She Threw His Pie Away. Now the Judge Says My Foster Son Is Hers.

Sarah Jenkins

The pie judge at the county fair held my foster son’s cherry pie up to the tent, said “Nobody’s twelve-year-old makes a crust like that, and nobody fostering five kids for a county check has time to teach one,” and dropped it in the trash. Isaiah unzipped his backpack and handed me the only book he owned.

He’d been in eleven homes before mine, and in March I’d promised his caseworker mine would be the last.

Isaiah is twelve and says maybe twenty words on a good day.

He showed up with a trash bag of clothes and one green hardcover with a library pocket glued inside the back.

Nobody touched that book.

Three nights before the fair he asked if he could use my oven.

He baked at the kitchen table after the other four kids were asleep, rolling the crust out again every time the edge went ragged.

Kaylee, who’s nine and sleeps right off the kitchen, came down at one in the morning to watch him.

“He cut the strips with a ruler,” she said over cereal. “A RULER, Mom.”

So we entered it in the youth division at the Marion County Fair. Cherry, lattice top, entry 31.

The judge was Gail Wojcik.

Twenty-six years she’s run that tent. She wears a laminated badge and writes a column about crusts in the free paper.

She cut a sliver of his, chewed it twice, and set her fork down.

Then she lifted the whole tin up over her head.

“Whose is this?”

Isaiah put his hand up halfway.

“Honey, I’ve been tasting pie for this county since before you were born,” she said. “That’s a bakery crust. Somebody bought it and slid it into a tin.”

“I made it,” Isaiah said.

Three words. To strangers.

She didn’t look at him again. She found me in the crowd instead.

“Are you the mother?”

“His foster mother.”

That’s when she said it, the part about my five kids and the county check, loud enough for the back row.

And she tipped his pie into the trash can by the table leg.

Somebody behind me laughed. One short laugh, like a cough.

A man two tables over was selling honey in bear-shaped bottles, and he kept right on selling it.

Forty people. FORTY.

My face burned. I picked Isaiah’s pie server up off the table because my hands needed something to hold.

He didn’t cry.

He unzipped his backpack.

“It’s from my book,” he said. “Page eighty-eight. I did it exactly.”

He handed it to me. Green cloth, the spine taped in two places, the corners soft as felt.

In seven months I’d never once seen inside it.

The card was still in the back pocket, with nine due dates stamped down it in purple ink.

The last one said JUN 14 1985.

Under it, in neat blue cursive, was the name of whoever never brought it back.

Gail Bacani.

I got my phone out and texted his caseworker, because she’d already said the word county once and I wanted this ON RECORD before she said it again.

Then I walked the book to the judges’ table.

“He’s not lying,” I said. “This is where it came from.”

She took it with two fingers, like it was damp.

“A library book. Sure,” she said. “Kids lie, and the people who take them in for money lie for them. I can call the county on you, you know.”

“Somebody already called them,” I said.

She flipped to page eighty-eight to prove her point.

The margins were full of pencil. More lemon. Eight strips, not six. Use a ruler.

Her thumb stopped moving.

Fern, who’s run the canning table since the eighties and went to high school with her, leaned over her shoulder.

She slid the card out of the pocket and held it up to the light coming through the canvas.

“Gail,” Fern said. “That’s YOUR NAME. That’s you before you got married.”

Gail didn’t answer.

She was looking at Isaiah now, really looking at his chin and his ears and the way he held both backpack straps in his fists, for the first time since she’d lifted his tin over her head like a prize hen at auction.

“Where did you get this,” she said.

Isaiah didn’t look at her.

“My mom gave it to me before they took me,” he said. “She took it from her mom’s house the night she left. She said her mom would NEVER even notice it was gone.”

Gail sat down on the cooler behind the table.

Nobody was laughing now.

“What’s her name?” she said. “His mother. What is her name.”

I didn’t know if I was allowed to tell her. I honestly didn’t.

Then Amit Trivedi came through the tent flap, lanyard still on, his daughter’s cotton candy in one hand and a manila folder in the other.

He’d been at the goat barn. He’d gone to his truck for the file first.

“Dorota, I got your text,” he said. “What happened?”

Gail stood up off the cooler.

“Are you the county?”

“I’m his caseworker, ma’am.”

“Then her name’s in that folder.”

Amit looked at me, then at Isaiah, who was staring at the trash can.

“I can’t READ you anything from his file,” he said.

“I’m not asking you to read it to me,” she said. “I’m asking you to look, and tell me if I’m right.”

Nobody in that tent moved.

Amit set the folder on the judges’ table, right next to the blue ribbon nobody had won yet, and opened the cover.

Isaiah let go of his straps.

The cover

Amit read the first page standing up. He didn’t touch anything but the corner of it.

Gail didn’t wait for him.

“Cara,” she said. “Cara Ann. April ninth, 1990.”

Amit’s finger was on a line halfway down the page, and it stayed there. Then he closed the folder and put his hand flat on top of it.

“Ma’am, I can’t confirm anything in this file.”

“You don’t have to,” Gail said.

Isaiah was still looking at the trash can.

“That’s her,” he said. “That’s my mom.”

