Reverend Ralph Put My Name in His Jacket Pocket

Maya Lin

Our minister caught my mom by the coat rack after Thursday youth night and told her I’d be “more comfortable elsewhere,” with me right beside her zipping my jacket.

He didn’t know my backpack already held his church’s budget, with $3,500 for kids like me sitting untouched on one line.

Or that I’d be the one standing up that Saturday.

I’m twelve, I have Down syndrome, and I was close enough to smell the cherry cough drop in his cheek.

Mom’s hand clamped down on my shoulder.

“Ralph,” she said. “He can hear you.”

“I know, Janine,” Reverend Ralph said. “That’s why I’m keeping my voice down.”

He said it the way you’d tell somebody their tire looked low.

Here’s what he never bothered to find out about me.

I keep score of everything in a red spiral notebook I bought with my own dollar.

Mom has burned thirty-eight pancakes since March. She says it’s nine.

The notebook doesn’t lie, and neither do I.

My dad moved out the year I turned four, so it’s me and Mom and the notebook, and the notebook takes up the least room.

We’d gone to Cedar Hollow Bible Church for six years.

Thursday nights were the best part of my whole week.

Games, then snack, then a Bible story, then more games if Mrs. Leona was in a good mood.

I only wanted one thing out of it.

Capture the flag with the big kids, and to make it across the line once without getting tagged.

The first weird thing happened sixteen days before the coat rack.

Mrs. Leona crouched down by me and said, “Eli, sweetie, during games you’re going to sit out in the hallway now.”

There was one folding chair out there, next to the water fountain.

Just one.

I told Mom at dinner.

She called Mrs. Leona from the bathroom so I wouldn’t hear.

I heard anyway. The fan in there has been broken since summer.

Mrs. Leona told her the games had gotten rough and the church had to think about its insurance.

Mom bought it.

Honestly, so did I. I figured big kids are heavy.

The next Thursday I got home and didn’t touch my grilled cheese.

“What’s going on, bud?” Mom said.

“Nobody chose me,” I said.

“Not one team. Mrs. Leona told me I could KEEP SCORE.”

Mom put the spatula down on the stove and left it there.

I already keep score. I wanted to be on the score.

That night she typed an email to Reverend Ralph, deleted it four times, and finally hit send.

He answered before breakfast.

“We love Eli. Leona is stretched thin with the volunteers she has.”

Twelve words. I counted.

That Saturday we were at the laundromat by our apartment when Gemma’s mom came in hugging a basket of towels.

Gemma’s in my grade.

She’s the only kid in gym who passes me the ball on purpose.

Mom asked her mom, Talia, how Thursday nights were going for Gemma.

Talia stopped folding a towel halfway.

“Janine,” she said. “Ask Gemma about last Thursday. Don’t ask me. Ask her.”

So I asked her myself.

Gemma was sitting on top of a dryer, which you’re not supposed to do.

She said Mrs. Leona moved my chair behind the snack table, by the trash cans.

She said Mrs. Leona told everybody, “Eli gets tired, so we let him rest.”

I don’t get tired. I can do forty jumping jacks without stopping.

I’ve counted.

Then Gemma told the worst part, and she told it to her sneakers.

“Some of the boys say Eli doesn’t COUNT,” she said.

“Mrs. Leona heard them. She laughed and said okay, okay, settle down.”

The dryer under her buzzed.

Mom stood there holding a sock that wasn’t even ours.

I didn’t cry. I got mad, and when I’m mad I make a list.

Mom pulled out her phone to dial Ralph’s office.

“Don’t,” I said. “If you call, they’ll just be nice on the phone. Let’s count instead.”

She looked at me a good while.

Then she put the phone away.

For five days, that’s what we did.

We went to NINE families. Mom drove. I knocked.

Every parent let me write in my notebook, and Mom asked before she turned on her phone’s recorder.

My tally said I’d been sent to the hallway seven Thursdays straight.

It said I’d been left off a team thirteen times.

Thirteen.

One dad remembered the exact night, because his son got in the car and asked why Eli was “the bench.”

Mom printed the church’s welcome page.

Across the top it said EVERY CHILD BELONGS HERE, over a picture of kids in a circle holding hands.

I looked for me in the circle.

I wasn’t there, but it was a stock photo, so that one’s fair.

