Dad Spent the $171,000 Meant for My Leg

Lucy Evans

The porch light was the only thing on my street still burning at nine, and it was full of moths, which is how I knew before I opened the door that somebody had been standing out there a while.

It was my mother, in the gray wool coat she wears to funerals and the bank. My father stood a step behind her with a green accordion file held to his stomach like a hot-water bottle. I hadn’t seen either of them up close in seventeen years. Not since the August I was sixteen, when a crutch of mine knocked over a rinse pail at the county fair, Yael’s heifer bolted, and that night Dad pushed an empty seed-corn bag into my chest and Mom held the screen door so I could leave faster.

Two summers before that, a silage blower had taken my left leg. Mom’s whole hospital visit was one question about the skid steer. Yael got a four-wheeler. I got township crutches with another family’s name on the tape.

I walked four miles to Grandma Philomena’s that night. She took me in. Three winters later she asked where the insurance money went, and I found the file in Viroqua: $171,000, a restricted account, Dad as conservator, eleven withdrawals sworn for my medical needs. By my eighteenth birthday, $340 was left. I’ve kept the copies in my fire safe for fourteen years.

Now Dad said Yael, the 4-H foundation treasurer, had made a mess before Monday’s audit, and Mom said the number. “Yael needs $57,500 by Monday. You owe us.”

I knocked twice on my socket and called Kendrick Salinas while she was still talking. They left before his car turned in. Kendrick read all eleven requests twice at my table.

At 6:40 Saturday morning Grandma called from Maple Ridge. Mom had brought her “Medicaid forms” Wednesday. Grandma had sat on them for three days.

In her room she lifted the cushion and handed Kendrick six warm pages.

He read the third one, took off his glasses, and said, “Danica. How old were you in 2008?”

The third page

“Fifteen,” I said.

Kendrick turned the page around on his knee so I could see it.

It was a bank signature card. Driftless Farm Credit, the one by the feed mill with the bad parking lot. Two lines filled in. The top one was Justin Moriarty, in the same tall slanted hand that was on all eleven requests in my fire safe.

The bottom one was mine.

Fifteen-year-old me, with a loop on the D I gave up in tenth grade because a teacher said it looked like a balloon.

I didn’t say anything for long enough that Grandma reached over and took my wrist.

“You remember it,” she said.

I did. It came back the way a smell does. Kitchen table, spring of 2008, me on the bench with my stump propped on a chair because the crutch pads had rubbed my armpits raw. Dad put a paper in front of me and a pen on top of it.

“Bank wants your name on your leg money,” he said. “So they know it’s yours.”

I signed it. I thought it meant I was getting the leg.

I remember I asked what color the foot would be.

Kendrick put his glasses back on. “This opened a joint account. You and your father. Every one of those eleven withdrawals left the restricted account and landed here.” He tapped the account number with one finger. “Then it went wherever he wanted. The court thought it was going to a fifteen-year-old’s care. It was going to a fifteen-year-old’s account.”

“With my name on it.”

“With your name on it.” He flipped to page four. “And it’s still open.”

Grandma made a noise like a kettle starting.

Pages one, two, four, five and six were not Medicaid forms. They were a loan application at the same bank, $57,500, secured against that same joint account, and on page five there was a line marked Guarantor with a little yellow sticky arrow pointing at it.

Grandma’s name was typed under the line.

So was mine, as co-owner of the security.

I read it twice. Then I said what I would have said to a client, because it was the only way I could say it without throwing up on her carpet.

“If she’d signed, the bank lends Yael’s money against my account, Grandma guarantees it, and when it doesn’t get paid back, they come for you first and me second.”

“Your mother brought me a pen,” Grandma said. “A nice one. From the funeral home.”

That should not have been funny. I laughed so hard I had to hold the bed rail. Grandma laughed too, and then she stopped, and then she put her face in her blue cardigan sleeve, and I held on to her for a while and looked at the folded corner of page three.

Kendrick waited. He’s good at waiting. He bills for it, but he’s good at it.

“Here’s the part that matters,” he said when we were back. “You’re an owner on that account. You’ve been one since you were fifteen. Nobody ever took you off.”

“So?”

“So you can walk into Driftless on Monday at eight and ask what’s in it.”

I looked at him.

“And if there’s money in it,” he said, “you can ask them to hand it to you.”

“Dad’s money?”

“Your money. That’s the whole point of everything he swore to a judge eleven times.”

Grandma let go of my wrist and folded her hands on the empty cushion.

“Your grandfather sold milk to that bank for forty years,” she said. “Go ask them nice.”

My phone buzzed on the bed. A text from a number I’d deleted in 2009 and still knew by heart.

