My Mother Kept My Father’s Phone in Her Purse

Sofia Rossi

My sister put both hands on my chest at the door of our dad’s 80th birthday dinner and shoved me back down the steps, laughing, “Go home, Camille. You couldn’t cover a twelve-dollar soda in here.”

My mother watched her do it.

Neither of them knew the building was mine, or why my daughter had made me come.

I wasn’t going to go.

Then my ten-year-old came out of her room on Wednesday holding my phone and said her grandpa sounded scared.

Dad had been mailing Jazmin a card every birthday since she was five, with a five-dollar bill folded flat inside, and my mother never knew.

This time he’d called her instead.

She had the phone pressed against her shoulder so he wouldn’t hear.

“Mom, Grandpa’s being weird,” she said.

“Weird how?”

“He says Aunt Sasha keeps making him practice his name. He did it nine times on the back of a placemat, and she said the last one STILL didn’t look right.”

I took the phone from her.

He was gone.

He’d hung up, or somebody had hung up for him.

Dad turned eighty that Saturday.

Sasha had booked the dinner in the rooftop room at the Marbury, and my mother had sent me exactly one text about it.

“Do NOT come. Darren’s people from the bank will be there and your father doesn’t need a scene.”

I hadn’t sat at a family table in eleven years.

Not since I told them I was keeping the baby and not the man.

My mother’s goodbye that night was, “No husband, no money, no name. Enjoy scrubbing other people’s tubs.”

I did.

Night shifts, six years, three hotels.

Then I ran the carts, then a floor, then the whole housekeeping side of a building, and then I stopped working for buildings and started buying into them.

In March the group I put together bought the Marbury.

Nobody outside my office knew. I liked it that way.

So on Thursday I did the one thing an owner can do that a daughter can’t.

I looked.

Sasha had a suite on the fourteenth floor, five nights, charged to Dad’s card.

She’d also asked the concierge for a mobile notary, 9:15 Saturday, the rooftop room.

The note on the request said, “Signer is elderly. Please come after dessert, he tires early.”

She’d called the desk four times to make sure he wouldn’t be late.

I phoned Hyun, who runs security for the building, and gave him one instruction.

Then I got dressed for a party I wasn’t invited to.

Before we left the apartment, Jazmin held my phone out at arm’s length and put her cheek against mine.

“For Grandpa,” she said, and took the picture.

She’d picked the green dress herself.

Her tights had a run at the left knee that she swore nobody would see.

We came up from the street at ten to nine.

Sasha was standing under the awning in a red dress with a glass of wine, greeting people like she held the lease.

She saw me before I reached the top step.

“Oh, you’re kidding,” she said.

Then she bent down to Jazmin and smiled.

“Hi, sweetie. Grandpa’s upstairs. You can come up with me.”

She held her hand out for my daughter’s.

Not mine.

Jazmin stepped behind my hip.

“Not without my mom,” she said.

My mother came out through the revolving door wearing Grandma’s pearls.

Her eyes went to my blazer, then my shoes, then back to my face.

“I told you in WRITING,” she said.

“Ten minutes. I want to give Dad his present, and then we’ll leave.”

That’s when Sasha put both hands on my chest.

I went back two steps and caught the rail.

Jazmin’s fingers closed hard on my sleeve.

“Go home, Camille,” Sasha said, laughing.

“You couldn’t cover a twelve-dollar soda in here.”

The doorman I’d hired in June found something very interesting about the traffic.

My mother leaned down toward me.

“You still smell like the cleaning cart,” she said.

“Some people find their level.”

I didn’t answer her.

Behind her, through the glass, the elevator numbers were coming down.

Sasha turned and waved at the front desk with her whole arm.

“SECURITY. Can somebody get this woman OFF the steps? This is a private party.”

“She’s YOUR sister,” Jazmin said.

Nobody answered a ten-year-old.

The elevator opened.