Then Mom found the budget sheet from the spring members’ meeting, folded up in her Bible.

One line said $3,500 ACCESSIBILITY GRANT.

The column next to it, the one for what they’d spent, said ZERO.

“Zero,” Mom said.

“Zero,” I said.

I wrote it down and drew a box around it, then another box around the box.

Then came Thursday, and the coat rack.

“I think everyone would be more COMFORTABLE,” Reverend Ralph said, “if Eli found a place that’s better set up for him.”

He patted my head on the word him. I’m twelve.

I looked up at Mom.

“Did I mess something up?” I said.

She didn’t answer me.

She was staring at Reverend Ralph like she was memorizing his face for later.

In the car I opened the notebook and started a new page.

Times they said it in front of me: one.

One is plenty.

That Saturday evening I walked in carrying MY RED NOTEBOOK AND MOM’S BLUE BINDER, every tally, every recording written out, and the budget sheet with the box around zero.

In the lobby my legs quit and I ended up on the carpet by the coffee station.

I didn’t plan that. They just went.

Mom crouched in front of me.

“We can go home,” she said. “Nobody would blame you, Eli.”

“I would,” I said.

I took a butterscotch from the bowl by the coffee and got back up.

We sat in the last pew.

I counted the ceiling lights. Fourteen. One was out.

When the announcements started, I stood.

Mom started to get up with me.

I put my hand on her arm, and she sat back down.

“Hi,” I said. “Most of you know me. I’m the kid in the hallway now.”

A few people laughed, the nice kind.

“Reverend Ralph told my mom I’d be more comfortable elsewhere,” I said.

“So I counted how comfortable I’ve been.”

I opened the notebook to the first page.

Reverend Ralph’s wife got hold of his elbow.

Mrs. Leona slipped out of her pew and hurried toward the coatroom.

Then Talia shot up in the fifth row with a sheet of paper in her fist.

“Eli, honey, hold on,” she said.

“I found this in the volunteer folder last night. DON’T READ YOURS YET.”

She came up the aisle and laid a printed email on top of my notebook.

My name was in the subject line.

It was dated July ninth, back before anybody ever set a chair out by the water fountain.

The last pew

I read the top part first, because that’s where emails keep the boring stuff.

From: Ralph Gaddis. To: Leona. July 9. Subject: Eli.

Under that there were only a few lines.

The whole church had turned around in their pews to look at us, and I didn’t know what else you’re supposed to do with a paper in church, so I read it out loud.

“No,” I read. “Eli sits in the hallway during games from now on. Be gentle about it. His mother will see he’d be more comfortable elsewhere. R.”

More comfortable elsewhere.

He’d had it ready since July, like a casserole in the freezer.

Mom made the noise she makes when she stubs her toe and won’t swear in front of me.

Up front, Reverend Ralph took his wife’s hand off his elbow, set it back on her own knee like a library book he was returning, and came down off the platform.

He walked the aisle slow.

He’s sixty-four, but he moves fine when the potluck line opens, so the slow was for us.

He smiled the whole way, and the heads turned with him like the church was one big sunflower.

I shut my notebook on the email. My notebook is mine.

He stopped at the end of our pew and held his hand out, palm up.

“May I, son?” he said.

I’m not his son.

I had a dad four whole years, and that’s the number I’ve got.

He didn’t wait for an answer.

He slid the email out from between my pages like a bookmark, read it without moving his lips, folded it in half and in half again, and tucked it inside his jacket.

Then he patted the pocket twice, the way you pat a dog that didn’t bark.

A hundred and twelve, praise God

He walked back up front without hurrying, which is how you can tell a grown-up thinks he’s winning.

Most of what I know about Reverend Ralph is numbers.

He’s been the minister at Cedar Hollow since before I was born.

He keeps cherry cough drops in his jacket for kids who sit still.

In six years I have gotten two.

Every Saturday after announcements he tells us how many came.

“A hundred and twelve tonight, praise God.”

The first time I checked him, I got a hundred and six.

The next week he said ninety-eight and I got ninety-one.

He’s never once been under.

He rounds up like the number is a fish he caught.

Then he looks at the ceiling and says, “And one of these Saturdays we’ll get that light fixed,” and everybody laughs like they haven’t heard it a hundred times.

Eighty-some. I’m still counting.

