My Sister Priced Mom’s Last Pies at $18 Apiece. Then She Came for Mom’s Phone.

Samuel Brooks

My sister skipped every one of our mother’s last four months, then stood at the church bake sale selling the fourteen pies Mom had frozen for my kids, $18 apiece, and said, “You got four months with her, Simone. Let me have the pies.” Her phone lay face up by the pecan, and my daughter had already read it.

Mom baked those pies in July, the last week her hands still did what she told them.

Pecan, apple, two cherry, and the rest pumpkin.

She wrote PENNY and HUDSON on masking tape across every lid so nobody would get ideas.

Somebody got ideas.

Nicolette drove the four hours up for the funeral, took the freezer key off the hook by Mom’s back door, and drove home with all fourteen in a cooler.

I found out from the church bulletin.

“Frances Hinkle’s famous pies, baked with love by her daughter Nicolette.”

She has never baked a pie in her life.

So that Saturday I took Penny to the fellowship hall at Trinity Episcopal in Mayville, and we got in line behind the coffee urn like anybody else.

The radiator by the coat rack banged every couple of minutes, like somebody dropping a pan in the next room.

Lorrie Ferrara, who has run that table since before I was confirmed, had her hand flat on my sister’s back.

“Your mother would be so proud of you, honey,” Lorrie said.

“I just wanted people to taste her cooking one more time,” Nicolette said.

She’d peeled the tape off. Every lid.

My kids’ names were gone.

I didn’t say a word. I was going to buy one pie and leave.

Then Penny pulled on my sleeve.

“Mom,” she said. “Aunt Nicky’s texting Grandma.”

“Grandma doesn’t have a phone anymore, bug.”

“I know,” she said. “That’s what I mean.”

The phone was right there between the pecan and the cash box, screen still lit, nobody’s hand on it.

The name at the top of the thread said Mom.

Under every blue bubble, in small red letters, it said Not Delivered.

I knew why. I’d called the carrier myself on October 14 and paid the last $46.80 so the line would close.

The newest one had gone out at 11:52 the night before.

I’m sorry.

The one under it was 11:49, the night before that. I’m sorry Mama.

I scrolled with one finger.

Twenty-six nights.

Almost the same minute every night, all of them going nowhere.

Some were longer. I’m sorry I didn’t come. I’m sorry about what I said about the house. I’m sorry I’m sorry I’m sorry.

I should have felt something soft.

I didn’t.

I thought about the night in August Mom asked me to call Nicky and tell her the morphine made her dream about the lake, and Nicky texted back “can’t this week, crazy at work” with the sweating face.

I thought about who changed the pad on that bed at three in the morning.

Sorry was free at 11:52 at night.

It didn’t cost a drive.

“What are you doing?”

Nicolette had come around the table. She grabbed for it and I held it up over my head, the way she used to do to me with the remote.

“You left it open,” I said.

“That’s MY phone, Simone.”

“She can’t read these. I shut that line off three weeks ago. You’d know that if you’d ever once asked who was paying it.”

The women at the coffee urn stopped talking. Lorrie took her hand off Nicolette’s back.

“Give it back,” Nicolette said.

“You told this whole church you BAKED them.”

“I said they were hers.”

“The tape on those lids had MY KIDS’ NAMES on it.”

Her neck went red and blotchy, the way Mom’s used to.

“You had her,” she said. “You had her every single day for four months. I get one table at a bake sale and you can’t even give me that.”

“You could have had her too. She asked for you. EVERY NIGHT SHE ASKED FOR YOU.”

Nobody in that hall moved.

I set the phone face down on the pecan pie, gave Lorrie $18 for the cherry, and walked out holding Penny’s hand.

In the car she asked if Aunt Nicky was going to get in trouble.

I said no.

She asked if I was. I said not today.

At home the hospice tote was still on the floor of the hall closet where I’d shoved it on October 11.