Hyun crossed the lobby in his gray suit, and a stranger in a raincoat came half a step behind him with a brown envelope under his arm.

Sasha pointed down at me.

“Finally. Her. Walk her to the curb.”

Hyun didn’t look at her.

He came out through the door, stopped one step above me, and dipped his head the way he does every morning outside my office.

“Ms. Tiernan,” he said. “Your 9:15 is here early.”

Sasha’s glass stopped halfway to her mouth.

“Her WHAT?” my mother said.

Hyun kept his eyes on me.

“He says your sister booked him and had these drawn up herself. I told him what you told me. NOBODY SIGNS ANYTHING in this building until the owner reads it first.”

“The owner,” Sasha said, like a word she’d never heard.

My mother’s hand went up to Grandma’s pearls.

The notary held the brown envelope out to me.

It was thick, and still sealed.

I put my thumb under the flap.

The missing attachment

The first page said “Release of Family Loan.”

Dad’s name appeared beside “Lender.” Sasha’s appeared beside “Borrower.” The amount was $79,200.

I folded the flap back and put my finger under the paragraph that said Dad would give up his right to repayment.

“What loan?”

Sasha reached for the envelope.

I moved it behind my back.

“There’s an attachment missing,” I said.

The release referred to a Schedule A.

Every page after it was a copy of the same release.

“Your father has the supporting material,” the notary said.

“I haven’t met him yet.”

“Then let’s do that.”

My mother took her phone out.

Dad’s phone came with it, attached to hers by the charging cord.

I knew his case. Jazmin had mailed him the sticker on it.

“Why have you got his phone?”

“He’s celebrating. He doesn’t need interruptions.”

I held out my hand. She pushed both phones into her purse.

The notary turned to Sasha.

“I can’t proceed with an incomplete document. And I’ll need to speak to your father without anyone answering for him.”

My sister gave him the smile she used on people who mistook themselves for participants.

“Of course. This is all very simple.”

It cost me eleven years to become the kind of woman she called complicated.

Hyun opened the door. I took Jazmin’s hand and went inside.

Mother followed close enough to step on my heel.

“You own a share,” she said.

“Don’t embarrass yourself pretending you own a hotel.”

“I lead the ownership group.”

“And we were supposed to know that?”

“No.”

That answer bothered her more than the money.

In the elevator, Sasha pressed fourteen.

“The dinner’s on the roof,” I said.

“We need to speak privately.”

I pressed the rooftop button before she could stop me.

My daughter held the gift bag against her knees.

“Does Grandpa know we’re here?”

Mother put her hand over the rooftop button.

“Your father asked us to keep you away.”

Six envelopes

Dad’s gift was a book Jazmin and I had made that afternoon.

She’d put copies of his six birthday cards inside, beside photographs of herself at each age.

The originals stayed in a tin at home.

On the last page she’d written, “Now you can be in the next picture.”

I hadn’t corrected the crooked line beneath it.

I’d spent enough years making things look acceptable to my family.

While Jazmin worked, I turned over the envelopes.

The first had come to our apartment when she was five.

Dad had sent it through my aunt Alice, who’d kept my address and refused to apologize for keeping it.

Alice was going to the dinner.

She’d offered to meet us downstairs, but Mother had put her to work arranging place cards.

My mother could turn an ally into unpaid staff before she’d removed her coat.

That first envelope held a note for me.

“May I send her something on her birthday? I won’t come where I’m not wanted.”

I’d stood in our kitchen with my work shoes still on.

I called him.

Mother answered.

When I said my name, she said, “Don’t start this again,” and put the phone down.

So I wrote to Dad through Alice.

“You’re wanted. Call me yourself.”

He called twice that year. Both calls were short.

Whenever I mentioned coming over, he said we’d find a better time.

I stopped mentioning it.

That was my part.

I made him choose the door, and when he didn’t open it, I taught myself not to knock.

He kept sending the cards.

Jazmin kept sending replies through Alice. Drawings at first, then letters.