Four more words. I counted them because I count them every day.

Fern put the card back in its pocket and closed the book. She set it down in front of Gail very carefully, like it might go off.

Somebody in the back row said “Oh my God” to the person next to them, and not quietly.

I put the pie server down. I picked it back up. There was nowhere in that tent to put my hands.

Gail reached across the table toward Isaiah. She didn’t touch him. She sort of measured the air between them with her palm, the way you’d check a burner.

Then she pulled her hand back and turned to Amit.

“Then he’s coming home with me.”

March

Amit brought him on a Tuesday in March, at eight at night, which is when they always come.

The trash bag was the black kind with the drawstring. Isaiah carried it himself and wouldn’t let Amit take it up the porch steps. The book was under his other arm, not in the bag.

Amit stood in my kitchen doorway and said what he always says. Eleven placements. Quiet kid. No trouble, just quiet.

“Can you keep him?”

“I can keep him,” I said. “This one’s the last. You hear me? Write that down.”

He laughed, because everybody says that. Then he saw I wasn’t laughing, and he wrote something.

I have five right now. The county pays me eight hundred and some dollars a month for each of them, and it does not cover the milk. Gail Wojcik is not the first person to say the word check to me. She’s just the loudest.

The free paper comes on Thursdays. It sits in a stack by the door until it goes in the recycling or under the guinea pig. Gail’s column is on page six, under a photo of her in that laminated badge, holding a fork up like a torch. Crust Corner, it’s called.

Sometime in the summer, one Thursday’s paper was missing page six. I figured the guinea pig got it.

The oven thing I found out about the way I find out about everything in my house. Kaylee, at breakfast.

“He was up till one,” she said. “I was up too. You didn’t even hear the timer.”

I didn’t. I sleep like a dead woman. That’s on me, and I knew it was on me, and I let it go, because he was baking and he’d asked me first, and that was more than he’d asked me for in seven months.

Back in the tent, Gail was still talking to Amit. Not to me. Not to Isaiah.

“I’m his blood. Blood goes first. I know how it works, I’ve read about it.”

Amit looked at me over the top of her head.

“Dorota,” he said. “Can I talk to you outside for a second?”

The honey stand

We went out the flap and stood by the man with the bear bottles. He was still selling. He held one up at me like I might want one.

Amit’s daughter Sydney was on a hay bale by the tent, working on the cotton candy. He told her five minutes. She held up five fingers without looking at him.

“She can petition,” Amit said. “Relatives get looked at first. That’s not me, that’s the law.”

“She threw his pie in the garbage, Amit.”

“I know.”

“In front of forty people.”

“I know. I’m telling you what she can do Monday morning.” He rubbed his eyebrow with the corner of the folder. “And I’m telling you a judge would look at the whole file.”

“What’s in the whole file?”

He didn’t answer for long enough that the honey man sold two bottles.

“When they took him the first time, in 2020, the county ran a relative search. Mother’s side, father’s side. That’s standard. It’s in the court record, and you’re his placement, so you’re allowed to know it.”

“And?”

“And they found a maternal grandmother in Salem. They called the number they had.”

He opened the folder just far enough for me to see one page. A box was checked near the bottom. Relative declined placement. Under it somebody had typed a line in quotation marks.

I had the pie server in my back pocket. I don’t know when I put it there.

“It was a woman,” Amit said. “She didn’t ask his name. She didn’t ask how old he was.”

“What did she say?”

He closed the folder.

“She said, ‘I don’t have a daughter.’ Then she hung up.”

The cooler

I went back in before he could stop me. That’s the one thing I’d take back if I got one.

Gail was at the table with the book open again, showing the margins to a woman from the 4-H booth. Proud now. Like she’d baked the thing herself.

“My own notes,” she was saying. “Thirty, forty years ago.”

“Forty-one,” I said.

She looked up.

“The county called you in 2020,” I said. “They told you that you had a grandson in foster care. You said you didn’t have a daughter and you hung up the phone.”

The 4-H woman took a step back.

Gail didn’t blink. She laughed, one short laugh, the same as the one behind me earlier.

“I’d remember a call like that, sweetheart.”

She turned to the room. To the room, not to me.

“You see what I said? They’ll say anything. She’ll say anything to keep that check coming.” She pointed the book at Amit, who’d come in behind me. “Is that in your file? Go ahead. Tell them.”

Amit’s face didn’t do anything. “Ma’am, I can’t discuss the file.”

“There you go,” Gail said.

And people nodded. A man by the tent pole nodded. Twenty-six years she’d run that tent, and I’d lived in this county nine.

Fern was wiping her hands on a dish towel from the canning table. She didn’t look up from it.

“Gail,” she said. “I was at your kitchen table the week after Cara left. You poured me coffee and you said that exact sentence. I don’t have a daughter. I remember because you said it twice.”

“Fern, stay out of this.”

“I’ve stayed out of it eighteen years,” Fern said. “That’s plenty.”

Gail opened her mouth at Fern, and that’s when I turned around for Isaiah.

He wasn’t by the trash can.

The tent flap was still moving.

Page six

He was at the van. It’s a fifteen-passenger with a dent in the slider, and he was sitting on the back bumper with his backpack in his lap.

