My Daughter Wore Orange Rain Boots to Face Him

Maya Lin

At five in the morning the orange rain boots were already standing by our front door, toes pointed at the hallway, like they’d decided to go even if she hadn’t.

Hana picked them out herself. It wasn’t raining. It hadn’t rained all week.

For eleven weeks my nine-year-old had needed the hallway lit to sleep, then her lamp lit too, then an open bedroom door so she could watch both. The man who did that to her lived two floors up. I took the stairs the whole fall so we’d never share an elevator with him. I bought a lock. I switched doors. None of those changes reached her.

The night before court, while I folded her gray sweater, she sat on her bed and asked me, “Can he see my face when I talk?”

I told her I’d be right there. She heard what I didn’t say, and she turned away to face the wall. I watched the couch clock go from one to five.

Thursday, November 13th, I parked in the Kankakee county courthouse lot at 8:50. She was due on the stand at 9:30. I reached for my bag and heard the lock click. Hana was flat against the far door, knees up, saying no until her voice cracked. The prosecutor had told me in August that without Hana he went home. I could have pulled her out. I wouldn’t hand her to him already broken.

At 8:56 her teacher, Mrs. Urbina, texted me: “Look out your window.”

Thirty-two riders stood on the steps, sixteen to a side, leaving a path up the middle. Hana unlocked her own door. A gray-bearded man named Gerardo knelt on the wet asphalt and asked, “Want some company going in?” She took his hand and walked up between them in those boots.

At the glass doors she asked him if he’d still be there when she came out.

He didn’t answer. He was staring at the lot behind me. Then the rider nearest me stepped across the path.

Two floors up

I turned around anyway. I’ve never been good at being told not to look.

He was coming up from the far end of the lot with a man in a navy suit carrying a leather briefcase. Bradley Winslow. Fifty-eight, tan raincoat, the same raincoat he wore to get his mail every morning, the same one he wore the day he held the elevator for us in July and said Hana was getting so tall.

He was walking straight at the front doors. At the path. At her.

Nobody had told me he’d use the front. I’d assumed they kept people like him in a basement somewhere and brought them up through a pipe.

The rider who’d stepped in front of me was a big man, red beard going white, a vest with a little flag patch, and he didn’t say a word. He just stood where my view of the lot used to be.

On the left, the sixteen moved first. They didn’t hurry. They came down two steps at a time and shoulder to shoulder, and then the right side did it too, and in about four seconds the path up the middle was gone. There was a wall of leather at the bottom of the steps, and the only way through it was through thirty-two men.

Winslow stopped about ten feet short.

“Excuse me,” the lawyer said. “My client has a hearing.”

Nobody answered him. Nobody moved. One of them was chewing gum, slowly, like he had all day and a second pack.

“This is a public building,” the lawyer said.

“Side door’s open,” the red-bearded one said. “Around the corner. Real nice ramp.”

Winslow looked up the steps. He was looking for her. I knew that face from the mailroom, the friendly-neighbor face, and I watched it try to find my daughter’s face over thirty-two shoulders.

It didn’t find it. Gerardo had already turned Hana by the shoulders and walked her through the glass doors. All Winslow got was me.

I’d like to tell you I said something wonderful. I didn’t. I stood there with my car keys sticking out between my fingers like a woman in a self-defense pamphlet and stared at him until he looked away first.

He and the lawyer went around the corner. The gum-chewer watched them all the way.

Inside, Gerardo was crouched in the lobby, letting Hana show him how the metal detector beeped at her boots. The buckles. She was almost smiling.

“You knew him,” I said.

He stood up slow. “Knew of him.”

“From where?”

He looked at Hana, then at me, and lowered his voice so it was just for the grown-up.

“Six years ago I walked a girl up these same steps. Eleven years old. Different girl, same man. She got as far as that bench.” He pointed at a wooden bench by the elevators. “And she couldn’t. Saw him in this lobby, buying a coffee out of that machine, and she couldn’t. They dropped it by lunch.”

I looked at the coffee machine. It was the ugliest thing in Illinois.

“So when I saw him coming up the lot,” Gerardo said, “I wasn’t letting him buy a coffee.”

My phone buzzed again. Mrs. Urbina. “Are you in?”

I typed with my thumb shaking. “Did you call them?”

The dots went for a long time.

“I found them in September. I called every week. I’m sorry I didn’t ask you. I thought you’d say no.”

She was right. I’d have said no. I’d have said we didn’t need anybody, the way I said I’d be right there instead of answering the question my kid asked.