Dad knew about the spelling test she failed and the bicycle she bought with money saved in a pickle jar.

He knew almost nothing about my work.

Neither did Alice. I’d told her I was doing well, which in our family could mean anything from buying property to getting the washing machine repaired.

That afternoon, Jazmin held up the first card.

“Can I put the five dollars back in?”

“Why?”

“He always gives me something.”

I gave her an envelope.

She put five dollars from her jar inside and wrote, “For your birthday.”

Then I tucked our return letters beneath the copies of his cards.

Alice had photographed them before forwarding them, because Dad sometimes misplaced things and wanted another copy.

Six years of ordinary little letters.

There wasn’t one asking him for money.

Now, in the elevator, Mother’s finger stayed over the button until I moved her hand.

Jazmin lifted the gift bag.

“He wanted my picture.”

Mother looked at the bag.

“Keep that closed until we’ve spoken to him.”

The chair beside Dad

Dad stood when the elevator doors opened.

He took one step toward us, then checked Mother’s face.

At eighty, he still did that.

Alice came around the chairs and put her arms around me.

She held on long enough to make Mother clear her throat.

“She’s my niece, Norma,” Alice said. “I’ll finish.”

Dad bent toward Jazmin.

She gave him the bag with both hands.

“Don’t open it yet. Apparently we’re rationing birthday presents,” I said.

He laughed once. Then his eyes filled.

I wanted to put my arms around him.

I also wanted to ask where he’d been when I had forty dollars and a baby who needed shoes.

Both things fit inside me. Neither was comfortable.

Sasha came between us.

“Dad, Camille has some confusion about the paperwork.”

“I haven’t seen it,” he said.

“You’ve seen the figures.”

“The paperwork,” he said again.

A few guests stopped talking.

Among them were two people introduced earlier, according to Alice, as colleagues from Darren’s bank.

Sasha had put them beside Dad. She’d put Alice near the service door.

The seating chart had opinions.

I handed Dad the release.

His glasses were in his pocket.

Mother reached for the page before he got them out.

“Let’s do this in the suite.”

“No,” I said. “He can read here.”

Sasha moved closer to me.

“This is a private family arrangement. Owning a few bricks doesn’t give you a say.”

“No. Being asked to sign gives him one.”

Dad sat. I pulled out the chair beside him.

My mother put her purse on it.

I lifted the purse and gave it back.

It was a small act. My knees shook anyway.

Dad read the first paragraph twice.

“Where’s the list?”

“In my bag,” Mother said.

“May I see it?”

“We discussed this.”

“Then it won’t take long.”

Sasha leaned over his shoulder and pointed at the signature line.

“The figure is what we agreed. We can go through the history another day.”

The notary took off his raincoat.

“I’ll wait outside until you’re ready to speak with me.”

He folded the coat over his arm and went through the doors to the rooftop lobby.

Nobody had arrived to save us.

The man had come to witness a signature.

At least he understood the difference.

I tried the easiest fix first.

“Don’t sign tonight. Take the papers home. Have someone read them with you tomorrow.”

Dad pressed his fingers against the page.

“I told your mother I wanted it settled before my birthday was over.”

“Why?”

Sasha answered.

“Because some of us have carried things for a long time.”

She looked at my blazer again.

I pulled my chair closer to Dad.

“Did you borrow money from Sasha?”

“No,” he said.

“Did she borrow it from you?”

He looked toward Mother.

My sister took the wine glass off the table and set it farther from his elbow.

“We called it a loan for convenience.”

Dad caught my wrist.

“Don’t make me explain this in front of everyone.”

Six hundred dollars

I lowered my voice.

“Then tell me just enough to stop me worrying.”

Dad pushed the paper beneath the gift bag.

“You shouldn’t have come here angry.”

I hadn’t raised my voice.

In my family, asking a question twice counted as throwing furniture.

Alice pulled up another chair.

“She came because the child said you were frightened.”