Mrs. Leona is the opposite of numbers.

She hugs too long and calls everybody sweetie, even the dads.

Last April, on a Thursday, I asked her my question by the snack table with my coat already on.

I asked it every week.

“Can I play with the big kids next time?”

Most weeks she said, “We’ll see, sweetie.”

That night she crouched down so we were the same height and fixed my zipper, which wasn’t stuck.

“I’m working on it, Eli,” she said. “I asked. I’m still asking.”

She gave me a butterscotch out of her sweater pocket.

In the notebook I had a long row of checks under ASKED.

Next to the last one I wrote MAYBE.

I didn’t need to be good at capture the flag.

I just wanted one Thursday where somebody yelled my name because they needed me to run.

Up front, Reverend Ralph climbed the two steps to the pulpit, and his wife moved her purse off the step so he could get by.

Mrs. Leona’s spot in row three was still empty, and her coat was gone.

His hand on my head

He tapped the microphone, the way he does when it’s going to be long.

“Church family,” he said. “Most of you know Eli.”

Some people nodded at me.

A lady in a green sweater waved, like I was on a float in a parade.

“We love Eli,” he said.

“And some of you just heard him read part of a private note between me and our youth leader. I’m not going to hide from that. I’m a lot of things, but I’m not a man who hides.”

He breathed into the microphone so we could all hear him do it.

“Back in July, Leona came to me with a question. Was Eli safe in those games, with bigger boys knocking each other down? I prayed on it, and my answer was no. That’s the no you heard.”

A man with a mustache in the second row said, “Amen.”

“Did I put it clumsily? I did,” Ralph said.

“Eli, if it hurt you, I’m sorry it hurt you.”

Mom calls that kind of sorry a coupon.

It looks like money until you try to buy something with it.

Talia was still in the aisle.

“Ralph, I saw July and Eli’s name and I got in my car,” she said.

“You wrote ‘his mother will see.’ That’s not about safety, that’s about—”

“I did write it, Talia, and I’ve asked the Lord’s forgiveness for the wording,” he said.

“Now you’re blocking the aisle, and folks behind you can’t see.”

Talia looked at Mom.

I’d asked Mom to stay sitting, so she stayed sitting, and Talia walked back to the fifth row slow, like somebody leaving a store without buying anything.

I opened my notebook, because that was the plan, and the plan was all I had.

“Seven Thursdays in the hallway,” I said. I’m loud.

Mom says I came out loud.

“Seven Thursdays you were safe,” Ralph said.

“Thirteen times nobody chose me.”

“Thirteen nights nobody got hurt.”

He was taking my numbers out of my notebook and putting them in his own pocket, same as the email.

“The thirty-five hundred dollars for kids like me is zero,” I said.

Ralph smiled at me like I’d said something cute at a restaurant.

“That’s grown-up business, buddy, and it takes careful prayer,” he said.

“So let’s do the grown-up thing right now. Let’s pray for Eli.”

He came all the way down the aisle again.

Everybody bowed, because when a minister says pray, your neck just goes.

He put his hand on top of my head.

It was heavy and warm and smelled like cherry.

He prayed for my heart. He prayed for my patience.

He prayed I’d find “a place where Eli can truly flourish,” and a bunch of people said “Mm,” like they’d tasted something good.

“I’m not sick,” I said, right into the middle of it.

“Amen,” Reverend Ralph said, louder than me.

Then he walked back up to the pulpit and smiled out at all of us.

“A hundred and twelve tonight,” he said. “Praise God.”

Lemon bars

By Tuesday Mom still hadn’t said one word about Saturday.

Mom talks during movies. Mom talks to the microwave.

At 6:40 somebody knocked on our apartment door.

It was Reverend Ralph and Mrs. Gaddis, with a pan of lemon bars under plastic wrap.

She held the pan with both hands like it was hot.

Lemon bars don’t come hot.

Mom let them in, because Mom lets everybody in.

She’d let in a raccoon if it knocked.

We have one table. My notebook was on it.

Ralph sat down across from it and didn’t look at it once, which is how you look at something.

“Eli, buddy,” he said, “would you give us grown-ups a few minutes?”

I went into my room and shut the door loud.

Then I went across the hall into the bathroom, shut that door quiet, and sat on the edge of the tub under the fan that’s been broken since summer.