Jamila, the night nurse, had packed it. Mom’s slippers, her reading glasses, the blood pressure cuff and the little speaker they lent us, which I was supposed to drop back at their office on Route 9.

“Her phone’s in the side pocket,” Jamila had said at the door. “She had me keep it charged for you.”

I thanked her. I never unzipped it.

It was right there, dead as a rock, in the purple glitter case Penny picked out for her.

I plugged it in by the toaster and stood there till the screen came on.

Her code was Hudson’s birthday. She never changed anything in her life.

No service across the top. I’d done that.

There was one recording in Voice Memos.

It was called For Nicky.

October 9. 2:14 in the afternoon. Six minutes and eleven seconds.

The day before she died.

I didn’t know she could still hold a phone on October 9.

I was there. I was there that entire afternoon, except the forty minutes I went to the pharmacy for her mouth swabs.

My thumb was over the play button when a car door slammed in my driveway.

Through the glass in the front door I could see my sister on the porch, holding Mom’s old pie carrier out in front of her with both hands.

The pie carrier

I took my thumb off the button.

I pulled the cord out of the wall and pushed the phone into the front pocket of my jeans. The charger came with it. The plug hung out of my pocket like a tail.

Penny was in the kitchen doorway with her coat still on.

“Is that Aunt Nicky?”

“Go upstairs, bug.”

She didn’t go. I opened the door.

Nicolette held the carrier out at me with both arms straight. It was Mom’s, the brown plastic one with the latch that never caught on the first try.

“I brought them back,” she said.

She thumbed the latch. It took two tries.

Two pies inside. The pecan I’d set her phone on, and one pumpkin.

Somebody had stuck the masking tape back on. Crooked, wrinkled, the edges gone gray from handling. PENNY across the pecan. HUDSON across the pumpkin.

She’d kept the strips. She’d peeled every lid in that hall and stuck the tape somewhere she could find it again.

On top of the pies was a bank envelope, folded once.

“Eleven sold after you left,” she said. “Plus yours. Two hundred and sixteen.”

I didn’t take it.

Behind her, at the curb, her car was still running. Somebody was in the passenger seat with a purse on her lap.

Lorrie Ferrara.

“Why is Lorrie in your car?”

“She wanted to help.” Nicky looked past me, down the hall, at the closet door. It was still open from where I’d pulled out the tote. “Jamila said Mom’s phone went home with you.”

The plug was still hanging out of my pocket.

“Where’s Mom’s phone, Simone?”

The bread box

Mom’s house is on the county road out past the feed store, a white two-story with a porch that slopes toward the ditch.

Dad left it to her in 2015. After her, to the two of us. Half and half.

He wrote that out at the kitchen table with Mr. Sharma from the bank, and Mom kept the copy in a coffee can over the fridge for nine years. She showed it to me every time I asked about the furnace.

“Half and half,” she’d say. “Your father was a fair man. Get the furnace guy.”

In June I moved her bed into the front room so she could see the road.

That’s when the four months started. I won’t count them all out. I’ll say I learned how to roll a person onto her side without waking her, and that a hospital pad costs more than you’d think, and that Hudson learned to make his own cereal.

Penny was the one who taught her Voice Memos.

That was back in April, before the bed. Mom couldn’t type on the glass. Her thumbs were too big, she said, and too old, and too Episcopal. So Penny showed her the red circle.

After that every grocery list came to me as Mom talking.

“Eggs. The good butter. Tell Simone the gutter on the north side.”

I have eleven of those still on my own phone. I’ve never deleted one.

Nicky called on Mom’s birthday in May. She sent flowers to the church that Sunday, a big arrangement on the altar with a card in it, and Lorrie read the card out loud at coffee hour.

“That Nicolette,” Lorrie said to Mom, “always does things nice.”

Mom said yes, she does.

In August a manila envelope came for Mom, certified, with Nicky’s handwriting on the front and a return address four hours south.

I signed for it. I brought it in. Mom opened it in bed with her reading glasses on the end of her nose.

She read for a long time. Longer than a card takes.