“I wasn’t frightened.”

“Grandpa,” Jazmin said, “you said you couldn’t get it right.”

Dad looked down at his hand.

Sasha opened her mouth.

Alice put up one finger.

“The child is speaking.”

Jazmin stayed beside me.

“The name. You said Aunt Sasha kept telling you to do it again.”

Dad rubbed his thumb over the back of his other hand.

“It shakes when I’m being hurried.”

“It was practice,” Sasha said. “So there wouldn’t be a problem tonight.”

The notary appeared at the doorway.

“What sort of problem?”

“Nothing,” she said.

Dad answered him.

“She said it needed to look normal. Otherwise people might think I didn’t understand.”

The man came back into the room.

“Your signature doesn’t need to win a handwriting contest.”

Dad gave him a look of such relief that I wanted to throw my sister’s wine into the elevator.

Instead, I moved the release away from Dad’s elbow.

“That settles tonight.”

“No, it doesn’t,” Mother said.

She was still holding her purse with both hands.

“We’ve spent months getting him ready for this.”

Dad looked up.

“Getting the figures ready,” she said.

Sasha turned toward the guests.

“Please, everyone, carry on. My sister enjoys an audience.”

One of the bank guests put down his fork. Nobody carried on.

I asked Dad about the amount.

He stared at the gift bag.

“Six hundred a month,” he said.

“For what?”

He shook his head.

“For how long?”

“Since you left.”

I did the multiplication on my phone because I didn’t trust the answer in my head.

Six hundred dollars. One hundred thirty-two months.

Seventy-nine thousand two hundred dollars.

There it was, down to the last month.

Dad reached for his phone.

Mother said, “It needs charging.”

“It was charged when you took it.”

She put it beside his hand.

He opened his banking app.

It took two tries with the password, and Sasha began helping before he’d asked.

He turned the screen away from her.

The transfers were there. Six hundred dollars to Sasha, month after month.

He scrolled through them while Alice stood behind his chair.

My sister’s name kept coming up.

“Dad,” I said, “why were you paying Sasha?”

His face changed.

“Don’t do that.”

“Do what?”

“Make her say it.”

Sasha folded her arms. My mother sat down.

I looked from one to the other.

My father had sent me five dollars in a birthday card through someone else’s house.

He’d sent my sister six hundred dollars every month without missing one.

He pushed his phone toward me.

“She kept you and that baby off the street.”

I put both hands on the edge of my chair.

There were words ready in my mouth. None of them belonged near Jazmin.

Alice moved beside her.

“Would you help me get some water?”

Jazmin looked at me. I nodded.

They went to the lobby, where I could see them through the glass.

Dad leaned toward me.

“She said you couldn’t bear taking it from me. After what happened.”

Sasha reached for his phone.

I picked it up first.

The first transfer was dated the month my mother told me to enjoy scrubbing tubs.

The gift bag on the floor

“I never received six hundred dollars from Sasha.”

Dad pushed his chair back.

“Camille.”

“Not once.”

Mother stood.

“We’re not going to humiliate your father on his birthday.”

I wanted to ask whether birthdays had a special allowance for theft.

Instead, I asked for the list.

Sasha said, “Money went toward things. Rent. Bills. It wasn’t always handed over.”

“Which rent?”

“You moved constantly.”

“Twice.”

“How am I supposed to remember every address?”

“Pick one.”

She looked at Mother.

Dad’s hand closed into a fist.

“Enough. I won’t have this.”

I reached into the gift bag and took out the book.

“These are the letters Jazmin sent you. Alice kept copies. There’s one from the year our landlord sold the building. You offered to send a birthday present early because she was worried about moving.”

Dad opened the book.

His fingers stopped at that card.

“You said you were managing.”

“We were.”

“Then why did Sasha tell me—”

Mother took the book from him.

“Because Camille didn’t want you worrying. We agreed to keep her business private.”

“We?” I said.

