My Stepmother Picked Paint Colors While I Stacked Her Chairs

Daniel Foster

One rubber foot was missing from a folding chair, and it scraped my concrete every time I moved it.

That was what I concentrated on after my graduation party. Not Dad’s face. Not the laughter. The chair.

Friday, May 15, was supposed to celebrate my honors degree in computer science from Purdue. Five years, including a co-op year at a seed company in Iowa, and three job offers. At twenty-three, I still wanted my father to ask which one I liked.

Instead, I cooked.

Kelly, my stepmother of nine years, hosted 34 people in our machine shed outside Hastings. At about four, she announced that the family was leaving for a $615,000 house in Cedar Bluff. I wasn’t invited.

Marissa, nineteen, wanted her own bathroom. Carl, seventeen, joked about my future accommodations. Dad rearranged beer in the cooler.

I’d lived on that farm since eleven.

“You stayed here, hon. Staying isn’t owning,” Kelly said.

Mrs. Pruitt nodded over her pickle.

They knew January’s buyer, Bluestem Land Holdings LLC, had paid $486,000 cash for the farmhouse and 40 acres. They knew their lease-back ended May 25.

They didn’t know Bluestem belonged to me.

HaulSlot, the grain-delivery scheduling app I’d built in my second year, had brought three co-op licenses, investors, and a $26,000,000 acquisition offer from Kansas City. The money I’d already earned let me buy the farm before foreclosure.

Dad’s seven missed payments were $2,140 apiece. I’d found the $14,980 problem in a drawer while hunting a screwdriver.

By dusk, everyone had gone. I counted twenty-two chairs twice while Dad and Kelly compared paint chips inside.

At 9:40, my attorney, Marla Voss, texted about serving papers at seven. I approved.

Then she asked whether every occupant should be named.

Kelly kissed a paint sample and stuck it on the refrigerator.

I sent my answer.

“Every one. Kelly first.”

Seven on the Porch

I slid my phone into my pocket, shut the shed lights off, and walked across the yard.

Inside, Kelly held a gray sample against the refrigerator.

“Which do you like?” she said.

I pointed at neither.

“I’m going to bed.”

Dad lifted his head as if he might follow me. Then Kelly asked whether the living room should have an accent wall, and he stayed where he was.

Upstairs, I sat on the edge of my bed without taking my shoes off. My desk still had the groove Carl had cut into it while borrowing my pocketknife. The router blinked in the hall. Apparently I could be trusted to keep everybody connected, just not included.

I texted Marla one more instruction: any new lease would be for Glenn Kowalczyk alone. No other residents without my written permission.

She answered that she would prepare it, but I should understand something before I offered it.

My father could refuse.

I put the phone down. That possibility kept me awake longer than Kelly did.

At seven Saturday morning, the knock came while I was pouring coffee.

Kelly opened the front door in slippers. The server confirmed her name, handed her the papers, and explained what they were. There was no shouting, no audience on the lawn. Just a woman holding the end of an arrangement she had signed four months earlier.

She shut the door and brought the notice into the kitchen.

“Glenn. This says we have to surrender possession.”

Dad came in from the hallway.

“On the twenty-fifth,” he said. “That’s the date.”

“Then why send this? We know the date.”

She turned a page. Her finger stopped.

“Kurt?”

I set my cup down.

“Bluestem is mine.”

She looked at Dad. He looked at me.

For once, neither could appoint the other person responsible for answering.

“I bought the farm in January,” I said.

Kelly pulled out a chair but didn’t sit.

“You don’t have that kind of money.”

“I paid the purchase price.”

“From that computer thing?”

“HaulSlot.”

Dad rubbed his mouth.

“The elevator program?”

I nodded.

He knew the name. That hurt in a way I hadn’t prepared for. He knew enough to recognize the product, but hadn’t asked his son about it.

Kelly put the notice against my chest.

