Derek Turned My Guest Into Entertainment at Gwen’s Pool

Chloe Bennett

The cuff button on my mustard blouse came loose before we got through lunch. I’d worried it with my thumb all morning, as if that little piece of plastic could keep me together.

I was thirty-nine, divorced after fifteen years with Derek, and tired of dropping our children off at family gatherings without staying.

On Saturday, May 22, his sister Gwen invited me to her Memorial Day weekend lunch in Macon. Peyton, fourteen, wanted me to swim. Landon, nine, had another swim shirt waiting at his aunt’s house.

I promised to come on Sunday, May 30. Then I invented a guest.

Wes, thirty-six, hosted events and performed improv. I found his listing, offered a flat fee, and explained that the children would know him only as my guest. At my door, he canceled the charge. He came in his faded denim shirt anyway.

By then I’d changed out of my blouse and back into it. Six months after Derek left, I still heard his parting assessment whenever I dressed.

“You used to try.”

His new girlfriend, Kayla, booked installs at the flooring outlet he managed. She was twenty-nine. Apparently, forty-one-year-old Derek considered this a qualification nobody could dispute.

Lunch was at one. At 1:20, he crossed Gwen’s deck with Kayla, paused to flip a burger, and inspected my company.

“What’s he billing you by the hour?”

I twisted my button. Wes covered my hand.

“You never opened my reply.”

He added that he’d canceled the fee. Derek found no takers for his laugh among the twelve people within earshot.

Seven minutes later, he tried the cousins again, saying I’d bought a man for the day. Kayla gave a laugh.

Wes released my hand, opened a different conversation on his phone, and offered her the screen.

She read it twice, began crying, and pushed past Derek toward the gate.

The Message Above Mine

Derek reached after her, caught nothing, and turned back toward Wes.

“Give me that.”

Wes brought the phone against his chest.

“You can open your own copy.”

That stopped me harder than Kayla’s tears.

“My own copy of what?” Derek said.

Wes turned the screen toward me. “Heather should read it.”

There was Derek’s name above a message dated three weeks earlier. His profile picture was the one Peyton had taken of him at a baseball game. I knew because he’d made her take it six times.

The message began with a question about Wes’s availability for May 30.

Then came Gwen’s address.

Then me.

“My ex-wife will be there. Heather. I want you to turn up like you’re her date. Get her to play along, then let it slip that you’re hired. Nothing nasty. Just enough that everyone gets the joke.”

I read the next lines with my finger braced against the phone.

“Kayla thinks I’m being hard on her. Let her see Heather will take attention from anybody. Kayla’s easy to steer once she thinks something was her idea.”

Below that was Wes’s answer.

“I don’t take jobs meant to humiliate someone. Do not book me for this.”

The app showed that reply as unread.

Derek had wanted to hire the same man I’d found for myself. He’d planned to supply my company, arrange my embarrassment, and leave his girlfriend thinking she’d formed her own opinion.

For a moment I couldn’t get past the address. My children swam there. Gwen kept their sunscreen in a basket by the door.

He’d put that address in an order for a joke about their mother.

“You sent this?” I said.

“It was an inquiry.”

Gwen stepped beside me. At forty-four, she could still make her younger brother straighten up just by moving closer.

“At my house?”

“It wasn’t booked, Gwen.”

She read over my shoulder.

Wes kept hold of his phone. Nobody had to worry about me dropping it. My hands had gone stiff enough to hold roofing tiles.

Kayla stood inside the gate, unable to work the chain while she cried. Around the corner, twenty feet away, Peyton and Landon were still at the shallow end. I could hear Landon splashing.

I wanted to march over to Derek and slap that expression off his face. Instead, I took one step toward the corner.

Gwen touched my arm.

“I can see them from here,” she said. “They’re in the water. Stay.”

Derek tried a laugh.

“Come on. People book these things for parties. You’ve seen those videos.”

“Did you send it?” I said.

“Yes, but you’re reading it like a legal document. It was supposed to be funny. He didn’t even take the job.”

There it was. No stolen account. No imaginary cousin with his phone. Just Derek, annoyed that his joke had developed witnesses.

Kayla let the chain fall against the post.

“You said she kept calling you.”

Nobody answered.

She turned around.

“You said she wanted you back. Every time I said maybe we should leave her alone, you told me I didn’t understand.”

Derek spread his hands toward her.

“You don’t know what the last year was like.”

“She isn’t the one who wrote that about me.”

He moved toward her. She put a hand up.

Wes lowered the phone, and I faced him.

“When did you know?”

“This morning, when you sent the address. I searched it in my inbox.”

“You knew before you knocked?”

“Yes.”

I pulled my hand away from his sleeve.

He didn’t try to take it back.

“I should have told you then,” he said. “I thought refusing the money and coming as your guest would let you have the lunch you wanted. That was my decision to make about the money. The rest should have been yours.”

“You let me walk in without knowing.”

“Yes. I’m sorry.”