“You weren’t speaking to us.”

“You told me not to call.”

“And yet here you are, making accusations with nothing behind them.”

My first fix had been to postpone the signature.

My second was to put something Dad knew in his hands.

Mother removed both as if she were clearing crumbs.

I took the book back.

Sasha pulled out her phone and moved a few feet away.

She typed, stopped, then put it away when Dad said her name.

“Did you give her the money?”

“Dad, please.”

“Did you?”

“I dealt with what needed dealing with.”

The notary closed his pen.

Dad turned toward me.

“Why would she tell me that if she hadn’t?”

There it was. The question I’d been up against since childhood.

Why would Sasha say it?

Because she could say it in a red dress beside a man from a bank, and I could deny it wearing shoes my mother disliked.

That had been enough before.

I put Dad’s phone beside the release.

“Ask her for one receipt.”

Sasha bent over him.

“There are receipts. There are records. Mom has everything. But I’m not having them read aloud to people we work with.”

“Then give them to him.”

Mother opened her purse an inch, then shut it.

“After Camille leaves.”

Dad looked at me for a long time.

I could see him trying to put eleven years into a shape he could stand.

If I was telling the truth, he’d missed my daughter’s childhood while paying someone to keep him away from it.

Sasha offered him something easier.

“She has money now, Dad. Apparently plenty. She’s embarrassed about how she got through those years. Let her have that.”

I stood so fast my chair struck the wall.

“Don’t you dare.”

Several guests stood too.

Through the glass, Jazmin turned.

Dad put both hands over his ears.

“Stop. Both of you.”

I sat again.

“I’m sorry,” I said to him. “For shouting.”

Mother touched his shoulder.

“You see what this does to him.”

Dad looked at the doorway, where Jazmin stood beside Alice.

“Take her home, Camille.”

I couldn’t make my hand close around the book.

“Dad.”

“Please. Just go.”

Eleven years, and he was asking me to walk out again.

Mother picked up the gift bag and set it on the floor beside my chair.

I put the book inside. One handle tore.

Sasha brought the release back to the center of his place.

“Let’s finish, Dad.”

I reached for Jazmin’s five-dollar envelope before it could fall out.

She’d written “For your birthday” twice.

Once on the front, once under the flap.

Dad stretched out his hand.

I thought he meant the present.

Sasha put her pen in it.

Schedule A

I set the five dollars beside his hand.

“That’s from Jazmin. You can tell her yourself if you don’t want it.”

Dad put down the pen.

His mouth moved before any words came.

“I want it.”

“Then she should hear that.”

I went to the door.

Alice had one hand on Jazmin’s shoulder.

My daughter held two glasses of water, determined to be useful in a room full of adults making a mess.

“He wants your present,” I said.

She went straight to him.

Dad pulled her against his side and began crying into her hair.

Mother reached for the release.

I put my palm on it.

“The attachment. Now.”

“This doesn’t concern you.”

“My name just bought seventy-nine thousand dollars of silence. Show me.”

Dad lifted his head.

“Give it to her, Norma.”

Mother took a folded packet from her purse.

The first sheet listed every monthly transfer.

Beside each amount were the words “Household support delivered to Camille.”

Below the list was a statement for Dad to sign.

He was to confirm that all the money had been used as intended, accept the attached receipts, and give up any claim against Sasha or Mother over its handling.

I read it aloud.

Then I turned the page.

The receipts were printed four to a sheet.

Every one carried a signature that was supposed to be mine.

I took the book from the bag and put the first beside the letter I’d written Dad through Alice.

Sasha reached across me.

“Those are copies.”

Alice caught the packet before it slid off the edge.

“Copies of what?”

Dad took off his glasses and put them on again.

The first receipt said I’d collected cash at my parents’ house in December of the year they sent me away.

On that Christmas Eve, Alice had brought groceries to my apartment.

She’d knocked until I opened the door because I was too ashamed to let anyone see what I didn’t have.