“Fine. Then this is unnecessary. You can cancel it.”

I took the paper before it fell.

“No.”

“Your father and I are buying a house. We don’t need a threat on our way out.”

Dad closed his eyes.

I hadn’t known their finances after the sale. I’d bought the property through Marla; I hadn’t purchased permission to rummage through his checking account.

But his hand gripped the back of that chair.

“Glenn?” Kelly said.

He opened his eyes.

“There isn’t money from the sale.”

She stared at him.

“The bank got it,” he said. “The payoff and the costs took everything.”

“The down payment.”

“There isn’t one.”

Kelly sat down then.

Outside, a bird kept hitting the same three notes. I wanted somebody to unplug it.

“You told me we were waiting for the money to clear.”

“I thought I could get the financing worked out.”

“On your wages?”

He didn’t answer.

Dad was fifty-six. Kelly was fifty-three. They sat there with a paint sample on the refrigerator and no money for the house she’d announced to a shed full of people.

“Call them,” she said.

“It’s Saturday.”

“Then call Monday. Tell them there’s been a delay.”

“There hasn’t been a delay,” Dad said. “There isn’t a down payment.”

She turned to me.

“You can fix this.”

There it was. Less than a day after I’d been told to find somewhere else to live, I had been promoted to somewhere else.

“No.”

“You let us stand there yesterday talking about Cedar Bluff.”

“I didn’t know he lied to you.”

“But you knew you owned this place.”

“Yes.”

“And you let me look stupid.”

I picked up my coffee. It had gone cold.

“You managed your own speech.”

Her chair scraped backward.

Marissa appeared in the doorway, with Carl behind her. They’d heard enough to stop smiling before they entered.

Kelly pointed at me.

“Your stepbrother bought the farm without telling anybody. Now he’s putting us out.”

“The lease ends May 25,” I said. “You announced you were leaving.”

Carl looked at Dad.

“We’re not getting the new house?”

Dad shook his head.

Marissa sat on the bottom stair. She wrapped her arms around her knees, the way she used to when she was little.

I didn’t enjoy that part.

Kelly held out the papers again.

“Then extend this.”

“No.”

“Where is your father supposed to go?”

I took my phone out and opened Marla’s reply.

“I’ll offer him a lease. Just him.”

Dad looked up so sharply his chair shifted.

Kelly waited for him to laugh.

He didn’t.

The Step by the Parts Room

Kelly walked past me toward the back door.

“Come outside, Glenn.”

Dad started after her. I nearly let him.

That was our family habit: she moved, he followed, and I got the version afterward with all the sharp edges sanded off.

“Stay,” I said. “Please.”

He stopped.

Kelly turned around.

“This is between your father and me.”

“Yesterday you made my home everybody’s business.”

“You are twisting what happened. I threw you a graduation party. I cooked for two days. I invited everyone. You stood there sulking because we said it was time to grow up.”

I could have reminded her who carried the tables, fetched the ice, and worked the grill. Instead, I asked Dad one question.

“Did you know I wasn’t coming with you?”

He stared at the floor.

“Glenn,” Kelly said.

“Did you?”

“Yes,” he said.

Marissa lifted her head from her knees.

For a second, I couldn’t get enough air. I had spent the night angry at him for ducking a fight. He had helped arrange it.

“How long?”

“We talked about it last week.”

“And you couldn’t tell me?”

“I didn’t know how.”

Kelly folded her arms.

“He didn’t want to hurt your feelings.”

I laughed once. It sounded bad in that kitchen.

“So you put me by a hot grill and told everybody else.”

Dad reached toward my shoulder. I stepped away.

That was the first thing I did all morning that made him cry.

Not much. His eyes filled, and he pressed his thumb against one of them like he could push it back in.

Kelly picked up her phone.

“I’m calling Mrs. Pruitt. She heard what I said.”

“Go ahead,” I said.