“She’s in,” I typed. “Thank you.” Then I deleted the period and put three hearts, because I am forty-two and that’s how I cry in a lobby.

Nanette Mazzola, the prosecutor, came off the elevator at 9:14 in a blue suit with her reading glasses on her head and stopped dead when she saw the window. The whole front of the courthouse was leather.

“Well,” she said. “That’s new.”

Then she knelt in front of Hana and asked if she was ready, and Hana looked up at Gerardo.

“You didn’t say,” Hana said. “If you’ll be here.”

He took a long time. He gets down on one knee like it costs him money, and he did it again anyway.

“Kiddo, there are thirty-two of us,” he said. “We’re not good at leaving.”

The screen

The courtroom was smaller than on TV and colder, and somebody’s radiator knocked like it wanted to testify too.

Gerardo and four of the riders sat in the back row. Mrs. Mazzola had warned them there’d be no talking, no patches flashed at the jury, nothing. They sat with their hands on their knees like deacons. One of them had taken his vest off and folded it on his lap, and underneath he was wearing a sweater with a reindeer on it.

Winslow sat at the front table in a gray suit now, not the raincoat. He’d combed his hair wet. He turned around once when we came in, and his eyes went right past me to the back row, and stayed there a second too long.

He knew Gerardo. I could see it on him. Six years, and he knew.

They put Hana in the witness chair with a cushion under her so she could reach the microphone. The judge was a woman with short white hair who said good morning to Hana before she said it to anyone else, which I decided meant I could forgive her for the radiator.

Mrs. Mazzola had told us about the screen in August. A little partition they could set between the witness and the defense table so a child doesn’t have to look at him. She’d asked if we wanted it, and I’d said yes so fast I knocked over the tissues.

A bailiff carried it in. Tan, on little feet, like a folding wall from a doctor’s office.

He set it down in front of Hana.

And Hana stood up on the cushion.

“Hana,” I said, from the first row, out loud, which you are not supposed to do.

“Can I not have that?” she said to the judge.

The judge took off her glasses. “You don’t have to look at anyone, sweetheart. That’s what it’s for.”

“I know,” Hana said. “But last night I asked my mom if he can see my face. And she didn’t say.”

Every head in that room turned and looked at me. I wanted the floor to open. I’d have taken the basement, the pipe, any of it.

“I want him to,” Hana said.

Winslow’s lawyer was halfway out of his chair with an objection and no idea what to object to. The judge looked at Mrs. Mazzola. Mrs. Mazzola looked at me. I’d like to say I gave some brave nod. I put my hand over my mouth and nodded through it.

The bailiff carried the screen back out.

So there was nothing between them. Just eleven feet of courtroom carpet and the knocking radiator.

She told it.

I’m not going to tell it here. It’s hers. But I’ll tell you she didn’t look at the floor once, and she didn’t look at me, and she didn’t look at the back row. She looked at him. She said where. She said when, the last Saturday in August, the laundry room, and she said what he told her afterward, about how nobody listens to kids in this building.

Winslow looked at his hands.

Then the lawyer got up for his turn, and that was the worst forty minutes of my life, and I have given birth without the epidural because the anesthesiologist was at lunch.

He was gentle. That was the horrible part. He was gentle and slow, and he asked if she liked television, if she ever had bad dreams, if her mom ever talked about Mr. Winslow at home, if her mom maybe didn’t like Mr. Winslow because of the parking spot. There’d been a parking spot thing. In 2023. I had honestly forgotten.

“Isn’t it possible,” he said, “you’re mixed up, Hana? Lots of men wear raincoats.”

She went quiet.

Too long. Long enough that the radiator filled it. Long enough that I watched the jury start to wonder.

At the front table, Winslow lifted his head and smiled at her. Small. Friendly. The mailroom smile. The one that says you’re getting so tall.

Her chin started to go.

I knew that chin. It had gone at birthday parties and at the dentist and the morning her goldfish floated, and it was going now, in front of twelve strangers and the man two floors up, and there was not one thing I could do from the first row.

She looked past him. To the back.

Gerardo didn’t move. He didn’t nod or wave or mouth anything, because Mrs. Mazzola would’ve killed him. He just sat there with his hands on his knees, the way he’d stood on those steps. Not going anywhere.

Hana looked back at the lawyer.

“I’m not mixed up,” she said. “He has a mole by his thumb. On the left one. He held the dryer door shut with it.”

The lawyer did not look at the left hand of his client. He didn’t have to. The jury did it for him, all twelve, at once, like a tennis crowd.

Winslow put his left hand under the table.

The left hand

The jury was out two hours and nine minutes. I know because I watched the coffee machine the entire time and refused to buy anything out of it.

