My Husband’s Girlfriend Pushed Me Down in Courtroom Three in Shreveport

Maya Lin

The saltines were the first thing I counted.

Half a sleeve left, lying on the carpet by my knee, and I remember thinking I’d need them before lunch, as if lunch were still coming. My hip was on fire. The rest of me was trying to work out whether the kick I’d just felt meant Meera was fine or meant something else.

Ms. Gibson had done it from behind. She waited for Anton, the deputy, to look at the door, and then she leaned her whole weight into my shoulder and the courtroom railing took me down. She was twenty-four, in tan boots I couldn’t have bought with a month’s rent, and she said, “She ran into me. Y’all watched her do it.”

Nobody had watched anything. Five strangers in the gallery were studying their own shoes.

My husband stayed at his table in the navy suit I’d paid off for his mother’s sixtieth. Jody had a settlement on that table and a pen beside it: one wire, $18,500, the house and the joint account and the crib fund to him, and a custody schedule Eugene Tate had typed for a girl who hadn’t been born. He wanted my signature before noon on a Thursday.

Thanh was on her knees with her hand on my back. Tate, seventy-one, stood and told Judge Webb about my “history.” The February records. The ice storm. The steps Jody locked me out onto.

Then Jody finally looked at me. “Get off the floor, Shay,” he said. “Nobody here believes you.”

What nobody in that room knew was that I’d lived in the judge’s house when I was six. Florence Webb. Her cereal-box bookmark with her old number and a star on it had slid out of my bag to the foot of her bench.

She had Anton hand it up. She turned it over once. She shouted at Tate that she’d been watching. She told Jody she’d known me twenty-eight years.

Then she lifted the bench phone and asked for the district attorney, and said she’d wait.

The folder under her gavel

She did wait. We all did.

It’s a strange thing, waiting on hold in a room with thirteen people in it. The court reporter put her hands in her lap. One of the strangers in the back row, a man in a Saints cap, slowly took his earbuds out. Anton stood at the bottom of the bench steps with his thumbs hooked in his belt like he’d decided that was his spot now and he was keeping it.

I was still on the floor. Thanh got one arm under mine.

“Don’t stand,” Judge Webb said, without looking up. “Ms. Nguyen, she stays down until somebody with a stethoscope says otherwise. Deputy, call it in.”

So Thanh’s last name went on the record, and so did an ambulance, and I sat on the courtroom carpet with my back against the railing that had just put me there, eating a saltine, because I am who I am.

Eugene Tate was the first to recover. Of course he was. He’d been in rooms like this since 1985.

He stood up, buttoned his jacket, and said, “Your Honor, in light of what appears to be a personal relationship between the Court and the petitioner, the respondent moves for recusal. Immediately. On the record.”

Jody sat back. He actually looked relieved. He tugged the left cuff again.

Judge Webb said, “Granted.”

Tate blinked. He had a whole second paragraph ready. You could see it sitting in his mouth with nowhere to go.

“Granted, Mr. Tate. And you’re about a week late.” She opened a manila folder that had been under her elbow the whole morning and held up one typed page. “This is my disclosure to the parties. It’s dated last Thursday. I pulled this file, I read the petitioner’s prior name in the intake sheet, and I knew who she was. I was going to read this aloud at nine-thirty, transfer the case to Judge Grayson, and step off.”

She set the page down.

“Then your client’s girlfriend put her on my floor before I could get to it. So I’m not just stepping off. I’m a witness now. And a witness doesn’t sit up here.”

I hadn’t known. I want that clear. I’d walked in that morning sure she wouldn’t know me, half praying she wouldn’t, because the last thing I wanted was for the one adult who’d ever drilled a phone number into me to watch me lose.

She’d known for a week. She’d read Shayla Pruitt on a form and kept it to herself, because that was the rule, and she followed rules like other people breathe.

The phone clicked. She picked it back up.

“Lamar. Florence. I need someone from your office in courtroom three. A pregnant woman, thirty-one weeks, was pushed into my rail by a non-party. I saw it from four feet. Yes. Yes, I’ll give a statement. No, I’m off the case, I’m done with it as of right now.”

She hung up.

Ms. Gibson said, “This is insane.” She said it to Jody. “Babe. Tell her this is insane.”

Jody didn’t tell anybody anything.

Ms. Gibson tried again, to the room this time. “She literally fell. She’s pregnant, they fall.”

“Ms. Gibson,” Judge Webb said, “every word you say right now goes to the district attorney with my name next to it. I would think very hard about the next one.”

It’s the only time I’ve ever seen that woman think hard about anything. She sat down in the first row of the gallery, in the tan boots, and crossed her arms, and nobody stopped her because Anton had moved to stand right beside her.

That’s when Thanh did the thing I will love her for until I die.

