My Niece Made Me Play It Twice Every Thursday. I Kept Count in Pencil.

Sarah Jenkins

For six years my niece climbed to the church organ loft every Thursday to tell me my hands were finished, and in March she had the board take my bench. “Thirty-one years is plenty, Aunt Aileen. Nobody’s sad but you.” In August I judged her little boy’s crayon picture at the fair, and I understood what she’d been asking me.

Her boy was seven, and his was the thirty-seventh picture I picked up that day.

But first you have to understand Thursdays.

Practice night at our church ran six to seven, just me and the pipes and whatever the custodian was vacuuming downstairs.

Summer started coming up the loft stairs the winter Brayden turned one.

She’d sit on the bottom step with her coat zipped to the chin and her car keys in her lap.

“You’re dragging it,” she’d say. “You drag everything now, Aunt Aileen.”

“Then go home, honey,” I said once.

She didn’t.

She stayed the whole hour, EVERY Thursday, and made me play the same hymn twice, slower, so she could tell me the second one was worse.

I thought it was the meanest hobby a grown woman ever had.

My own sister’s girl. I held her at her baptism.

In March her husband stood up at the board meeting and read a letter with her name signed at the bottom.

My tempo. My hearing. My “attitude in the loft.”

Ricky read it like a man reading a water bill.

They gave my bench to a twenty-two-year-old named Varun who plays hymns off a tablet.

Summer sat in the third pew that Sunday and never once looked up.

I didn’t climb those stairs again.

In June I ran into Varun in the cereal aisle.

“Nobody ever comes up to the loft on Thursdays,” he said. “Is that normal? Mr. Vaughn’s asked me twice if anybody does.”

I told him it was normal now.

Then came the county fair.

The 4-H lady asked me to judge the under-ten drawings, because I’d taught piano to half those children’s parents, and apparently that makes you an art expert in Pettis County.

The tent smelled like kettle corn and the goat barn.

My judging pencil came from a funeral home in a town I’ve never been to.

Thirty-six horses, tractors, rainbows, one very angry chicken.

Number thirty-seven was a blue car.

A lady with yellow hair sat in the back seat.

Every window was colored over in black crayon, pressed so hard the paper had gone shiny.

A man stood outside it, taller than the car, holding a key as big as his own arm.

And along the bottom ran a row of little moons.

I counted them with the funeral home pencil.

NINETEEN.

The entry card said BRAYDEN VAUGHN, AGE 7, in Summer’s careful printing.

I didn’t hear him come in.

“Did I win?”

He was at my elbow in a green church camp shirt, sticky to the wrists.

“It’s a good car,” I said. “Who’s the lady, sweetheart?”

“That’s Mama.” He touched the moons one at a time, like he was checking they were all still there. “That’s how many times she had to stay in there.”

“Stay in where?”

“In the car. In the garage. Till Daddy says she can come in.”

My hand went flat on the table.

Then the tent flap moved, and Summer was standing in it with Ricky right behind her.

Two women from the choir stopped talking over by the jam entries.

Somebody near the door said, not quietly, “Oh, here we go.”

Every soul in that tent knew what my niece had done to me in March.

They were waiting to watch me do it back.

Summer saw the drawing in my hand, and her lip curled like it smelled.

“Don’t you DARE give him a pity ribbon,” she said. “He can’t color. He gets that from his daddy.”

Ricky laughed and put his hand on the back of her neck.

Easy. Friendly. Like a man steering a shopping cart.

“Brayden, come here, bud,” he said.

Brayden didn’t move.

He took hold of my judge’s lanyard with both fists instead.

I looked at the key ring hanging off Summer’s finger.

It was the same ring she’d held in her lap on that bottom step for six years of Thursdays.

Sixty minutes a week.

I counted the Thursdays since March on my fingers, under the table, and made myself stop.

I laid the drawing face up and took a picture of it with my phone.

I sent it to Mohammed Stahl, who took piano from me in 1994 and has worn a deputy’s uniform for eleven years.

Under it I typed two words. Art tent.

“Is she throwing it out?” somebody behind me said.