I appreciated the absence of a speech about protecting me. I had spent fifteen years married to a man who could turn an apology into a complaint about my hearing.

Still, my stomach hurt.

“Send me that conversation.”

Wes tapped the screen. My phone buzzed in my pocket.

Derek stepped forward.

“Don’t start passing private messages around.”

I opened the images Wes had sent. The date, the address, every word. I saved them.

Then I put my phone away.

“You brought twelve people into it,” I said.

Gwen held out her hand to Wes. “May I read the rest?”

Derek reached for her wrist.

She moved it before he could touch her.

“Don’t.”

For once, his sister hadn’t softened the word.

Gwen’s Deck

Gwen read the exchange from the first message to Wes’s refusal. Derek stood beside her, offering explanations over her shoulder.

“I was angry when I sent it. Heather acts like coming here is some enormous sacrifice. Everybody has to coax her. Everybody has to make sure she’s comfortable.”

I opened my mouth, but Gwen held up a finger without looking away from the phone.

He kept going.

“And now she’s here with somebody she hired herself. That’s what nobody wants to talk about. I didn’t make her do that.”

“No,” I said. “You didn’t.”

He pointed at me, delighted by a sentence he could use.

“Exactly.”

“I asked for company. You asked for an audience.”

His hand dropped.

Kayla came back from the gate. She kept a chair between herself and Derek.

“Read the part about me,” she said.

“Kayla, please.”

“Out loud.”

He rubbed his forehead. I remembered that hand on that forehead from our kitchen, when I’d asked what we were supposed to tell the children. Somehow he was always exhausted by questions he caused.

“This is getting ridiculous,” he said. “We’re wrecking Gwen’s lunch.”

“You can stop saying my name like I’m on your side,” Gwen said.

Wes took his phone back when she offered it. He didn’t speak. This was no longer a job he could perform his way through, and I was glad he seemed to understand that.

Derek looked toward the cousins.

“You know me.”

Nobody rescued him.

One cousin set down his drink and moved away from the grill. The space beside Derek grew by one person, then stayed empty.

Kayla pulled her phone from her pocket.

Derek’s shoulders eased. He seemed to think she’d found something ordinary to do.

Then she said, “I’m ordering a ride.”

“We came together.”

“I’m leaving separately.”

“Over one message?”

“Over the way you talk when you think I can’t hear.”

He lowered his voice, though we could all still hear him.

“Don’t do this in front of everybody.”

That nearly made me laugh. My humiliation had been suitable entertainment. His required curtains.

Kayla wiped under her eyes with her knuckles.

“You don’t get to come home with me tonight. I’ll arrange for you to collect what you’ve left there. Not today.”

He stared at her.

“You’re serious?”

She turned her screen toward him just long enough to show that the ride was booked.

Then she faced me.

“I’m sorry I laughed.”

I wanted to tell her about every time I’d walked past the mirror sideways. About the afternoon Derek kept repeating her name while I tried to understand what was happening to my marriage.

But the children were twenty feet away. I had already given this woman more space in my head than she paid rent for.

“You did,” I said. “Don’t do it again.”

She nodded, crying harder, and returned to the gate.

A wet foot sounded on the steps.

Peyton stood at the corner of the deck with Landon behind her. He held the neck of his swim shirt in both hands. My daughter looked at her father, then at me.

I went to them immediately.

“Are you okay?”

Peyton didn’t answer that.

“Was he paying somebody to be mean to you?”

Derek came forward.

“Nobody paid anybody, honey. Adults are having a disagreement.”

Peyton stepped closer to me.

That movement hurt him. His face changed before he arranged it again.

“Don’t look at me like that,” he said. “You haven’t heard the whole thing.”

I put my hand on Peyton’s shoulder.

“She heard enough to ask.”

“He didn’t pay me,” Wes said from behind us. “I refused.”

Landon stared at Wes.

“Are you Mom’s boyfriend?”

“No,” I said. “He’s a guest I invited. I asked him to come because I was nervous about being here.”

“Because of Dad?”

I crouched, which finally pulled the cuff button free. It bounced once and landed beside Landon’s foot.

“Because I thought someone might make fun of me,” I said. “I shouldn’t have needed help coming to lunch.”

Landon picked up the button and placed it in my palm.

Peyton had started crying without making a sound. I stood and put an arm around her.

Derek looked at Gwen.

“See what this is doing? We need to take it inside.”

“No,” I said.

He stared at me.

I had said that word to him before. Usually it came with reasons, alternate dates, a promise to find a way around whatever inconvenience I was causing.

This time I let it sit.

Gwen opened the door to her house.

“Derek, get your keys.”

He didn’t move.

“You’re throwing me out of a family lunch?”

“I’m asking you to leave mine.”

“She’s the one who brought a hired date.”

“And you’re the one who planned to hurt her here.”

He looked at our children.

“Come on. I’ll take you home.”

Peyton tightened her arm around my waist.