Hana sat on the bench by the elevators, the bench, eating a granola bar Gerardo pulled out of his vest. The whole thing. Crusts, if granola bars had crusts. The first food I’d seen her finish since August, and it came out of a biker’s pocket next to a tire gauge.

Mrs. Urbina came in at 11:40 on her lunch break, still wearing a lanyard and a sticker that said STAR READER that some kid had slapped on her sleeve. She looked at me like she expected to get yelled at.

“I should have asked you,” she said.

“Yes,” I said. “You should have.”

Then I hugged her so hard the lanyard dug into my chin.

They called us back at 12:31.

Guilty. The foreperson was a woman in a Bears sweatshirt, and she said it on every count, and she looked straight at him each time, like she’d been saving it.

Winslow stood up when the judge told him to. And then he did the thing I’ll think about the rest of my life. He turned around. Not to his lawyer. To the back row.

“You,” he said to Gerardo. Loud. The bailiff stepped in. “You did this. You and your circus. You think you’re heroes? You think that little—”

“Sit down, Mr. Winslow,” the judge said.

He didn’t. “She’s a kid. She’s confused. Six years ago they said the same garbage and it went nowhere, it went nowhere, because it was nothing—”

The courtroom went dead quiet. Mrs. Mazzola’s pen stopped. Even the radiator stopped.

He’d said it out loud. Six years ago. In front of the judge and the jury and the court reporter whose fingers were still moving.

His own lawyer sat down and put both hands flat on the table like he was holding it to the ground.

Gerardo stood up. Slow, like getting off one knee. He didn’t say a word. He just stood there in the back row, so Winslow had to keep looking at him.

And Hana stood up next to me. On the bench, actually, in her orange boots, because she was too short to be seen otherwise.

Winslow looked at her. She looked right back.

His face did what wet cardboard does.

“Take him,” the judge said.

They put cuffs on his wrists in that room. The left one went on over the mole. He didn’t look back again.

Here’s the list, because I kept one.

He was held without bond that afternoon. Mrs. Mazzola filed that Friday to reopen the case from six years ago, using every word he’d yelled, because the court reporter got all of it. The building manager changed his locks Monday. His unit, two floors up, had a dumpster under its window by the next Thursday, and I watched his tan raincoat go into it from my balcony with a cup of coffee that was not from that machine. In February the judge gave him twenty-two years.

The girl from six years ago is seventeen now. Mrs. Mazzola called her mother. That one’s not mine to tell either, except that she’s going to testify, and she asked for Gerardo by name.

Ten forty in the morning

The week before Christmas it finally rained.

Hana came out of school at 3:05 in her orange boots and stomped every puddle between the doors and the car like each one owed her money. Mrs. Urbina stood on the curb with an umbrella and waved. Hana’s been eating lunch since the Monday after court. Mrs. Urbina texts me a picture of the empty bag every Friday. I’ve never asked her to stop.

The hall light is off now. The lamp’s still on. We’re working on it. I’m in no rush.

We still take the stairs. Not because of anybody. Hana says it’s good for my legs, which is the meanest thing anyone has ever said to me, and she’s right.

The Saturday before Christmas, thirty-two motorcycles pulled into our apartment lot at 10:40 in the morning. The neighbors came out on their balconies in bathrobes. Mrs. Neuhaus from 3B called the police, and then saw who it was and called them back to cancel.

Gerardo got off his bike with a box under his arm. Brown paper, wrapped badly, so much tape it could’ve held a house up.

Hana was already down the stairs before I’d got my shoes on.

He got down on one knee on the wet asphalt. Same as the courthouse. Same groan.

She opened it. It was a vest. Small. Brown leather, kid-sized, brand new and stiff, and on the back one patch, the only one on it you could actually read.

It said HANA.

She put it on over her pajamas. It was too big. She didn’t care. She turned around in a circle so all thirty-two could see the back.

“You said you’d be here when I came out,” she said. “You were.”

“Told you,” Gerardo said. “Not good at leaving.”

“Mom,” Hana said, looking up at me, “can he see my face?”

And I looked at my daughter in her rain boots and her too-big vest, beaming at thirty-two grown men in the rain, chin all the way up.

“Baby,” I said, “everybody can.”

If this one got to you, send it to somebody who’s ever walked a kid through a door they didn’t want to go through.

For more family tension that spills into the open, read the dinner where a father pointed a steak knife at his grandson and the toast that turned a housewarming into a public betrayal. And for another courthouse-bound story with an unexpected turn, there’s the grandmother stopped on her way home from school pickup.