I walked across the tent.

Not to Ricky.

To my niece.

“Summer,” I said. “You still want me to play it slower?”

Her chin went the way it used to when she was nine and trying not to cry at a recital.

Ricky’s thumb moved on her neck.

“She’s not well,” he said to the whole tent, grinning. “Everybody knows Aileen’s not well. That’s why she’s off the organ.”

“I’m well enough to judge, Ricky.”

“We’re going. Brayden. NOW.”

“Go if you want,” I said. “I’m not leaving this tent WITHOUT MY NIECE AND HER BOY.”

Nobody by the jam table said a word.

Summer didn’t look at me.

But down by her hip, where Ricky couldn’t see, her fingers found my hand.

She pushed something into my palm and closed my fingers over it.

It was a church bulletin, folded to the size of a matchbook and soft as cloth from being carried.

On the outside, in blue ballpoint, was a Thursday in 2021.

That’s when Mohammed came through the tent flap in uniform, his phone still lit in his hand.

Ricky’s hand came off her neck.

But he wasn’t looking at the deputy.

He was looking at my closed fist, the one I hadn’t opened yet, and he was still smiling.

Entry thirty-seven

I opened my hand right there, with Ricky watching it.

The folds had been pressed so many times they’d gone white. It was an order of worship from some Sunday I’d played, hymn numbers down the side, and across the top, in the same blue ballpoint, was Summer’s careful printing.

Aunt Aileen. Thursday is the only hour he lets me out of the house. Whatever I say up there, please keep playing.

I read it, and then I turned it over and read the date again.

Mohammed was at the table by then. He looked at the drawing, at the moons, at Brayden’s two fists in my lanyard. He didn’t look at the paper, and I didn’t show it to him.

“Mrs. Vaughn,” he said. “Let’s you and me step outside a minute.”

“She’s fine,” Ricky said. “Tell him you’re fine, babe.”

“I’m fine,” Summer said.

Ricky held his hand out to me, palm up, the way you hold it out at a register for your change.

“That’s church trash, Aileen. Hand it here.”

I put the bulletin in my cardigan pocket and did the button up over it.

He laughed, and the alto by the jam jars laughed a little with him, because she didn’t know what else to do.

“Keep it,” he said. “She signed that letter herself, you know. Ask her who wanted you gone.”

The back page of my hymnal

I’ve carried the same hymnal up to that loft since 1995. Black, the gold rubbed off the spine, my maiden name inside the cover.

The back page is where I kept count of her.

One pencil mark for every Thursday Summer sat on that bottom step. Fives with a line through them, like a bowling score. I started it that first winter out of pure spite. I meant to show my sister one day what her girl did with her Thursdays. Then my sister died in 2023, and I kept counting anyway.

There are two hundred and eighty-one marks.

I know that hour better than my own kitchen. The heat clanking on at six-ten. Number 377, “It Is Well,” twice, slower. Summer’s coat zipped to the chin in January and zipped to the chin in July. Her keys in her lap and her thumbs on the keys. Never a phone in her hand. Never a glance at a watch, because she didn’t wear one.

And Jerome’s vacuum somewhere under the floor. A low hum I tuned around for six years. Some nights it ran clear through the last verse, and I’d think that man was going to wear a hole in the fellowship hall.

When I came out at seven there’d be a gray pickup idling by the dumpster. I took it for Jerome’s, if I thought about it at all.

Everybody at our church knows Ricky Vaughn. He counts the offering with the treasurer every Sunday. He built the Methodists a wheelchair ramp and wouldn’t take a dime. He calls me Miss Aileen in front of people and Aileen when it’s just us.

Mohammed knows my house better than he knows that church. In 1994 he came to his Tuesday lessons through my kitchen door, because my porch steps had rotted out that year and I couldn’t afford new ones until spring.

Back in the tent, he walked Summer out through the flap into the sun. Brayden let go of my lanyard to watch her go.

She came back inside in under two minutes and stood where Ricky’s hand could reach her.

Nine-forty

Mohammed came over to my table and put his back to the room.