She hesitated, then called on speaker. Mrs. Pruitt answered from her kitchen, judging by the dishes rattling behind her.

Kelly spoke quickly.

“Would you come over? Kurt’s saying I threw him out yesterday, and now he’s threatening to evict us.”

I held out my hand for the phone. Kelly kept it.

“Mrs. Pruitt,” I said, “would you come to the shed? All five of us will be there.”

The dishes stopped.

“I’ll be over.”

Kelly ended the call.

“You’ll listen to her, at least.”

I took the notice and went outside.

The chairs were stacked where I’d left them. I pulled six down, setting them near the parts-room step. The one with the missing foot went back against the wall. There were enough wobbly things in my family already.

Dad followed carrying his coffee. Kelly came with Marissa and Carl.

When Mrs. Pruitt arrived, she stood inside the bay door and looked at the chairs.

“Well,” she said. “This looks unpleasant.”

“It is,” Kelly said.

She launched into the party, the brisket, the insult of receiving papers at seven. She said I had hidden money, bought the farm behind their backs, and waited until she was happy to spoil everything.

Mrs. Pruitt listened without taking a chair.

Then she held her hand out.

“Let me see.”

Kelly gave her the notice.

Mrs. Pruitt read it with the paper held at arm’s length.

“This is the same moving date you told us yesterday.”

“That’s not the point.”

“What is the point?”

“He owns it,” Kelly said.

Mrs. Pruitt looked at me.

I nodded.

She lowered the paper.

“Oh.”

Kelly nodded hard, as if that little word had settled the case in her favor.

“He could have told us.”

Mrs. Pruitt walked over to me.

“I owe you an apology.”

Kelly’s mouth stayed open.

“I nodded yesterday,” Mrs. Pruitt said. “I thought you had all discussed it. Then you asked where you were supposed to go, and I still stood there.”

“Thank you,” I said.

“I should’ve asked you to come home with me.”

That nearly did it. I had kept myself together through the papers and Dad’s confession. A woman offering the room she hadn’t offered yesterday almost put me on the floor.

Kelly took the notice back.

“So I’m the villain because I expected an adult to move out?”

Dad set his coffee on the workbench.

“You expected my son to disappear so we could have the house you wanted.”

“You agreed.”

“Yes,” he said.

He looked at me.

“I agreed.”

The shed went quiet.

“I lied about the money,” he said. “I let you tell everybody we could afford Cedar Bluff. And I let you tell Kurt he wasn’t coming because I couldn’t bear another argument.”

Kelly stepped toward him.

“You are blaming me for your debts?”

“No. Those are mine.”

“Then stop making me sound cruel.”

Dad looked at the parts-room step where she’d stood the afternoon before.

“You laughed when he asked where he would go.”

Carl put his phone in his pocket.

Nobody had asked him to.

Kelly turned to me.

“You’ve made your point. Tell your father we can stay while we sort this out.”

I wanted Dad to choose me without a lease in his hand. I wanted something I couldn’t buy.

“The offer is for him,” I said.

Kelly looked at Dad.

“If you stay here, don’t pretend we’re all moving together later.”

He gripped the edge of the workbench.

“I understand.”

The Chairs Came Down Again

Kelly walked out of the shed first. Marissa followed her, but Carl stayed near the door.

“Am I supposed to pack now?” he said.

“No,” I said. “You have until May 25. Nobody’s putting your things outside.”

He rubbed the toe of his shoe against the concrete.

“The cot thing was rotten.”

“Yes.”

“I knew you heard me.”

“I know.”

He stood there a moment longer.

“I’m sorry.”

I nodded. He went after his mother.

Dad started to speak, but Mrs. Pruitt held up one hand.

“Before everybody goes off to feel bad privately, what are you telling the people who were here?”

Dad looked at me.

I hadn’t thought beyond the room. In my head, the people who laughed were still gathered around the keg. I could hear them whenever I stopped talking.