She put her finger on the date.

“I was with Camille. We called you from her kitchen, Norma.”

Mother said nothing.

“You wouldn’t come to the phone.”

Dad turned another page.

The signatures were identical. Every loop. Every dot.

They’d copied my name once and pasted it again and again.

I took the release from beneath my hand and placed it beside the receipts.

“You wanted him to sign that these were real.”

Sasha said, “You have no idea what Mom was trying to prevent.”

Dad pushed back his chair.

“Then tell us.”

The red dress by the door

Sasha stood between Dad and the guests.

“We should never have done this here. I said that from the beginning.”

Dad held up a receipt.

“Did she sign this?”

“She wouldn’t communicate with us.”

“Did she sign it?”

“Someone had to keep a record.”

I stayed beside his chair.

My sister could fill any silence if you let her.

For once, I let her.

“You can’t pretend those years were simple,” she said.

“Mom was beside herself. You wanted to send money. Camille wouldn’t come home. Every conversation became a fight, and somehow I was expected to keep everyone together.”

Dad held the receipt higher.

“Answer me.”

“No. She didn’t sign that particular sheet.”

Alice put the whole packet in front of her.

“Choose one she did.”

Sasha looked toward the bank guests.

One of them moved his chair away from hers.

It was barely a foot. She followed it with her eyes.

“You don’t understand,” she said to him. “This is family business.”

He picked up his coat.

“I understood her question.”

Mother stood in his path.

“Please. We can explain.”

He went around her. The other bank guest followed.

Sasha put both hands over her face.

For the shove, she’d laughed. For the receipts, she’d argued.

Two people leaving with their coats broke her.

Dad waited until the door closed.

“Where is the money?”

Mother said, “It’s safe.”

My sister dropped her hands.

“Mom.”

“Most of it is safe.”

Dad turned toward her.

“You told me she needed it.”

“She did need it. She needed to come home and stop making everything so difficult.”

Alice took Jazmin back to the doorway.

My daughter carried the gift book with her.

Mother reached for Dad’s arm.

“I wasn’t going to send household money out every month while she refused to speak to us.”

“You told me it was going to her.”

“You would’ve sent it anyway.”

“Yes.”

“And then she would’ve had no reason to come back.”

Dad pulled his arm away.

My mother stood with her hand still out.

She tried me next.

“You own a hotel. You’re hardly suffering.”

I thought of a winter coat I’d worn indoors while Jazmin slept.

Of counting laundry quarters into my palm.

All the small things I’d stopped telling people because there was nothing they could do.

“You didn’t know that.”

Sasha began crying.

“I kept telling her we needed to stop. That’s why I wanted this settled.”

Dad looked down at the release.

“So I’d say you owed me nothing.”

“You called it a loan,” she said.

“You always called it a loan when you sent it.”

“Because you said Camille would be ashamed of charity.”

Sasha sat.

Mother remained standing.

“We can put it back,” she said.

Dad didn’t answer.

“We can. Sasha has some. The rest is in my savings.”

“You have it?”

“I kept it separate.”

“From whom?”

She sat down beside him.

He moved his chair.

That scraped floor did more than all my words.

Sasha took out her phone.

“I have eighteen thousand two hundred forty dollars and sixty-three cents. I can send that now.”

Dad looked at me.

I gave him his phone.

“Your money. Your decision.”

He opened the account details and put the screen in front of her.

“Send it.”

Sasha’s fingers shook enough that she entered the amount twice.

She turned her screen toward him.

Dad waited until the credit appeared on his own.

Then he faced Mother.

“Sixty thousand nine hundred fifty-nine dollars and thirty-seven cents.”

“I can’t do all that on a Saturday night.”

“Then you can do it Monday morning.”

“You’re making this sound—”

“Monday.”

She nodded.

He pulled the release away from the packet.

The notary stood near the door with his raincoat over his arm.

“I won’t be signing,” Dad said.