“She says he draws whatever he sees on TV,” he said. “Without her, Aileen, I’ve got a crayon picture.”

“It’s Thursday,” I said.

“So?”

“So go by the house tonight. Please.”

He looked at me a long time, the way he used to look at a page of sixteenth notes. “I can do a welfare check. That’s what I can do.”

Ricky took Brayden by the wrist. Brayden let go of my lanyard one finger at a time, and on his way out he looked back at the table where his picture was.

The alto came over once they’d gone. She’d sung next to Summer’s mother for twenty years.

“Aileen, honey. Ricky counts the money every Sunday. You need to think about how this looks.”

“I’m thinking about it.”

I pinned the blue ribbon to entry thirty-seven anyway. First place, under ten. Then I slid it into the judges’ folder and took it home, which you are not supposed to do. I didn’t want it hanging in that tent overnight where Ricky could come back for it.

At home I sat by the phone with the hymnal open to the back page. At six o’clock I turned the kitchen clock to face the wall.

Mohammed texted at nine-forty.

Went by. He let me in, showed me the garage himself. She says she’s fine. Boy’s asleep.

Then a second one, a minute later.

Car’s a blue Malibu. Back windows tinted black.

Chana’s copy

Chana has kept the board minutes since her husband retired off the board, and she files everything in the church office in folders with typed labels.

Friday morning I stood at her desk.

“That letter’s about me,” I said. “I’d like to read it.”

“Ricky said you’d come asking.” She went to the cabinet anyway. “You didn’t get this from me.”

It wasn’t the one page Ricky had read in March. It was four pages. He’d stood up and read the first one and sat down.

Page two was a list.

Thursday, October 14, 2021. 6:22 p.m. Mrs. Gibbs told me to “go home, honey.”

Thursday, March 3, 2022. 6:47 p.m. Second time through 377. Left hand behind the right for the whole last verse.

Thursday, November 9, 2023. 6:31 p.m. Mrs. Gibbs cried on the bench and kept playing.

Three pages of that. Times to the minute. My own words, in quotation marks, things I’d said with nobody in that loft but me and a woman with her hands in her lap.

At the bottom of page four, Summer’s name, in the careful printing.

I took the copy home and laid it beside my hymnal on the kitchen table. Every date on that list had one of my pencil marks. The first one, October 14, 2021, was the date in blue ballpoint on the bulletin in my pocket.

Summer never looked at a clock in that loft. I’d have seen her do it.

Saturday I called Jerome.

“Thursdays?” he said. “Miss Aileen, I never once worked a Thursday. Thursdays I’m at my daughter’s in Sedalia.”

“The vacuum,” I said. “Under the loft. Six years of it.”

“I do the floors Tuesday.” He was quiet a second. “And my truck’s red. It’s always been red.”

So who sat by that dumpster every Thursday with the motor running?

Ninety-one degrees

Sunday I went to church and sat in the eighth pew, as close to the loft as I could stand. Varun played 377 off his tablet at a nice brisk clip.

At the door, I caught Ricky in front of the pastor and the alto.

“Brayden ought to have piano,” I said. “Thursdays, six to seven, my house. No charge. Summer can sit in like old times.”

A deputy had stood in his garage three days before. He needed to look like a family man in front of the pastor, and I’d counted on that.

He grinned. “Sure, Miss Aileen. She’ll sit on your steps and keep you honest.”

“I record every lesson,” I said. “For the parents.”

“Send me every one.”

Thursday at five fifty-eight a gray pickup pulled up to my curb and didn’t shut off.

Summer came up my walk in her winter coat. It was ninety-one degrees. She sat down on the bottom step of my stairs, which face the piano, and put her keys in her lap.

I set my phone on the music stand, recording, and put Brayden’s right thumb on middle C.

“Again,” I said. “Slower.”

He played it. In the rest between his notes, I heard it.

Low and steady, right under the bottom A-flat on my upright, where it had sat under every Thursday hymn for six years.

My house doesn’t have a downstairs.

It was coming out of Summer’s coat.