She went to our table, pulled the thick binder Tate had served on us Monday, and flipped to the tab marked FEB. The ER records. Tate’s own exhibit. The one he’d just stood up and called my history.

“Your Honor, before you step down. For the record, since the respondent filed these.” She read it flat. “Triage note, February eleventh, 11:52 p.m. ‘Patient states she slipped on steps. Husband present, standing directly behind patient, answers questions for her. Patient looks at husband before each answer. Patient declined private interview.'”

She closed the binder.

“That’s his history, Mr. Tate. You filed it.”

Tate’s face did what Jody’s face had never done in five years of marriage. It went red from the collar up, slowly, the way a thermometer does in a cartoon.

He leaned toward his client and said something under his breath. Jody said, out loud, “You told me those helped us.”

I laughed. On the floor. With a cracker in my hand. It hurt my hip and I didn’t care.

Judge Webb gathered the folder, the disclosure, and her glasses chain. She stood, and the robe made her look taller than I remembered, which is funny, because I was six the last time and she’d looked like a building to me then.

She came down the three steps. She knelt next to Thanh, on the carpet, in the robe.

“Your hip,” she said.

“Just my hip, I think.”

“You still say ‘I think’ after everything.” She shook her head. “You did that at six. ‘I brushed my teeth, I think.'”

She put the bookmark in my hand. The tape was warm from her palm.

“I’ll give it back to you properly when I’m not a witness,” she said. “For now, hold your place.”

The ambulance crew came through the double doors. Right behind them came a woman in a gray pantsuit with a DA’s badge on a lanyard, and she walked straight past my husband to the girl in the tan boots.

Judge Grayson’s courtroom

Meera was fine.

The ER kept me four hours on a monitor, and the doctor, a tall boy named Ravi who looked like he’d graduated that morning, said the heartbeat was “frankly showing off.” My hip was a bruise the size and color of an eggplant. I was home by six.

Not Jody’s home. Thanh’s guest room, where her cat sat on my stomach all night like he’d been told to.

The district attorney’s office charged Ms. Gibson the next Tuesday. Battery on a pregnant woman. The witness statement attached to it was signed Florence A. Webb, and Thanh printed it out and handed it to me without a word, and I read it nine times. It was two pages long. It described the boots.

It took five weeks to get back in front of a judge. Judge Grayson, courtroom five, one floor up. Same building, same freezer air. I was thirty-six weeks by then and walked like a sofa being moved by two people who disagree.

Jody’s mother was in the gallery.

That was Thanh’s idea. I’d said, “Why would she come?” and Thanh said, “Because I told her what she’d be hearing, and a woman who bought her son a navy suit wants to know what he does in it.”

Kay Dupree was sixty-five and sat in the second row with her purse on her knees. She wouldn’t look at me. That was fine. She wasn’t there for me.

Ms. Gibson was not there. Her lawyer had told her to stay out of every courtroom in Caddo Parish that didn’t have her name on the docket.

Eugene Tate was there, and he was not the same man. He’d lost the invoice voice. He spoke like the customer now.

Jody had come in loud. He’d brought a binder of his own and a new suit, charcoal, nobody paid it off in installments. In the hallway he’d tried to catch my arm and Thanh had said, “Touch her and I’ll have the deputy write down which hand,” and he’d put it in his pocket.

Inside, he talked first and longest.

“Your Honor, I want to be heard, because none of this is fair. I run nine businesses in this city. My face is on I-49. I have employees with families. And a judge, a judge who, it turns out, babysat my wife, decides to call the DA on my—on an employee of mine. On no evidence.”

Judge Grayson was in his fifties and had the look of a man who’d heard every kind of sentence that begins with “I run.”

“Mr. Dupree, the evidence is a sitting judge who saw it.”

“She’s biased.”

“She’s a witness. Bias is for the jury in Ms. Gibson’s case.” He turned a page. “I’m here about temporary orders, custody of an unborn child, and a settlement your attorney drafted. Mr. Tate?”

Tate stood. He looked at Jody, then at Kay Dupree in the second row, and then down at the table.

“Your Honor, the respondent withdraws the proposed custody schedule.”

Jody turned his whole body. “We did not discuss that.”

“We discussed it Friday,” Tate said, quietly. “You didn’t listen.”

Then Thanh stood. She didn’t raise her voice. She doesn’t have to. She read the triage note again, the whole thing, slowly, with Jody’s mother three rows back.

Husband present, standing directly behind patient, answers questions for her.

Then she added something I hadn’t heard before. “The night of February eleventh, the National Weather Service had Shreveport at nineteen degrees. The respondent’s own home security log, produced in discovery, shows the back door locked from inside at 10:41 p.m. and unlocked at 11:06. Twenty-five minutes, Your Honor. On iced steps. At twenty-two weeks.”

Kay Dupree made a sound. Not a word. The sound you make when you put a foot down on a stair that isn’t there.

