The cake knife still had its cardboard sleeve on it. Kim had remembered everything for Walter’s eighty-first birthday except a place where he could sit without being laughed at.
Nine days earlier, on Tuesday, Dad had shown me his bank statement in his kitchen. Glasses on his head, butter knife beside the envelope, pencil around twenty-three withdrawals. Four hundred dollars each, over eight months. $9,200 gone through the gas station ATM near my brother’s house.
When I suggested a forgotten bill, Dad reminded me his record went back to 1968. This was a man who still licked stamps, including the ones that didn’t require it.
Darren, my younger brother, was forty-six and selling fewer used boats than he needed to. After Dad’s hip trouble, he’d arranged online banking. During rehab, in February two years earlier, he’d brought Dad a power of attorney to sign.
Dad kept a library copy of the statement. I took the original. My call from his driveway got nowhere: Darren had account access; I didn’t.
At the party, maybe fourteen of us gathered on Darren and Kim’s deck. My kids, their teenage boys, Kim’s sister, Dad’s two bowling friends. Dad rubbed the leather buttons of the brown cardigan Mom bought him.
Darren made a speech over the eight and one candles. A checkbook joke became a memory joke. Then came the money.
“He won’t even remember, so what’s the harm?”
I laid out the statement. Darren fetched his power of attorney, accused me of jealousy, and called the withdrawals an early inheritance. My seventeen-year-old stood; I made him sit.
Earl offered Dad a ride home. Dad stayed.
Then Kim answered the door.
Phil Okafor, Dad’s lawyer, arrived in a gray raincoat carrying a brown folder. He’d handled Mom’s will and their house deed. Now he set his papers beside the cake.
Darren reached. Phil stopped him.
“Your father asked me to read you the second page myself.”
Dad fastened his top button.
“Go ahead, Phil,” he said.
Phil lifted the cover.
The page with Dad’s handwriting
Phil adjusted his glasses. Darren moved behind Dad’s chair and put a hand on his shoulder.
Dad lifted it off.
My brother stood there with his hand hanging in the air. For once he had nothing useful to do with it.
“This is Walter’s instruction to me,” Phil said. “He asked me to read it because he didn’t want to be interrupted.”
Darren pulled out the chair beside Dad.
“Dad, you could have called me. You didn’t need to pay somebody to come over and make a production.”
“Let him read,” Dad said.
Phil held the page where Dad could see it.
“I have revoked Darren’s power of attorney. The bank has received the revocation and ended his access as my agent. I have not given Gladys control of my money. I will manage it myself.”
Darren looked at me.
I looked right back. I’d spent nine days feeling useless. Apparently Dad had spent them doing business.
Phil continued.
“I did not give Darren permission to take these twenty-three withdrawals. I want the full $9,200 returned. It is not an advance on his inheritance. I am alive, and I need my money.”
Kim got up from the edge of her chair.
“Wait. Darren, you told me he gave it to you.”
“Kim, please.”
“You said he wanted to help while sales were slow.”
“I said we’d sort it out.”
“No. You said he’d offered.”
Dad reached for his water. His hand shook enough to make the ice touch the glass. I nearly reached across to help, then kept my hands in my lap.
He took his drink.
Phil waited until he set it down.
“The rest is addressed to you, Darren.”
“Then give it to me.”
“Walter asked me to read it.”
My brother glanced toward his boys by the cooler. Their phones were down.
“Does everybody have to sit here for this?”
Dad nodded once.
“The people who heard you say I forget can hear what I remember.”
Phil lowered his eyes to the page.
“When I asked you about the first missing money, you told me I must have taken it myself. I started writing down my cash after that. I asked you again, and you told me to stop worrying. I checked my records before I called Gladys.”
Dad’s mouth pressed shut. He stared at the page as if Phil were reading somebody else’s letter and he wanted to be certain every word survived.
“I want you to tell your wife and your sons that I did not give you this money. I will not be your excuse.”
Nobody reached for the cake.
That was the part I hadn’t expected. I’d pictured legal words, perhaps a threat, perhaps Dad leaving everything to a home for cats out of spite. Dad disliked cats. He would still have considered it.
Instead, he’d written down the sentence my brother had to stop hiding behind.
Darren pulled the plastic sleeve toward him.
“This says durable.”
“Yes,” Phil said. “It remained effective if Walter became unable to act. It didn’t stop him from revoking it while he could.”
“So now you’re saying he’s perfectly fine.”
“I’m saying he understood what he signed.”
“He loses things.”
“So do you,” Dad said. “I’ve found your truck keys in my bathroom twice.”
One of Darren’s boys almost smiled, then looked away.
Darren leaned forward.
“I’ve been the one here. Gladys comes down from two hours away and sees a statement. I get the pharmacy calls. I take him places. You all think that’s nothing?”
I wanted to list every visit, every appointment I’d taken time off for. My brother could drag me into a contest about devotion and keep us there until the candles melted.
I put my finger on the first pencil circle instead.
“What did this pay for?”
“I don’t have receipts on me.”
“Then pick one you remember.”
“Gas. Groceries. Things for him.”
Dad turned his chair slightly.