Through the front window, Ricky sat in the truck with the windows up and one elbow on the wheel, his phone flat to his ear. He wasn’t saying anything.

“He’s dragging it,” Summer said, loud, to the room. “He drags everything, Aunt Aileen. Just like you.”

I wrote in pencil in the margin of Brayden’s lesson book, Is he on the phone?, and held the book out toward the stairs.

Summer read it. She drew her zipper down two inches, enough for the screen to light her chin.

RICKY, it said, and under that a timer: fourteen minutes, nine seconds, still counting.

Six-oh-two

I wrote the rest in that lesson book before the hour was out, and she read it on my step with her lips moving, and she nodded once.

The next Thursday Mohammed came in my kitchen door at five-fifty, the way he did in 1994, out of uniform, his own car in the alley. He sat at my table and didn’t touch the coffee.

At five fifty-eight, the truck.

Summer did what I’d written. She took the coat off and laid it along my bottom step with the phone face up in the pocket, still connected. She set her key ring on top of it.

“Go on and play it, then,” she said, loud, to the coat. “Slow. So I can hear you drag it.”

Then she took Brayden’s hand, and they went through my kitchen, and my back door closed so soft I only knew it because the curtain moved.

I played.

377, twice. Then “Blessed Assurance.” Then Brayden’s middle C exercise with one finger, badly, because a seven-year-old was supposed to be in that room. Then 377 again.

By six-forty my right hand wouldn’t open past the third finger. The same hand Summer had called finished for six years. I played the rest left-handed with my foot down on the sustain.

At six fifty-nine I stopped.

The truck door. My screen door. Ricky in my front room, looking at a coat on my step.

He took the phone out of the pocket and looked at his own name on it.

“Where is she.”

I didn’t say.

“You think she’s got somewhere to go? That car’s in my name. That house is in my name. She doesn’t have a dollar I didn’t hand her. She’ll be back on that step by Sunday, and you’ll be the old woman who stole a boy off a piano bench.”

“Sit down, Ricky.”

“I wrote that letter. Every word. She signed it at my kitchen table because I set it in front of her.” He was smiling. “Six years I sat in that lot listening to you two. You think I didn’t know what she was doing? Making you play it twice. Buying herself another four minutes. So I took the minutes. And when the bench was gone, she kept asking. Every Thursday. ‘Can I go up to the church, Ricky.’ So she sat in the car till she quit asking.”

He held up her phone.

“Nineteen times. Slow learner. Gets that from your side.”

On the music stand, the little red dot on my phone kept blinking. He’d told me to send him every one.

“You will never touch an organ in this county again,” he said. “I’ll see to it.”

My kitchen door opened. Mohammed came in from the alley, in uniform now.

“Mr. Vaughn. Your wife’s at the sheriff’s office in Sedalia. She asked me to come get her coat.”

The bottom step

It’s November now. Thursday, six o’clock.

Summer sits on the bottom step of my stairs in one of my sweatshirts. Nothing in her lap. The Malibu was in Ricky’s name, and he kept it, the way he said he would.

Brayden is on the bench with his tongue between his teeth. The blue ribbon is on my refrigerator with a magnet from the feed store.

My right hand sleeps in a brace the doctor gave me. I haven’t been in the eighth pew since August. Chana mails me the bulletins. The alto crosses to the other pump at the Casey’s.

Varun texted last week. Nobody comes up on Thursdays. Is that normal?

The hymnal sits open on the piano to the back page. Two hundred and eighty-one marks, and I haven’t added one.

“Your left hand’s dragging,” Summer said.

“Then go home, honey.”

She laughed, and she didn’t move. “Play it again, Aunt Aileen. Slower.”

I played it slower.

If this one stayed with you, send it to the person in your family who keeps showing up on a step and never says why.

For more family stories where the past leaves its mark, read “Ken Says It Was March 1971. I Wrote a Different Year on the Back”, “My Husband Held Up His Phone While His Mother Gave Me the Papers. Then She Named the House”, and “My Mom Had One Letter Saved in Her Phone and It Wasn’t My Dad’s”.