Then she folded it back along its creases, the way she did with every letter she ever got, and slid it back in.

“Put that with the bread,” she said.

The bread box was the tin one with roosters on it, on the counter by the stove. I put the envelope in under the rye. I didn’t open it.

It had her name on it, not mine.

That was the same week I called Nicky about the lake dreams. The same week Nicky sent the sweating face.

After that I went to the pharmacy every afternoon at two, while Mom slept off lunch. Forty minutes there and back if the line was short. It was the only time I left her alone in that house.

At the funeral, in the narthex, Nicky stood with Pastor Doyle’s hand on her shoulder and said, “I never even got to talk to her at the end.”

I was standing right behind her with a tray of ham buns.

I didn’t say anything then either.

Now she was on my porch, asking for the one thing of Mom’s I hadn’t touched.

Lorrie’s purse

“It’s dead,” I said. “It’s in the tote.”

That was half true. It had been dead for three weeks and in the tote until an hour ago.

“Then give me the tote.”

“The tote goes back to hospice. There’s a cuff in it and a speaker. They want them back.”

“I’ll take it.” Nicky had the carrier against her stomach now. “Route 9, right? It’s on my way.”

Nicky has never in her life offered to return anything to anybody.

The car door opened at the curb. Lorrie got out slowly, one hand on the roof, her purse on her arm. She came up my walk in her church shoes and stopped on the bottom step.

“Simone, honey.”

“Hi, Lorrie.”

“I’m not here to take sides. I’m here because your sister asked me to come.”

She looked at the carrier and the envelope on top of the pies.

“She drove four hours up for that sale, honey. She’s driving four hours back tonight. She just wants something of her mother’s.”

“She has fourteen somethings of her mother’s,” I said. “Twelve of them she sold.”

“I brought two back,” Nicky said.

Lorrie put her hand on the porch rail.

“I know you two said things at the hall. I know you’re worn down to nothing. Everybody at Trinity knows what you did for Frances. Nobody’s saying different.”

“Okay.”

“But you can’t keep her away now.”

I looked at her. “Keep who away?”

Lorrie looked at Nicky. Nicky was looking at the pies.

“Honey, she told us. At the funeral lunch. How you said your mother wasn’t up to visitors in August. How you said it would just upset her to see Nicolette, the way things were with the house.”

There it was. The house again.

“I never said that.”

“I said it was hard to get time off,” Nicky said.

“You said Simone told you not to come,” Lorrie said. “You said it right in front of Bernard and me, at the coffee.”

Bernard is Lorrie’s husband. He’s eighty and he hears everything.

My face went hot. My hand went to my pocket. The phone was warm from me.

“Is that true, Simone?” Lorrie said. “Did you tell her not to come?”

Penny was behind me in the hall. I could feel her there without looking.

“Give me ten minutes,” I said.

I shut the door on both of them and turned the lock.

Jamila’s cell number

The hospice folder was still on my fridge under a magnet shaped like a cow. Jamila had written her cell on the inside flap in purple pen. “Days or nights. Text first if you can.”

I didn’t text first.

She picked up on the fourth ring. There was a television on somewhere behind her.

“Simone. Hey. You doing okay?”

“Did you call my sister this morning?”

A pause. The television went quiet.

“No,” Jamila said. “She called me.”

I sat down at the kitchen table. Penny sat down across from me and put her chin on her hands.

“She called the office Thursday,” Jamila said. “They gave her my number, which they shouldn’t have, but she said she was family and she was upset. Then she called me Thursday night. Then yesterday. Then this morning at seven.”

“About what?”

“About your mom’s phone. Whether it came back to us with the equipment. I told her I packed it in the tote myself and gave it to you.”

“What else?”

“She asked if anybody in the family had been into it.”

I plugged the phone back in by the toaster. The screen lit. No service. For Nicky was still the only thing in Voice Memos.

“Jamila, did my mom tell you she made a recording?”