“You took me shopping. I paid at the register.”
“Not every time.”
“Tell me one time.”
Darren rubbed his forehead.
“This is ridiculous. I wasn’t keeping a ledger on my father.”
Dad laid his palm beside the statement.
“I was keeping one on myself.”
Kim folded her arms across her middle. Her sister moved nearer but didn’t touch her.
Phil set the second page down.
“Walter wants repayment within thirty days. If you dispute the amount, provide records of expenses he authorized. Otherwise, he’ll pursue recovery. That decision is his.”
Darren stared at Dad.
“You’d take your own son to court?”
Dad’s eyes watered. He wiped them with the back of his hand, impatiently, the way he dealt with rain on a windshield.
“I would rather you paid me.”
For a moment I thought Darren might do the decent thing simply because every other route had become embarrassing.
Then he turned to me.
“You got what you wanted, Gladys. Enjoy looking after him.”
Dad pushed back his chair.
“Ask me who looks after me.”
The empty chair beside Darren
Earl put his hand near Dad’s elbow, without taking it. Dad stood by himself.
Darren stayed seated.
“Dad, sit down. You’re getting worked up.”
“I’m standing because you keep talking over my head.”
“You know what I mean.”
“I know what you’ve said.”
I moved the cake knife away from the papers and put it beside the cake. An absurd little chore. My hands needed employment before they started doing something that would require an apology.
Darren looked around the deck.
“Fine. I’ve had a rough year. Everybody knows that. Dad’s got money sitting there, and I had things to cover. He used to help us without turning it into a trial.”
“Did he agree?” Kim said.
“I knew he would.”
“That isn’t what I asked.”
Darren pulled his beer closer, then pushed it away again.
“I was going to put it back.”
“When?” Dad said.
“When business picked up.”
“You never told me that.”
“Because you’d worry.”
Dad took the statement from under the plastic sleeve. He held it with both hands.
“I worried anyway.”
My son lowered his head. Darren’s boys stood against the rail now, shoulder to shoulder. Nobody had asked them to stay. Nobody was pretending they couldn’t hear.
Kim said, “You watched me thank him.”
Darren shut his eyes.
“I know.”
“You let me say we’d make it up to him.”
“I know, Kim.”
“And he didn’t know what I meant.”
Dad sat back down. That took more out of him than standing had.
“I thought you meant the rides,” he said.
Kim covered her face.
There was a point when I wanted to gather everybody’s shame into a bag and carry it out myself. I’d done versions of that since Darren was little. Explain him. Soften him. Tell Dad he hadn’t meant it quite that way.
I stayed in my chair.
Darren reached toward Kim. She stepped back.
“Don’t. Tell them.”
He looked at his boys.
“Your grandfather didn’t exactly offer it.”
Kim’s hand dropped.
“Exactly?”
“I took it,” Darren said. “All right? I took money without asking. I figured I’d replace it before there was a problem.”
Dad kept his eyes on him.
“And the forgetting?” I said.
Darren’s face reddened.
“I shouldn’t have made that joke.”
“Before today.”
He looked down at the statement.
“I shouldn’t have told him he’d taken it.”
“Did you know he hadn’t?”
“Yes.”
Dad folded his hands together. His thumb moved over a knuckle instead of a button.
Darren kept talking.
“I panicked when he asked. Then another month went bad. Once you’re behind, four hundred doesn’t look like much. I didn’t take it all at once. I wasn’t trying to wipe him out.”
“You took it twenty-three times,” Kim said.
“I know the number.”
“Then stop making it smaller.”
Phil moved the folder away from a ring of water. He said nothing. He’d brought the page; the family could manage the rest.
Darren looked toward the house, through the glass door at the television above his fireplace.
“I don’t have ninety-two hundred spare.”
“Neither do I,” Dad said. “Mine’s missing.”
I nearly laughed. It caught in my throat and came out as a cough. Dad gave me a glance that said he knew perfectly well what that noise was.
Darren spread his hands.
“So what am I supposed to do?”
“Pay him,” Kim said.
“From where?”
“Your boat.”
He straightened.
“That’s mine.”
Kim looked at him until he looked away.
I hadn’t known whether he still owned the fishing boat he used on Sundays. He’d talked about it so often that even my ignorance had become a courtesy.
“I can’t sell it overnight,” he said.
“You have thirty days,” Phil said.
“And if I get less than it’s worth?”
Dad began sliding the statement back toward me, then stopped and kept it.
“That’s between you and your buyer.”
Darren stood so abruptly his chair scraped the deck.
“You’re all enjoying this.”
“No,” Earl said.
Just that. No sermon. Earl had bowled with Dad for years and could apparently put the same economy into a sentence as a strike.
Darren took his wallet out and laid Dad’s bank card beside the folder.
“There. Happy?”
Dad didn’t pick it up.
“The card’s canceled,” Phil said.
My brother’s shoulders fell. He’d offered back something he couldn’t use, and it hadn’t bought him anything.
Dad asked for his house key.
Darren stared.
“You don’t trust me to come into your house now?”
“No.”
The key came off Darren’s ring with an ugly little struggle. He dropped it beside the card.
