard enough that Martha could hear the ballpoint scratch through to the page beneath. On the last one she paused, pen up, and Martha thought she might stop.

“For the record,” Carol said, not looking up, “he was a lousy husband. He was always at school. He graded papers at dinner. He forgot my fortieth birthday because of a field trip to Gettysburg.” She signed the last line. “But he was never mean. Not one time. I’d like that to be on the record somewhere.”

“It is,” Martha said.

Visiting Hours

Donna came back with two coffees in paper cups and stopped dead in the doorway. Two women in one room, one of them in a wedding dress, both of them crying a little now, in that dry, embarrassed way of women who were raised not to do it in public.

“Okay,” Donna said. “Okay. I’m gonna count that as one visitor.”

She put the coffees down on the windowsill and checked the bag on the pole again and adjusted something on the monitor, and on her way out she squeezed Martha’s shoulder without saying anything.

Carol stood, slow, a hand on the bedrail. She looked at Arthur for a while.

“I’m gonna go home,” she said. “I’ve got dialysis at six tomorrow and I didn’t eat today.” She held up the envelope. “I’ll get these to the courthouse Monday myself. I’ll hand-carry them. I’m not trusting another Burke.”

“Do you need a ride?”

“My car’s at my house. I came in the ambulance.” Carol thought about it. “I’ll call my sister. She owes me.”

At the door she turned around.

“You should’ve seen him on the porch,” she said. “He had a boutonniere. A little white one. He’d pinned it on crooked and I almost told him.”

Then she was gone, and the door swung shut on its slow arm, and Martha was alone with him.

She pulled the hard plastic chair right up to the bed. The dress made a sound like a grocery bag when she sat. She took his hand, the one Carol had let go of, and it was warm, which surprised her. She’d expected cold. She’d held Walt’s hand at the end, and she supposed her body still thought hospital hands were cold.

Around 11:30 the sheet cake people went home. Around one she dozed off with her cheek against the bedrail and woke with the shape of it pressed into her face.

At 4:52, by the clock above the door, his fingers moved.

She stood up too fast and knocked one of Donna’s coffees off the windowsill. Cold now, thank God. It went all over the floor and splashed the hem of the ivory dress brown, and she didn’t care at all.

His eyes opened. Took a while to find her. The tube was out by then; they’d pulled it around two. His voice came out like sandpaper.

“What time is it.”

Martha looked at the clock. She looked at him, at his flat hair and his crooked mouth and the folded glasses on the tray table.

“You’re late,” she said.

And Arthur Pruitt, who had never been late for anything in his life, started to cry.

—

Would you have signed those papers if you were Carol? Tell me honestly.

For more stories about people underestimated and the surprises that change everything, read the mechanic they thought they could replace, the friend who stood up during an award speech, and Betty’s unexpected phone call.