You can hear the whole kitchen through that fan.

It’s the best thing in our apartment.

“Here’s what I’m proposing,” Ralph said.

“Thursday, Eli’s back in the games. My wife will be his buddy, personally.”

“I’m very quick on my feet,” Mrs. Gaddis said.

She’d taken our stairs one at a time.

“The funds will be put to work, and we’ll pray on exactly how,” Ralph said.

“And Saturday, Eli stands up for one minute and helps us put this behind us. I’ll write the words, so it’s easy on him. And the notebook goes in a drawer. Nobody heals keeping score.”

“He’s twelve, Ralph. It’s a notebook.”

“Think about who it’s keeping score on, Janine.”

Nobody said anything. The fridge hummed.

Somebody peeled the plastic off the lemon bars.

“Six years,” Mrs. Gaddis said.

“When his daddy left, who brought you a casserole every Thursday for a month? That was Leona. That was us.”

“I know who it was,” Mom said.

“So let us take care of him,” Ralph said.

I held on to the edge of the tub.

“Okay,” Mom said.

One word, through a broken fan.

After they left, she knocked on my bedroom door, and I got back in there just in time to be in the right room.

“You get to play Thursday, bud,” she said. “That’s what you wanted.”

“I wanted them to want me,” I said.

“Not you saying okay to him.”

“You heard.”

“The fan’s broken.”

She sat on the end of my bed and wiped her face with her wrist.

“It’s our church, Eli. They’re the people who came. Ralph even signed the card.”

“A card,” I said.

“I can’t burn down the only house we’ve got.”

I went to the kitchen, got my notebook off the table, put it in my backpack and zipped it all the way to the end.

I didn’t open it again all week. Not even for the pancakes.

Forty words

Thursday Mrs. Gaddis met us at the church door in white sneakers so new they still had the little plastic tag on the lace.

Mrs. Leona was at the snack table pouring juice.

She looked at the juice the whole time I was in the room.

When it was time for capture the flag, the tall boy from eighth grade was red captain and Gemma was blue.

Before anybody could pick, Mrs. Leona blew the whistle and said, “Eli and Mrs. Gaddis are on red.”

“We have to take his babysitter too?” the tall boy said.

Some boys laughed. Mrs. Leona didn’t, this time.

She just blew the whistle again.

Mrs. Gaddis took my hand.

Running holding hands with a sixty-something lady is a three-legged race where one of the legs wants to sit down.

I got tagged in four seconds. Four.

Gemma tagged me, and she looked sorry about it.

Then Mrs. Gaddis, breathing like our vacuum cleaner, walked me out to the hallway, to the folding chair by the water fountain.

“Let’s rest a minute,” she said. “Eli gets tired.”

“You got tired,” I said.

She opened her mouth and shut it.

There was only one chair, so she sat down on the floor next to it in her new white sneakers, and she didn’t say anything else the whole game.

The gym door was propped open.

I could hear them in there yelling names. None of them were mine.

At pickup Reverend Ralph was by the coat rack with an envelope.

“For Saturday,” he said, and handed it to Mom, not me.

“Short and sweet. Forty words. You can count them if you want, Eli.”

He winked. He used my counting on me like it was his.

Mom opened it right there, and I read it upside down, which I’m good at.

*I’m sorry I upset my church family last Saturday.

Reverend Ralph and Mrs. Leona have always loved me and kept me safe.

I am so happy to be back on Thursdays.

Thank you all for praying for me every week.*

Forty. He wasn’t lying about that one.

“Good game, champ?” Ralph said.

Behind him Mrs. Gaddis started to say something.

He patted her arm and she stopped.

“Thank you, Ralph,” Mom said.

She put the envelope in her purse, next to the coupons, and snapped it shut.

Pancake thirty-nine

Friday is breakfast for dinner. Friday always is.

Mom had the griddle going.

The envelope was on the table by the syrup, and she kept glancing at it like it might tip over.

“Want to practice it once, bud?” she said.

“Just to hear it out loud?”

“No.”

“Eli.”

“Fine.”

I got my backpack.

If I had to say his forty words, I didn’t want my numbers in the same building.

I was going to tear the tally pages out and put them in the drawer myself, so at least nobody else got to.

I opened the notebook to the first page.