Then he reached for the power of attorney.
“Leave that,” Phil said. “You can have a copy of the revocation with it.”
For two years my brother had carried that paper like a badge. Now he stood waiting while Dad’s lawyer clipped another sheet to it.
Kim turned to Dad.
“I’m sorry I told Gladys to stop.”
Dad nodded.
“I wanted my birthday too.”
She began crying then. Quietly, with her mouth open, as if she’d been trying to get one more sentence out.
Darren said, “Dad, come on. We can start over.”
Dad put the key in his cardigan pocket.
“You can start with the money.”
The leather button
Darren stayed beside his chair while Phil handed him the papers. Dad put the canceled card into the brown folder, then asked me to fold his statement along its old crease.
My son came over.
“Grandpa, do you want your cake?”
Dad looked at Kim. She had a tissue pressed under her eyes.
“Will it travel?”
She nodded.
The cake went back into its box with the eight and one candles laid beside it. My son carried it through the house. Earl held the door, and Dad walked past the enormous television without giving it so much as a glance.
At the front step, Darren followed us out.
“Dad.”
We stopped.
“I’ll sell the boat. You don’t have to keep telling everybody.”
Dad faced him.
“Then don’t make me ask twice.”
He walked down the steps. I followed with my purse and the statement, and for once I didn’t turn around to see whether my brother was upset.
I drove Dad home with the cake buckled into the back seat. He objected to the seat belt until I told him I’d already had one disaster involving his birthday and wouldn’t be accepting another.
He laughed once.
Then he cried.
He kept his face toward the passenger window, and I drove without saying anything helpful. Helpful would have ruined it. He’d been holding himself together while his son explained why stealing from him was understandable.
At a red light he took out his handkerchief.
“Did I embarrass the boys?”
“Darren did.”
“They shouldn’t have had to hear it.”
“They heard him laugh too.”
Dad pressed the handkerchief against his eyes.
“I kept checking whether I’d bought something.”
“I know.”
“Looked in the cupboards.”
My hands tightened on the wheel.
All those pencil circles, and I’d started by suggesting a forgotten bill.
“I’m sorry I didn’t believe you immediately.”
“You counted it.”
“After I questioned you.”
He folded the handkerchief.
“Next time, count first.”
“I will.”
At his house, I carried the cake inside and put it in the refrigerator. Dad laid his house key in the drawer by the door, where he kept spare keys. He shut it with his knee.
I offered to stay.
He said yes.
That surprised me more than anything he’d done on the deck. Dad usually waved help away before you finished offering it, as if accepting a night of company might put him on a government list.
We sat in the living room. His cardigan’s top button had pulled halfway loose; he’d worried the thread all afternoon.
“Give me that,” I said.
“The whole sweater?”
“Unless you’d like me to sew you into it.”
He took it off and handed it over. I found Mom’s sewing tin in the cupboard where he’d always kept it.
He leaned back while I threaded a needle.
“I didn’t know you called Phil.”
“I wasn’t sure what he could do.”
“You could have told me.”
“I wanted one conversation where nobody answered for me.”
I put the needle down for a moment.
“Fair enough.”
On the twenty-fourth day after the party, Darren came to Dad’s house with a cashier’s check for $9,200. Dad had asked me to be there. I sat in the living room while my brother stood just inside the door.
He held out the check.
“The boat sold.”
Dad read the amount, then the name.
“All of it?”
“All of it.”
Darren had brought the sale receipt too. Dad didn’t ask to see it. He put the check in the envelope Phil had given him for the repayment records.
My brother shifted his weight.
“I hated selling it.”
Dad looked up.
Darren swallowed.
“I know. That’s my problem.”
It was the first sentence he’d said about the money that didn’t ask Dad to carry some of it.
“I’m sorry I made you doubt yourself,” he said.
Dad held the envelope against his knee.
“You’ll need to give me time.”
Darren nodded. He didn’t ask for a key. He left without getting one.
Dad and I took the check to the bank that afternoon. I waited in a chair while he spoke to the teller himself. When he came back, he handed me the deposit receipt long enough to read it.
$9,200.00.
He took it back and tucked it into his wallet. Every withdrawal had been returned. Darren’s access stayed gone.
Outside, Dad put on his cardigan. The repaired button held.
“Home?” I said.
“Library first.”
He wanted a copy of the receipt.
Of course he did.
That evening, back at his house, I stood in the hallway putting on my coat. Dad was in his armchair with his glasses on, the television turned low. He lifted a hand as I passed.
A thread stuck out beside the button I’d repaired.
“Your mother would’ve cut that shorter.”
“Your mother would’ve charged you for the criticism.”
He smiled and held still while I fetched the scissors from the sewing tin.
I snipped the thread, smoothed the cardigan over his shoulder, and bent to kiss his forehead.
His hand closed around mine.
“Come Sunday, Gladys.”
“Do you need something?”
“Yes,” he said. “My daughter.”
I took my coat off again and hung it on the hook.
For more family money drama, read about a son who tried to sell his father’s house and a brother who made his sister pay for Dad’s reading glasses. There’s also the brother who tried to put a pen in Grandma’s hand – and take control of her money.