Jody heard it. He turned around in his chair.

“Mama, she’s lying, she always—”

“Is the door log lying, Jody?” Kay said.

Everyone in that room stopped. The judge stopped. The court reporter’s hands stopped.

Jody stood up. “I don’t have to sit here and be—”

“Sit DOWN,” his mother said. She didn’t stand. She didn’t have to. “You sat for that girl. You can sit for me.”

And he did. He sat down, in his charcoal suit, at forty-two years old, because his mother told him to, and he put his face in his hands.

I wanted to say something. I had a whole thing in my head about the steps and the cold and how I’d counted the minutes out loud to keep the baby company. What I said, when Judge Grayson asked if petitioner wished to be heard, was, “No, sir. I think he’s heard.”

Judge Grayson ruled from the bench.

The settlement offer was off the table and the record would show why. The proposed custody schedule was stricken in full. Temporary sole custody to the mother upon birth, any contact by the father supervised, pending the final decree. Exclusive use and occupancy of the marital home to the petitioner. The joint account frozen, half released to her within ten days. And the crib fund, which Jody had moved into a business account in March, returned to the petitioner “in its entirety, to the cent.”

It was $4,212.37. I’d put in eleven dollars a week since the first positive test. The thirty-seven cents was from a jar of change.

Jody didn’t look at me when he walked out. He looked at the floor, the whole way down the aisle. His mother didn’t follow him.

She came to my table instead, purse in both hands.

“I bought him that navy suit,” she said. “You paid for it, didn’t you.”

“Every month for a year.”

She nodded, like that was one more thing she’d have to carry, and walked out after all.

Two chapters

Meera was born on a Sunday at 4:10 in the afternoon, seven pounds, one ounce, with a voice on her like a smoke alarm.

The billboard on I-49 came down that December. It wasn’t me. It was Jody’s lenders, who did not want their money’s face next to the words in the paper, and Ms. Gibson’s plea took up four inches of the Times on a Thursday. Pleaded guilty. Probation, anger classes, a protective order, restitution for my emergency room bill to the dollar. She resigned as operations coordinator the same week. Five of the nine shops are for sale now. The settlement on the house closed in my name in March.

I didn’t call Florence. She called me.

She couldn’t before, not while she was a witness in an open case. The day after the plea, a number I didn’t know rang at 7:30 in the morning. I almost didn’t answer.

“It’s Florence,” she said. “Is she sleeping?”

“Nobody here sleeps.”

“Good. I’m bringing a book.”

She came that Saturday to the house. My house. She was out of the robe, in jeans and a cardigan, gray hair the same, glasses on the chain, carrying a paperback in a grocery bag like it was contraband. It was the same book. The actual same title she’d read me in 1998, a different copy, with the corners already soft.

“I looked for my old one,” she said. “I gave it to Goodwill in 2003. I’ve never forgiven myself.”

We sat on my couch. I had Meera on my chest, asleep for once, breathing that little wet whistle that makes you hold still. Florence put on her glasses. She opened the book to the first page, then stopped and looked at me over the frames.

“You never called,” she said.

There it was.

“It got disconnected when I was thirteen,” I said.

“I know. I moved. I kept looking for a way to get you the new one and your mother kept moving faster than the mail.” She took her glasses off again and let them drop. “But February, Shayla.”

“I didn’t think it still counted.”

“It always counted.”

I didn’t have anything to say to that. I cried instead, a lot, loud enough that Meera woke and joined in, and Florence took the baby off me without asking, the way she used to take a hot pan off a burner, and walked her around my living room until both of us quit.

Then she sat back down and reached into the grocery bag again.

It was a cereal box. Bran flakes, the kind she always kept. She took kitchen scissors out of her purse, because of course she carries scissors, and cut a long rectangle from the back. She wrote her number on it in black marker. Her new one. She drew the star.

She had packing tape in that purse too. She sealed it, front and back, and punched a hole with a pen, and tied a piece of red yarn through it. New red.

She held it out. Not to me. To the baby.

Meera grabbed the tassel and put it straight in her mouth.

“That’s fine,” Florence said. “She can learn the number later.”

She opened the book and slid the bookmark in at the first page. Then she looked at me, and I knew exactly what she was going to say before she said it.

“Anybody lays a hand on either one of you,” she said, “you dial this. I don’t care what hour it is.”

“I’ll dial it,” I said.

“Say it back.”

I said her new number back to her, all ten digits, with my eyes shut.

“Two chapters,” she said, and started to read.

If this one got to you, pass it to the woman you know who still has somebody’s number tucked away and has never called it.

For more jaw-dropping family betrayals, read about the daughter left at a snowed-in cabin and the twin whose sister tried to rewrite their story; for a neighbor dispute with a stubborn twist, there’s also the blocked beagle’s vet visit.