The man nodded, put his pen away, and left.

Sasha reached for the receipts.

Dad put them inside the gift book’s empty bag.

“Those stay with me.”

Mother said, “There’s no need to keep punishing us.”

He looked at Jazmin in the doorway.

“Come here, sweetheart.”

She came with the book held against her chest.

Dad opened it to the last page.

“Now you can be in the next picture.”

He read it aloud and started crying again.

“I’m sorry,” he said to me.

I couldn’t give him eleven years back. I couldn’t give myself that either.

“You can call tomorrow.”

“I will.”

Mother put a hand on his chair.

“We should go home.”

Dad looked at Alice.

“Can I stay with you tonight?”

Alice took his coat from the back of the chair.

“Yes.”

Sasha came toward me as Dad stood.

“You could’ve taken me aside. You didn’t have to do this in front of them.”

“You chose the room.”

Monday, 10:06

Mother came to Alice’s house on Monday with her phone and Sasha.

Dad asked me to be there.

Jazmin was at school.

She knew Grandpa was staying with Alice and that nobody was signing those papers.

That was enough work for a ten-year-old.

Mother sat on the sofa without taking off her coat.

“I want to know what happens after I send this.”

Dad sat opposite her.

“You’ll have returned my money.”

“And us?”

“We’re talking about the money.”

She looked at me.

I was holding a mug Alice had handed me without asking.

My mother disliked drinking tea outside a kitchen. I drank some.

Sasha opened her phone.

Mother sent $60,959.37.

Dad’s screen changed at 10:06.

He read the amount aloud, then added Sasha’s transfer from Saturday.

“Seventy-nine thousand two hundred.”

He set down the phone.

Mother began crying.

He gave her the tissue box. He didn’t move back home.

Sasha still had another bill.

Dad showed her the hotel charges she’d put on his card: $3,487.50 for the suite.

“You told me that was for guests who couldn’t drive home.”

“We needed somewhere to get ready.”

“Then you can pay for it.”

She said she’d need to sell a bracelet.

“Then sell it,” he said.

On Friday, she came back to Alice’s without the bracelet.

Dad checked the repayment while she stood in the doorway.

She asked whether he’d come to her house on Sunday.

“No.”

“For how long are you going to do this?”

He put the phone in his own pocket.

“I’ll call when I’m ready.”

Mother stopped carrying his phone. Sasha stopped receiving six hundred dollars a month.

Dad kept the receipts.

The birthday book stayed beside his bed at Alice’s.

When I came to collect him the next Saturday, he was wearing his coat an hour early.

“Where are we going?” he said.

“Jazmin has instructions.”

The picture with three people

She’d asked him to come to our apartment before we went anywhere.

Dad stood in the hallway holding the book.

I opened the door, and he waited.

“You don’t need an appointment,” I said.

He stepped inside.

Jazmin came out of her room with the green dress on again.

This time the tights were different.

Dad held up the book.

“I brought it back so we can finish it.”

“It’s not finished for a long time,” she said.

“Good.”

She led him into the kitchen and showed him where we’d taken the picture before the dinner.

Then she handed me my phone.

“You have longer arms.”

Dad stood beside her, careful about where he put his hands.

She took one and put it around her shoulder.

I held up the phone.

His face filled the corner of the screen.

He looked at me instead of the camera.

“I should’ve called you,” he said.

“Yes.”

“I should’ve come.”

“Yes.”

His eyes filled.

I lowered the phone.

“You’re here now. Take your coat off.”

He did.

Jazmin hung it on the hook beside her schoolbag.

Then she came back and fitted herself between us.

I held the phone out again.

The three of us barely fit. Dad leaned closer.

“Is this all right?”

Jazmin put her cheek against his.

“Closer, Grandpa.”

If this one got to you, send it to someone who still has room in a family picture.

For more family drama and hidden power plays, read the twin sister who didn’t know whose company her fiancé was investigating and the kitchen door that shut one twin out.