“Not in so many words.” She was quiet for a second. “On the ninth, when I came on at seven, she had the phone in her hand. She was holding it on her chest like a hymnbook. She asked me to keep it charged, and she said when it was over, it goes to you. Not anybody else. You.”

“She said that?”

“She said, ‘Simone gets it.’ Twice. I wrote it on the sheet.”

Outside, Nicky knocked. Three soft ones, then nothing.

“Simone,” Jamila said. “There’s one more thing, and I didn’t like it.”

“Go ahead.”

“Your sister asked me how long a voice memo stays on a phone after the line gets shut off.”

Recents

I thanked Jamila. I said I’d bring the tote by Monday. She said there was no hurry on the speaker, nobody ever brings the speaker back.

When I hung up, Penny had Grandma’s phone.

She’d unplugged it again and had it in both hands in her lap, the purple glitter case catching the light from the window over the sink. She knew the code. Of course she knew the code. She’d set half of that phone up herself.

“Bug, give me that.”

“Mom.” She didn’t give it to me. “Grandma called Aunt Nicky.”

“Grandma called everybody. Grandma called the radio station.”

“No.” Penny turned the screen around. “On the day.”

It was the Recents list. The green phone in the bottom corner, the list Mom always called “the who-called.”

Most of it was me. Simone, Simone, Simone, every day for months, two minutes, four minutes, one minute. Pharmacy. Trinity Episcopal. Simone.

And on October 9, between two of mine, one line in black.

Nicky. 2:03 PM. Outgoing. 9 minutes.

I took the phone out of Penny’s hands. I didn’t grab. She let go.

Two-oh-three. I would have been in the pharmacy line behind the man with the oxygen tank, the one who always paid in quarters. I would have been holding the mouth swabs.

Mom had picked up that phone while I was gone and called my sister.

And my sister had answered.

Nine minutes. Then the call ended at 2:12. Then two minutes after that, at 2:14, the red circle.

For Nicky.

I scrolled up past October 9. I scrolled back to August and September, as far as the list would go.

There was nothing else from Nicky. No calls in. No calls out. Just that one, the day before.

“I never even got to talk to her at the end.”

Pastor Doyle’s hand on her shoulder. My tray of ham buns.

Nicky knocked on the door again, harder this time.

“Simone, please. I just want to hear her. Please. I won’t even take it, just let me hear it.”

Penny was looking at me. Eleven years old, her coat still on, the zipper pulled up to her chin.

“Mom,” she said. “Is that why Aunt Nicky keeps saying sorry?”

Six minutes and eleven seconds

I sent Penny upstairs. This time she went.

I waited until I heard her door close. Then I set Mom’s phone flat on the counter next to the toaster and pressed play.

At first there was nothing. A rustle. The hospital bed’s mattress pump, the hum it made every minute or so to shift the air.

Then Mom.

“Nicky. You hung up on me, so I’m saying it on here. Penny showed me how. You talk and it keeps it.”

Her voice was thick. The morphine made her slow, like every word had to be carried across a room first.

“I’m not mad you hung up. You were always a hanger-upper. Your father was too.”

A cough. A long one. The pump hummed.

“I didn’t sign them, honey. Your papers. I read every page. I’m not signing them.”

I put both hands flat on the counter.

“They’re in the bread box. Under the rye. You can have them back. I’m not putting the house in your name, Nicky. Your father wanted it even. Half and half. I’m not going to undo your father with three weeks left.”

Three weeks. She’d thought she had three weeks.

“I know what you said. That your sister would sell it the day I’m gone and put her half in the kids’ college and you’d get a check and nothing to come home to. Maybe she will. That’s hers to do. It’s half hers.”

A long breath in. A longer one out.

“And I’m not telling her you sent them.”

The pump hummed.

“You hear me? I’m not telling Simone. She would never let it go. You know her. She’s your father all over. She would hold it till she died, and then who would you have?”

I couldn’t feel my hands on the counter.

