My Mother Found Our Babysitter, and My Daughter Switched Hands for Her

Rachel Kim

The grape juice stain never came out. My mother flipped that tablecloth over thirty years ago and has set it upside down ever since, so the good side faces the floor and nobody but me knows.

I was thinking about that stain on Sunday at 6:30, when the roast came out in my parents’ dining room in Sandusky. My dad was turning 70 and acting as if it were no big deal. My mom had the carving knife. Alisha sat across from me, Kara on my left with the rolls, and the two kids were at the card table beside the window.

By 6:50 my mother had already lit the two numeral candles on the cake, with half the roast still sitting there, because she sets the schedule.

Carson, nine and in charge of everyone, signed the fishing card in pencil and pushed a purple marker at Eden. She took the cap off with her left hand, then moved the marker over to her right.

She has been a lefty since she was two.

Her name came out crooked and drunk.

“Since when are you a righty, Bug?” I said.

“Miss Dianne says I have to use this one now.”

Miss Dianne. The woman we’d paid $210 every Friday for nine weeks. My mother’s friend from the same pew for twenty-five years. My mother found her for us.

“Because the other one gets hurt,” Eden said, and turned her left wrist over.

Three oval marks, side by side, like fingertips. Yellow and green at the edges, about ten days old. I know that color from hockey.

My chair went back. My dad told me to sit. I sat and counted the squares in the tablecloth. Eden told me not to be mad. She said it was an accident. She said she got a lollipop.

My mother kept carving.

At 7:05 Kara had her phone under the tablecloth, and she was dialing.

7:40

Kara didn’t get up. She said, “Yes. I need to report a child being hurt,” in her normal voice, the one she uses to order a pizza, and every adult at that table heard it.

My mother put the knife down for real that time.

“Kara,” she said. “Hang that up.”

Kara gave our address. Then she gave my parents’ address. Then she spelled Halverson, H-A-L-V, slowly, and looked straight at my mother while she did it.

“You are making a scene on his birthday,” my mother said.

“Yes,” Kara said, and asked the dispatcher how long.

Thirty-five minutes. I know because I watched the clock on the microwave through the kitchen door the entire time, and the wax 7 burned down to a stub that looked like a melted fork.

My dad finally got up and blew out the candles. One breath. He’s still got it.

“Happy birthday, Gilberto,” Alisha said, like a joke, and nobody laughed, and she put her face in her hands.

Eden kept working on her N.

I wanted to pick her up and drive to Dianne Halverson’s house and stand on her lawn. I didn’t, because I knew if I got in that truck I wasn’t coming back as somebody Eden would want to hug. So I sat on the floor next to the card table, which is not built for a 36-year-old man, and I let my daughter color on my knee with her wrong hand.

At 7:40 the doorbell went.

Deputy Garrity was maybe forty, with a mustache that had given up halfway and a voice like a gym teacher’s. He wiped his boots on my mother’s mat twice. My mother noticed. I watched her notice.

He crouched by the card table. His knees popped like bubble wrap.

“Hi. I’m Lee,” he said to Eden. “That’s a pretty serious card.”

“It’s Grandpa’s. He’s seventy.”

“That’s old,” Lee Garrity said, and my dad said, “Thank you, Deputy,” and Eden almost smiled.

He asked if he could see her arm. She held it out the way you’d hold out a library book. He looked. He didn’t touch. He asked Kara if he could take a picture and she said yes before he finished the question.

Then he asked Eden the question I hadn’t thought to ask.

“Did you show anybody else this, Eden? Before tonight?”

She nodded.

“Who’d you show?”

Eden turned around in her little chair and pointed across the room with the purple marker.

“Grandma. Last Sunday. In the bathroom.”

I have never heard a room go that quiet. The fridge was louder than all seven of us.

“Grandma said she’d call Miss Dianne,” Eden said. “And she did. And Miss Dianne said it was an accident. So it was okay.”

My mother was standing at the end of the table with a dish towel in both hands.

Deputy Garrity stood up slowly. Pop, pop.