I sat down next to him. The bumper went down an inch.

“You heard me,” I said.

He nodded.

“I shouldn’t have said it in there. I’m sorry.”

He didn’t say anything. He unzipped the backpack and took the book out again, and this time he didn’t hand it to me. He opened the front cover and pulled a folded piece of newsprint out from under the endpaper, where the glue had let go.

Page six. Crust Corner. Gail with her fork up.

He’d cut it out with my kitchen scissors. I could tell by the edge. They’ve got a nick in them that leaves a little tooth every few inches.

Above her photo, in pencil, in his square capitals, it said GRANDMA GAIL.

The column was about youth pie. I read it there on the bumper, with the sun coming off the van window. She’d written that in twenty-six years of judging she had never tasted a youth entry she believed a child made alone. And that the day she did, she’d know it in one bite.

“My mom said she wouldn’t notice a book,” Isaiah said. “But she’d know her own pie. If she tasted it she’d know it was hers.”

“Is that why you wanted to enter it?”

“I wanted her to taste it first. Before she knew who.”

He turned the clipping over. On the back he’d copied out the margin notes in his own hand. More lemon. Eight strips, not six. Use a ruler. Like a list you’d take to the store.

“I did it exactly,” he said.

“I know you did, baby.”

“She chewed it twice.”

He folded the clipping back along its creases and slid it under the endpaper and pressed it flat with his thumb, the way you’d press down a stamp.

“Do I have to go live with her now?”

Entry 31

When we came back in, Gail was sitting on the cooler again with Amit standing over her, and she was the one talking.

“Monday morning. I’ll be at the county office when they unlock the door. I own my house outright. I’ve got a guest room, I’ve got a church. I don’t have five other kids I’m farming for money. He came looking for me, you heard him. A boy doesn’t bake his grandmother’s pie by accident.”

She saw us and stood up.

“There he is. Honey, come here.”

Isaiah stayed next to me. He had both straps again.

I put the clipping on the judges’ table, on top of the folder, GRANDMA GAIL side up.

“He did come looking for you,” I said. “So come to my kitchen. Saturdays. Taste what he makes. Sit at my table with my five kids and my county check.”

Somebody in the crowd made a noise. Fern put her towel down.

Gail looked at the clipping. Then at me.

“I’m not setting foot in a house like that,” she said. “You don’t get to make terms. He comes to me. He comes to my house and he stays at my house, and when Cara hears I’ve got him she can walk up my porch steps and knock like anybody else. That’s how this goes. She took my book. She can come get her boy off my porch.”

Nobody said anything.

Amit had his pen out. He was writing on the inside of the folder cover, small.

“What are you writing?” Gail said.

“Contact notes, ma’am. I write down what happens at a contact.”

“Then write this.” She pointed at me. “Write that she lets them run that oven at one in the morning with nobody awake but a nine-year-old. The little girl told her so. Put that in your notes.”

Amit looked at me.

That was mine to stop. All I had to do was say it was a lie, and it wasn’t one.

“Write it,” I said.

He wrote it.

Then he kept writing. “I’m also noting that the maternal grandmother was offered weekly contact in the foster home today, and declined.”

“I did not decline anything.”

“You did, Gail,” Fern said. “Just now. Forty people heard you.”

“Fern, so help me God.”

“Sit down before you fall down.”

Gail didn’t sit. She picked the green book up off the table and held it flat against her blouse.

“This is mine,” she said. “My name’s on it.”

“It belongs to the library,” I said. “Your name’s just on it.”

Isaiah put out his hand. He didn’t say anything. He held it out flat across the table, palm up, the way you do when a kid’s taken something off your dresser and you’re waiting.

She held on a second longer. Then she put the book in his hand.

He zipped it into his backpack and walked out of the tent ahead of me.

The circulation desk

The home visit was two weeks later. A woman from licensing I’d never met opened my oven and looked inside it like something might be in there. The note stays in my file for two years. Amit said that’s just how it is.

Nobody filed anything that Monday. Or the one after.

The youth ribbon went to a peach pie. Gail’s column skipped a Thursday and came back about pumpkin.

On a Saturday I drove Isaiah to the Marion County Library with the green book on the seat between us.

The woman at the desk had a badge that said Paulina. She looked for a barcode, and there wasn’t one. Then she pulled the card out of the back pocket and laughed out loud.

“Nineteen eighty-five,” she said. “We don’t even have that system anymore.”

The replacement fee was thirty-four dollars. I paid it out of the grocery envelope.

Paulina dug an old rubber stamp out of a drawer that said WITHDRAWN. She inked it on a pad that was mostly dry and pressed it purple under JUN 14 1985, under Gail Bacani. Then she held out a pen.

“It’s yours now,” she said. “You want to sign for it?”

Isaiah took the pen.

He wrote his name under hers in his square capitals, slow, like he was cutting strips.

If Isaiah got to you, send this to somebody who’s ever opened their kitchen to a kid carrying a trash bag.

For more family secrets and courtroom-sized twists, read the fight over a frozen $42,000 and the brother who claimed Mom signed away her house.