“Tell them I wasn’t part of the decision,” I said. “And that I wasn’t living here because you were supporting me.”

He took out his phone.

Kelly had used a group message to invite the twenty-nine neighbors and co-op coworkers. Dad opened it and began typing. Then he stopped.

“Will you read it?”

He handed me the phone.

The message said he had mishandled the announcement.

I gave it back.

“That sounds like you used the wrong microphone.”

He stood beside the workbench and deleted it.

The second version named what happened. He and Kelly had decided to move without me, told me at my own party, and made jokes while I stood there working. He said I had bought the farm through my company in January and allowed them to remain until May 25.

He didn’t put my earnings in it. He didn’t need to.

He finished by saying the Cedar Bluff purchase wasn’t happening because he had misrepresented their finances.

“Send it,” I said.

His thumb hovered. These were the people he saw across the scale desk every week.

Then he pressed it.

Mrs. Pruitt took one of the chairs.

“Now,” she said to me, “which job do you want?”

I sat down opposite her.

For the first time that weekend, somebody waited for my answer.

I told her about the three offers. Dad stayed standing at first, then lowered himself onto a chair beside me. When he asked about HaulSlot, he didn’t pretend he already understood it.

I explained the delivery slots. The three co-ops. The investors. The Kansas City offer of $26,000,000, which was an offer, not a suitcase of money under my bed.

Dad put both hands over his face.

“All those nights.”

“Yes.”

He didn’t ask me to rescue Cedar Bluff again.

On Monday, May 18, he brought his phone onto the porch after speaking with the mortgage lender. Without the down payment he’d claimed he would have, the loan could not proceed.

Kelly stood in the doorway while he told me. There would be no $615,000 house. No private bathroom waiting for Marissa. No sprinkler system for Carl to admire.

Kelly had found a rental in Hastings for herself and her children.

She held up a paint sample.

“I suppose this is funny to you.”

“No.”

“Are you satisfied?”

“I wanted a graduation party.”

She tore the sample in half and dropped it in the kitchen trash.

Dad signed his new lease that afternoon after reading every page. It began May 26, named him alone, and made him responsible for $600 a month and the utilities. His marriage was his decision. Who lived in my house was mine.

He slid the signed pages toward me.

“I don’t expect this to fix us.”

“Good.”

On May 25, I held the front door while Marissa carried out a box. Carl brought down the last of his clothes. They had beds waiting in Hastings, and Dad had helped them move the furniture that belonged to them.

Kelly came out last.

She put her farmhouse key in my palm.

“You’ll find out what this place costs to keep.”

“I already did.”

She went down the steps.

I closed my hand around the key and stayed on the porch until the car reached the road.

That evening, Dad found me in the shed taking down the party lights.

“Leave those a minute,” he said.

He carried two folding chairs to the bay door. Then he brought out the grill.

“I don’t need a second party,” I said.

“I know.”

He lit the burners and put a burger on.

I reached for the tongs without thinking. Dad moved them to his other hand.

“No. Sit.”

So I did.

My graduation gown was still upstairs in its bag. My desk was still at the end of the hall. I could take a job somewhere else, travel, leave for months if I wanted. Nothing in the house needed to be packed that night.

Dad scraped the grill with more attention than the job required.

“Your co-op year,” he said. “The one in Iowa. Was it really that hard?”

I looked at him.

He pulled the other chair closer with his boot.

“Tell me.”

I began with the first week, when I got lost driving to the seed company and ate crackers for dinner because I was too tired to shop.

Dad listened.

When the burger was ready, he put it in a bun and brought it over.

I started to stand.

He rested a hand on my shoulder.

“Stay there, son. I’ve got it.”

Family slights have a way of revealing bigger secrets, as in the brother who left his sibling off Christmas but not off his loan and the envelope delivered to an ex-wife’s door. For another painful family gathering, read about a grandfather who sent his granddaughter to eat in the laundry room.