“Ma’am,” he said. “Is that right?”

The good tablecloth

She folded the towel in half before she answered. Then in half again.

“It was an accident,” my mother said. “Dianne told me herself. Eden grabbed the stove handle, and Dianne caught her arm, and she held on too tight. She was upset about it. She cried on the phone, Javier.”

“She cried,” I said.

“She’s been through a lot this year. Her husband’s back. The roof.”

“Mom. Eden’s six.”

“I know how old my granddaughter is.”

“Then why didn’t you tell us?”

She lifted her chin. “Because you’d do this.” She waved the towel at the deputy, at Kara’s phone, at the dead candles. “You’d ruin a woman over one bad afternoon. I’ve known Dianne Halverson since before you could drive. She taught you Sunday school.”

“She taught me the Ten Commandments,” I said. “Apparently she skipped one.”

Kara put her hand on my back. Not to stop me. To let me know she was there.

Deputy Garrity had his notebook out. He wrote while my mother talked, and she watched the pen, and I think that was when she understood what kind of night it was.

“Mrs. Correa,” he said. “When you called Ms. Halverson last week, did she mention any other children? Any other parents?”

And my mother, who decides when things happen, said the one thing she’d decided not to.

“Only the Tariq woman,” she said. “From October. And that girl’s always been clumsy, Dianne said.”

The deputy wrote that down too.

My father stood up.

He’s not a stander. He’s a sitter, a recliner, a man who’s been telling the same fishing story since 1983. But he put both fists on the table and got up, and his napkin fell into his gravy, and he didn’t even look at it.

“Another mother,” he said. “In October. And you knew.”

“Gil, sit down. Your heart.”

“My heart’s fine. My heart’s the only thing in this house working.” He was shaking. “You looked at that baby’s arm in our bathroom. Our bathroom, Francesca. And then you let her go back to that woman’s house on Monday.”

“I didn’t let her go anywhere. Kara drops her off.”

“Because you told Kara that woman was safe!”

That was the loudest I’ve heard my father in my life, and I’ve watched him lose a walleye at the side of the boat.

Alisha was crying openly now. Carson had gone over to Eden’s table and was sitting next to her, holding the pencil like a sword. Nine years old, and he’d decided whose side he was on. Good kid.

My mother looked at all of us, one at a time. She was waiting for somebody to say it was fine. That’s how it always goes. She closes the subject and somebody brings out the coffee.

Nobody brought out the coffee.

“Javier,” she said. “Say something.”

I got up off the floor. My knees didn’t pop, which felt like a win.

“Eden,” I said. “Can you show Grandma your arm one more time?”

Eden looked at me. I nodded. She walked across the room in her socks, past the deputy, past her grandpa standing there with gravy on his napkin, and held her wrist up to my mother. Palm out.

“It doesn’t hurt now,” Eden said. “Only when she holds it.”

My mother looked down.

I’ve known that mouth since I was born. It’s pressed shut for thirty-six years whenever she’s decided something is over. I watched it come open. I watched her chin go.

She sat down hard on a dining chair and put her hand over her face and made a sound I didn’t know she owned.

“I’m sorry, baby,” she said into her hand. “Grandma’s so sorry.”

“It’s okay,” Eden said. “It was an accident.”

“No,” my mother said, and it came out ripped. “No, it wasn’t. Grandma was wrong.”

Deputy Garrity let that sit for a decent second. Then he asked my mother if she’d be willing to give a statement about the phone call. All of it. The October mother. Dianne’s own words.

She looked at me for help. I didn’t give any.

“Yes,” she said.

He took her into the kitchen. Twenty minutes. Through the door I could hear her voice going up and down and once, very clearly, “Twenty-five years.” Nobody else spoke. My dad finally pulled his napkin out of the gravy and looked at it like it had betrayed him personally.

When the deputy left at 8:31, he shook my hand and Kara’s and told us a caseworker would call in the morning, and that the state licensing people move fast on home daycares when there’s a picture and more than one family.

At the door, he turned back to Eden.

“You did good showing your arm, kiddo.”

“I know,” she said.