“So she doesn’t know. And you’re going to make that be true, Nicky. You don’t ever tell her. You just come.”

The radiator in my own kitchen clicked on.

“You said on the phone it’s because she won’t let you. Honey. Simone never said one word to keep you away. I’m the one asking. I’m asking. Come tomorrow.”

Another cough. Something knocked against the bed rail, maybe the phone.

“One night. That’s all. Come do one night. She changes that bed at three in the morning, Nicky. Every night. She thinks I’m asleep. I’m not asleep. She sings that song your dad used to sing when he was doing the dishes, the one about the train, and she gets all the words wrong.”

I made a sound. I didn’t know I was going to.

“She’s so tired. She’s tired down to the bone. You give her one night of sleep and I won’t ask you for another thing.”

The pump. A car going by on the county road.

“And the pies are for the kids. I put names on them. Don’t you get ideas.”

She laughed. It turned into the cough.

“I love you. I love you both. I wish you’d been nicer to each other when you were little. That’s my fault. I let you get away with too much because you were the baby.”

A long quiet. A minute, maybe more. Just the pump and the sound of her breathing.

Then her voice again, closer to the phone, like she’d brought it right up to her mouth.

“Penny, how do you make this thing stop?”

The rustle. A thump.

Six minutes, eleven seconds.

The screen went back to the list. For Nicky. October 9. 2:14 PM.

I stood there with my hands on the counter until the toaster’s little clock said 4:40.

Then I picked up the phone and went to the door.

The porch light

They were both still there. Lorrie had sat down on the porch swing with her purse on her knees. Nicky was standing at the top of the steps with the carrier.

I turned the porch light on, though it wasn’t dark yet. I don’t know why. My hand just did it.

I held the phone out with the screen toward my sister. The Recents list.

“Two-oh-three,” I said. “October 9. Nine minutes.”

Nicky looked at it. Her neck went red from the collar up, the way it did at the hall.

“So she called me,” she said. “So what. She called everybody. She called the radio station, she called the gas company about a bill from 2019, she was on morphine, Simone, she didn’t know what day it was.”

“She knew what day it was.”

“She called me for nine minutes and she cried for most of it and I couldn’t understand half of what she said. That’s what that is. That’s all that is.”

Lorrie had stopped swinging.

“Nicolette,” Lorrie said. “You told Pastor you never got to talk to her.”

“I didn’t. Not really. Not like that’s talking.”

Then she looked at the phone in my hand. Not at me. At the phone.

“Did she say anything about the papers?”

The porch went quiet. Down the block somebody was running a leaf blower.

“What papers?” Lorrie said.

“Nothing. It’s nothing. It’s a house thing.” Nicky turned to Lorrie and then back to me. “It’s between me and Simone.”

“You said it was between you and Mom,” I said.

That was all I said.

She set the carrier down on the porch boards hard enough that the latch popped open on its own.

“Fine. Fine. I sent her some papers. In August. A quitclaim, so the house would go to me without all the probate garbage, and then I would have bought you out. I would have. I had a whole plan. I had numbers. I had a man at the bank in Columbus look at it.”

“Okay.”

“Don’t say okay. You don’t know. You don’t know what this year has been. Antoine’s been laid off since March. We’re two payments behind. You live twelve minutes from that house. You were going to sell it the second she was in the ground and put your half in some college fund and I was going to get a check in the mail, Simone, a check, for the house I grew up in.”

She was crying now, but she kept going.

“And she wouldn’t sign. And then she calls me, the day before, and she wants me to come up and do the bed. The bed. And I said I can’t, I said I can’t do that, I can’t see her like that, and she starts in about how you’re tired. How Simone’s so tired. Everything was always how good Simone was.”

“Nicky,” Lorrie said.

“So yes. I told people Simone kept me away. What was I supposed to tell them? That she asked and I didn’t come? That she called me herself? I said what I could stand to say.”

She wiped her face with the back of her hand. Her acrylic nails had cherry filling dried under two of them.