“It’s my afternoon with them,” I said. “They’re staying.”

Landon took my other hand.

Derek looked down at our joined hands, then toward the house. He went inside without another word.

Gwen stood in the doorway until he came back with his keys.

The Button in My Pocket

Derek stopped at the deck steps.

Kayla was still by the gate, watching her phone for the ride. Wes stood near the chair where we’d meant to eat. Gwen kept her hand on the open door.

Our twelve-person audience had gone quiet enough for the pool filter to sound rude.

“Heather,” Derek said. “Can you come over here?”

I stayed with the children.

“What do you need?”

“Five minutes without everybody listening.”

“You had fifteen years.”

His jaw tightened.

“I knew you’d do this.”

“What?”

“Make sure they remember me this way.”

Peyton lifted her head from my shoulder.

“You said it where we could hear.”

He looked at her, and for a second I thought he might manage the one thing that could help him.

Instead he said, “You know I joke.”

She wiped her face with the heel of her hand.

“I know.”

He flinched.

Gwen came down the steps.

“You need to tell them what you did.”

“I’m not being put through some family trial.”

“Then stop asking your daughter to pretend.”

He pushed his keys into his pocket, took them out again, and looked toward Kayla. She had turned her back.

I wanted him to feel every inch of that deck. I won’t dress that up. After months of making myself smaller, it was a relief to stand still and let him be uncomfortable.

But Landon’s fingers were damp inside mine, and he needed something more useful than his mother enjoying a victory.

“Tell them they didn’t cause this,” I said.

“Of course they didn’t.”

“Tell them.”

Derek crouched in front of Landon. Our son stayed beside me.

“I sent a message I shouldn’t have sent,” Derek said. “I wanted somebody to play a trick on Mom. He said no.”

Landon’s mouth trembled.

“Was it a bad trick?”

“Yes.”

“Then why?”

Derek rubbed his hands over his knees.

“I was trying to be funny.”

Peyton made a small sound.

He looked up at her.

“At your mother’s expense,” he added.

Landon pressed his face into my blouse. I put my hand against the back of his head.

Derek stood.

“I’m sorry you heard it.”

I shook my head.

He stared at me, furious for a moment. Then his shoulders dropped.

“I’m sorry I did it.”

I couldn’t tell him it was all right. My children were listening, and it wasn’t.

Gwen moved aside to give him a clear path to the gate.

He passed Kayla without touching her. She stepped back anyway.

At the latch, he turned to me one last time.

“Was all this necessary?”

I held Landon closer.

“Leaving is.”

Derek unhooked the chain and went out. Gwen followed him only far enough to secure it again.

Kayla’s ride arrived a few minutes later. She said goodbye to Gwen, then looked toward me.

I gave her a nod. It was what I had.

She left without asking me to make her feel better.

For a while, nobody tried to restart lunch. Gwen brought the children towels, and I sat on the steps with them while their breathing settled.

Peyton leaned against my shoulder.

“You could’ve told me you didn’t want to come.”

“I wanted to come. I didn’t want the part that happened.”

“Me either.”

“I know, baby.”

She let me call her that. Fourteen-year-olds issue those permits sparingly.

Landon opened my fingers to check on the button.

“You can sew it back.”

“That’s the plan.”

“Can we still swim?”

I kissed his wet hair.

“Yes.”

He waited beside us instead of running off. Peyton reached across me and squeezed his hand.

Wes approached only after I looked up.

“I’m going to head out,” he said. “I don’t want you to feel like you have to keep entertaining a guest.”

“You were supposed to be the entertainment professional.”

“Bad day for my reviews.”

A laugh escaped before I could stop it. It hurt my throat, but it was mine.

He smiled, then stopped.

“I’m sorry I didn’t show you the message before we came.”

“You should be.”

“I am.”

I studied him for a moment. No grand promise. No suggestion that what he’d done afterward erased the choice he’d made earlier.

“Thank you for saying no to him,” I said.

“That part was easy.”

He said goodbye to Peyton and Landon, then Gwen let him out. I didn’t need another man staying until the credits. I needed my children to see me stay.

Gwen brought out the swim shirt Landon had left behind and handed it to him.

Then she held out a towel to me.

“You brought your suit?”

“Under this.”

“Good. Your daughter has asked me three times.”

Peyton covered her face.

“Aunt Gwen.”

I stood and put the loose button in my pocket.

My blouse still caught against my stomach as I pulled it off. For one second, Derek’s voice began its usual sentence in my head.

Landon interrupted it by dropping his towel on my foot.

I hung the blouse over a chair, stepped down to the pool, and lowered myself into the water beside my children.

Peyton reached for me under the surface.

I took her hand and pushed us both away from the wall.

Family gatherings have a way of bringing old grudges – and fresh betrayals – to the surface; see what happened in the wedding paid for by a daughter but canceled by her father and the laptop a mother sold without permission. For another case of someone making a major decision without asking, read the husband who promised his wife’s spare rooms to his family.