Friday

The caseworker called Monday at 8:15 a.m. Her name was Rachelle Wright and she said “okay” after everything I said, which I found weirdly calming.

On Tuesday, November 10, two days after the dinner, the state suspended Dianne Halverson’s home daycare license.

Effective that afternoon. No more kids through her door. Rachelle told us the Tariq family’s complaint from October had been sitting on Dianne’s own kitchen counter, never sent anywhere, and now it was in a file with Eden’s picture on top. She told us Dianne had a hearing coming and a deputy asking her questions, and that was as much as she could say.

It was enough. I’m not a lawn-standing man anymore. I checked.

Kara spent Wednesday on the phone with her boss and a woman from our church who runs an actual licensed center with cameras in every room and a sign-in sheet you could audit. Kara asked about the cameras four times. The woman didn’t blink.

On Wednesday night Mai Tariq found Kara’s number through the school and called her. The two of them were on the phone for an hour and ten minutes. I could hear Kara in the bedroom saying, “I know. I know. Me too.” When she came out her eyes were red and she was furious, which is my wife’s favorite combination.

“Dianne told her it was a door,” Kara said. “Her daughter’s arm. A door.”

“And my mom,” I said.

“Your mom knew there was a door,” Kara said, and went to bed.

My mother called four times that week. I let it ring.

My father called once, Tuesday night. “Your mother went to the pastor,” he said. “Told him. In his office, in front of the deacons, everything. Dianne’s off the altar guild. Your mother quit the altar guild too. Twenty-five years.” He was quiet a second. “She doesn’t know what to do with Thursdays now.”

“She’ll think of something,” I said.

“She’s sitting in the other pew now, Javi. The one by the furnace. By herself.”

I didn’t say anything. I didn’t have to.

Today is Friday, November 13.

Every Friday since September, at noon, Kara’s phone has made a little whoosh when the $210 went to Dianne Halverson. This morning at noon it didn’t. Kara held her phone in her hand at the kitchen counter and waited for the sound out of habit, and when it didn’t come, she laughed out loud, a short ugly laugh, and then cried over the sink for about one minute, and then made a sandwich.

Nine weeks. $1,890. Rachelle says we can go after it. Kara says she’ll get every cent of it if she has to stand in Dianne’s driveway with a coffee can. I believe her. She argues with the GPS.

At four o’clock somebody knocked.

My mother was on the porch in her church coat, holding the fishing card.

She looked smaller. Not old. Smaller. Like somebody had let a little air out of her.

“Your father wants the card,” she said. “He wants it signed right.”

I took it. I didn’t open the door wider.

“Can I see her?” my mother said.

“Not today, Mom.”

She nodded. She’d expected that. She didn’t press her lips together. She didn’t close anything. She just stood there on my mat with her hands empty.

“I’ll be at the hearing,” she said. “Rachelle asked me to come say it again. I’m going to.”

“Good,” I said.

She walked back to her car. She didn’t look back until she got to the door handle, and then she did, once, at the front window, where Eden was standing with her face on the glass.

My mother lifted her hand. Eden lifted hers. The left one.

I shut the door.

Eden was already at the coffee table with the purple marker. I put the card in front of her, open, next to the crawling, crooked name from Sunday.

“Grandpa says redo,” I said.

She looked at her right hand. Then she looked at me.

“Which one, Daddy?”

“Whichever one’s yours, Bug.”

She took the cap off. She put the marker in her left hand and held it there for a second, like she was checking it still fit.

The marks on her wrist were almost gone. Just a little yellow, like old tape.

She wrote E. A real E. Straight lines, nobody’s fence, no truck. Then D-E-N, big and fat and purple, right across the fish.

She held it up to me.

“There,” she said. “Now it’s his.”

If this one stayed with you, send it to someone who leaves their kid with somebody every afternoon, and tell them to look at the wrists.

For more family secrets and difficult choices, read the hospital paper my son kept with my name at the top, the old dog my ex-wife chained under her mother’s window, and the golf bags my father moved into Grandpa’s house before the funeral.