“Just delete it. Please. You don’t need it. You’ve got her every day, you’ve got all those grocery lists, Penny told me about the grocery lists. You had her. This one is mine. Just delete it, and I’ll go, and I won’t come back for anything.”

Lorrie stood up from the swing. It took her two tries.

She picked the bank envelope off the top of the pies, folded it once more, and put it in her purse.

“This goes to the hospice,” she said. “Out on Route 9. In Frances’s name. I’ll drive it myself Monday.”

Nobody argued with her.

“Bernard can come get me,” Lorrie said. “Or I’ll walk. It’s six blocks.”

She went down my steps one at a time with her hand on the rail. At the bottom she turned around.

“Your mother asked me in September to pray for you girls,” she said to Nicky. “I’ve been praying for the wrong one.”

Then she walked off toward the church in her good shoes.

Nicky stared after her. Then at me.

“Are you going to tell everybody?”

I didn’t answer that.

I looked at the phone in my hand. Mom’s purple case. Penny’s thumbprint smudged across the glitter.

There was no service on it. Nothing to send it with. Penny could probably have found some way to copy it over, some cord, some trick. I didn’t go upstairs and ask her.

I held the phone out to my sister.

“It’s called For Nicky,” I said.

She didn’t take it at first. She looked at it like it might be hot.

“The code’s Hudson’s birthday.”

“I don’t know Hudson’s birthday.”

“March 18th. Oh-three-one-eight.”

She took it. She held it in both hands, the way she’d held the carrier coming up the walk.

“You’re not going to delete it,” she said.

“No.”

“You’re giving it to me.”

“It’s yours. She made it for you.”

I went into the hall closet and got the hospice tote. I took out Mom’s slippers and her reading glasses and put them on the bench by the door. Then I zipped up what was left, the cuff and the little speaker, and set the tote on the porch next to her feet.

“Route 9,” I said. “It’s on your way.”

I picked up the carrier with the two pies in it and closed the latch. It caught on the first try.

“The pies stay,” I said.

She went down the steps with the tote over her shoulder and Mom’s phone in her hand.

At the curb she got in the driver’s seat and shut the door. She didn’t start the car.

The dome light stayed on.

Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving was at my house, the first one ever. Hudson asked if Grandma’s table would fit in our kitchen. It didn’t. We used ours.

The week before, I drove out to the county road with a garbage bag and the key from the hook. I opened the tin bread box with the roosters on it.

The rye was green. Under it was the manila envelope, still folded along her creases.

I didn’t open it. I mailed it back to the address on the front, certified, and signed for my own receipt.

The house is still half hers. It’s still half mine. Neither of us has called Mr. Sharma.

Lorrie took the $216 to Route 9 like she said. The church bulletin that week had a line in it at the bottom, under the prayer list. “A gift to Valley Hospice in memory of Frances Hinkle, from her daughters.”

Daughters. Lorrie wrote it.

I thawed the pecan Wednesday night on the counter by the toaster.

Penny peeled the tape off the lid before we cut it. She did it slow, one corner at a time, so the letters wouldn’t tear. PENNY, wrinkled and gray at the edges.

She stuck it on the fridge, next to the cow magnet, where the hospice folder used to be.

Hudson got the pumpkin. He ate his slice standing up, like Mom always yelled at him not to.

That night my phone lit up on the nightstand. 11:52.

Nicky.

I listened to all of it again. Is the train song the one that goes I’ve been working on the railroad?

Under the bubble, in small gray letters, it said Delivered.

I sat up in bed and typed back.

“No. It’s the one about the Wabash. I’ll sing it for you at Christmas. I get all the words wrong.”

If this one got to you, call your sister tonight, even if it’s late, even if you’re the one who’s tired.

For more family stories where old wounds surface around a loss, read about a brother’s fight over Dad’s ramp and the surprising message Dad left behind. And for another story of a mother’s keepsake carrying unexpected meaning, see the customer whose mother’s card held a name from the past.