There was a sheet of paper in it, flat between my first two pages, right where I’d shut the notebook when he came down the aisle.

It was creased from a week in my backpack.

At the bottom it said Page 2 of 2.

He’d slid out one sheet. There had been two.

From: Leona. To: Ralph Gaddis. July 9, 7:42 a.m. Subject: Eli.

I read it out loud, because when it matters I read everything out loud.

“Ralph, the accessibility money came in this morning. Can we use some of it for a helper on Thursdays, so Eli can finally play capture the flag with the big kids? He asks me every single week. I would love to tell him yes. Leona.”

Forty-four words. Plus her name.

The griddle started to smoke. Mom didn’t flip anything.

She came over with the spatula still in her hand, took the page, read it twice, and sat down on the kitchen floor by the stove with the spatula across her knees.

“She asked him,” Mom said. “Leona asked him for you. In July.”

“And he said no,” I said. “That’s the no.”

“He stood there in front of all those people and said she was scared you’d get hurt.”

She looked at the envelope on the table.

“And I said okay to him. In our kitchen.”

The pancake was black by then. Thirty-nine. I’d write it down later.

I turned off the burner, because somebody had to, and sat on the floor next to her.

“You tell me what you want, bud,” she said.

“Whatever it is. I’ll drive.”

“Saturday,” I said. “Same pew.”

“He’ll have the microphone again.”

“He keeps his voice down,” I said. “I don’t.”

A hundred and nine

On Saturday we sat in the last pew. Fourteen lights. One out. Same one.

Mrs. Leona was back in row three by herself, with her coat buttoned, like she might need to leave fast again.

Talia and Gemma were in the fifth row.

Gemma turned around and gave me a thumbs-up so small only I could see it.

Reverend Ralph did the food drive and the choir schedule.

Then he looked at the ceiling.

“A hundred and nine tonight, praise God,” he said.

“And Eli has asked to share a few words. Come on up, buddy.”

I hadn’t asked. But I went.

I walked all the way up the aisle this time, past the mustache man, past Mrs. Leona, to the bottom of the platform steps.

Mom stayed in the last pew because I asked her to.

She held her purse in her lap with both hands.

Ralph bent down and held the microphone out to me.

Even bending, he made it look like a favor.

“I’m loud,” I said, and didn’t take it.

I took the card out of my pocket and read the first line exactly.

“I’m sorry I upset my church family last Saturday.”

Ralph nodded with his eyes closed, like it was music.

“That’s his,” I said.

“It’s forty words. He wrote it. Here’s forty-four Mrs. Leona wrote.”

I unfolded page two and read it, every word, slow.

When I got to He asks me every single week, I looked at row three.

When I finished, nobody coughed. In church somebody always coughs.

Ralph reached for the paper. I stepped back.

“It was in my notebook,” I said. “Mrs. Leona, did you write it?”

She stood in her buttoned coat. Her face had already started.

“I wrote it,” she said.

“I asked him twice. He said no, and then he told me to put you in the hallway, gentle, and I did it, because he’s the pastor and I’ve done what he told me for twenty-one years.”

She grabbed the pew in front of her.

“And when those boys said you don’t count, I laughed. God forgive me. I laughed so they’d keep liking me.”

She sat down hard and cried into her coat sleeve like a little kid.

“All right,” Ralph said into the microphone. “All right, folks. Let’s be adults.”

He was still smiling, but only with the bottom half.

“Leona asked me for thirty-five hundred dollars that belongs to every person in this room. I said no because somebody has to be careful with it. Thirty-five hundred dollars, so one boy who, let’s be honest with each other, is never going to keep up with those kids, can get dragged around a gym by the hand? Some of you have asked me for two years about these lights.” He pointed up.

“There’s one out right now. I made a call. I tried to make it kindly. And I am not going to stand in my own pulpit and apologize for being careful with your money.”

“Thirteen work,” I said.

Somebody laughed. Then a few more. Not the nice kind.

The kind at him.

“You can see fine,” I said.

Ralph’s face went the color of his cough drops.

I turned around so I was facing everybody.

A hundred and nine, if he’d told the truth for once.

“If you want me in the hallway, stay sitting,” I said.

“If you want me on a team, stand up.”

Ralph came down the steps, sat in the front pew next to his wife and folded his arms, like a kid who picked his own time-out.

Then he put one hand on her shoulder and left it there.

For a second nobody moved, and I thought, okay, sometimes the numbers don’t come out.

Then Gemma stood in the fifth row.

“One,” I said.

Talia. “Two.”

Then a dad from the nine families, and his wife, and then a whole pew at once, so I had to count fast.

Kids stood on the pews, which you’re not supposed to do.

The tall boy stood because his mom pulled him up by the sleeve, which still counts.

Mrs. Leona stood with her face wet.

Mom stood in the last pew with her purse against her chest.

I counted the whole way, out loud.

When I got to the front row I was at a hundred and seven.

Mrs. Gaddis was still sitting, with Ralph’s hand on her shoulder.

She picked his hand up, set it back on his own knee like a library book she was returning, and stood up.

“A hundred and eight,” I said.

Then I looked at Ralph. “You said a hundred and nine.”

He stood up then, and it wasn’t to be counted.

“If this is what you want,” he said, louder than I’d ever heard him, “you can find yourselves another minister.”

He waited. Nobody sat down.

“Still a hundred and eight,” I said.

He went up the steps, set the microphone on the pulpit with a thump that came out of every speaker, and walked out a side door by the choir.

It has one of those slow arms on top, so it couldn’t slam.

We all had to watch it close the whole way.

Two flags, $39.98

His letter came on Monday. Five lines.

Talia read it to Mom on speakerphone, and Mom made her read the last line twice.

He meant it. Or he couldn’t figure out how to un-mean it in front of everybody, which with Reverend Ralph is the same thing.

The members took his letter the next Saturday after service, ninety-four to two. I counted.

Talia got ninety-five, and we argued about it by the coffee station, and I was right, because she counted a coat.

On Tuesday a man with a long pole took the letters off the sign out front.

REV RALPH GADDIS went into a cardboard box one letter at a time.

The thirty-five hundred dollars went where Mrs. Leona asked for it to go in July.

Talia runs Thursdays now, with a second grown-up every week, paid, so nobody is ever stretched thin again.

The first receipt she showed me was for two new flags, one red, one blue. $39.98.

“Write it down,” she said.

I did. ACCESSIBILITY GRANT. SPENT: $39.98. I’m going to need a bigger box.

That Thursday Mrs. Leona came before games, with her purse, not to stay.

She crouched down in front of me by the water fountain, where the chair used to be, with all the big boys standing right there.

“I laughed when they said you didn’t count,” she said.

“That was wrong. You count, Eli. I’m sorry.”

Then she took the youth room key off her ring, twenty-one years on that ring, handed it to Talia, and walked out to her car.

She didn’t hug anybody too long. She didn’t hug anybody.

Gemma was captain for blue.

She picked me first, before anybody even got their hands up.

“Eli,” she said, like it was obvious.

I went down the left side, past the snack table and the trash cans.

Nobody guards the trash cans.

I had seven Thursdays sitting there to figure that out.

The red flag was on the stage.

I grabbed it, turned around, and ran.

“Go, Eli,” somebody yelled, and then everybody was yelling it, my name, over and over, because they needed me to run.

The tall boy came at me from the side.

Gemma got in his way, legal.

His fingers caught my sleeve and slid off.

I crossed the line.

Eleven seconds. I counted the whole way.

Gemma jumped on me, and then about six more jumped on her, and I was at the bottom of a pile laughing so hard I couldn’t get air.

Mom was in the gym doorway with both hands over her mouth, crying the good kind.

“Winner keeps the flag till next week,” Talia said.

Reverend Ralph was by the coat rack when I went for my jacket.

It was his last week with keys.

He was carrying a box out of his office with a plant in it, a framed picture, and a bag of cherry cough drops on top.

He looked at the flag in my hand. He kept his voice down.

“Eli. Son,” he said.

“I’d like us to part as friends. Can I have one more chance?”

I zipped my jacket all the way up.

“One is plenty,” I said.

Then I walked past him and out to Mom’s car with the flag.

If Eli got to you, pass this along to someone who’s ever been handed the chair in the hallway.

For more family secrets and people discovering they’ve been underestimated, read My Mother-in-Law Pocketed My Dead Teacher’s Key and Patted It Twice and My Father Told The Agent My House Was Empty. You can also follow another tense family reckoning in My Former Husband Kept A Key To My Empty House.