Your father wants to talk. Tomorrow. Here. Bring your lawyer if you have to. — Mom

Here was the farm.

The kitchen on County Road N

Sunday at two I drove up the lane I’d walked down on crutches in the dark.

They’d painted the house. Same white. The porch swing was gone and a new four-wheeler sat under the lean-to, red, nicer than my car.

Kendrick had the six pages in a folder on his lap. Grandma was in the back seat. She’d signed herself out of Maple Ridge at noon and told the nurse she was going to church, which in her opinion was close enough.

“You don’t have to come in,” I told her.

“It’s my daughter’s kitchen,” she said. “I paid for half the linoleum.”

Mom opened the screen door before we knocked. She saw Grandma and her whole face stopped working. Seventeen years. Not one word. Then she said, “Mother,” like it was a diagnosis, and stepped back.

Dad was at the table with the green accordion file. Yael was at the counter in a 4-H fleece, thirty-one years old, arms crossed, chewing the inside of her cheek. Last time I saw her up close she had blue freezer pop running down her wrist.

Nobody offered anyone a chair. I took one anyway. My knee was killing me from the lane.

Dad opened with the mask on, the church-council one.

“We want this handled in the family,” he said. “Without courts. You’re good with numbers, Danica, everybody says so. Yael made a mistake. A transfer here and there. She meant to put it back.”

“Fifty-seven five is a lot of here and there,” I said.

“Heifer prices went bad,” Yael said, to the refrigerator.

Mom pulled the chair out next to Dad and sat like the chair owed her money.

“You’ve got that office,” she said. “You’ve got clients. You could cover this by Monday and not even feel it. And instead you call a lawyer on your own blood and you drag your grandmother out of her home.”

“I dragged myself,” Grandma said.

“You stay out of this.”

“I stayed out of it for seventeen years, Mindy. Look where it got the girl.”

Dad slid the file toward me. It was the loan application. A clean copy, the same six pages, the same sticky arrow, only this time the arrow pointed at my line.

“Just sign it,” he said. “It’s a loan against an old account. Your grandmother doesn’t even have to be involved. Bank’s fine with you alone.”

Kendrick didn’t move. I’d told him in the car: let them say it all.

“What old account?” I said.

Dad’s eyes went to Mom. Mom’s went to the window.

“An account from when you were little,” Dad said. “For your care. There’s a balance in it. It’s family money. This just borrows against it so nobody has to touch it.”

“Whose name is on it?”

“Mine,” he said.

“Whose else?”

He didn’t answer.

I put my hand flat on the table, the way I do when a farmer tells me his wife does the books and that’s why the books are wrong.

“Dad. Whose else?”

Yael turned around for the first time.

“Why would her name be on it?” she said to him.

That was the first crack. Yael didn’t know. Of course she didn’t. Yael got the heifers. She never once had to ask where they came from.

Dad’s voice came up. “Because I needed a second signer, Yael, and you were thirteen.”

“You put Danica’s name on the account you paid my show fees out of?”

“Your fees, your trip to state, your four-wheeler, this kitchen,” I said. “Eleven times. Sworn to a judge as my medical needs.”

Mom stood up so fast the chair hit the radiator.

“We fed you,” she said. “We housed you. You think a leg on a fourteen-year-old is cheap? Every bit of that money was for this family, and you are this family whether you like it or not.”

“You fed me in the mudroom,” I said.

That was all I said. It was enough. Mom looked at Grandma, and Grandma looked right back, and Mom sat down.

Dad leaned in close. He smelled like Copenhagen and bag balm, same as 2009.

“Listen to me,” he said. “If you don’t sign that, Yael loses the treasurer job, maybe worse. If you take this to a judge, they’ll take the farm. Your grandfather’s farm. Is that what you want? To be the one who lost the farm?”

Yael was crying now, quietly, the way she’d done everything in that house, out of the way of everybody.

And I’ll be honest. I almost picked up the pen.

Not for him. For the six-year-old version of her who used to climb into my bed during thunderstorms before any of it happened.

Kendrick put his hand on the file.

“She’s not signing anything today,” he said.

Dad stood up. “Then get out of my house.”

“It’s not your house yet,” Grandma said, and she started to get up, and her cane slid on Mom’s waxed linoleum, and she went down hard on one knee next to the table.

Nobody at that table moved but me.

Driftless Farm Credit

Grandma’s knee was bruised, not broken. The ER doctor in Viroqua said so at six o’clock Sunday night and said she’d be sore a week. Grandma told him she’d been sore since 1964.

I sat by her bed at Maple Ridge till ten.

“Your father thinks you’ll fold,” she said, with her eyes closed. “He thinks you’ll do it for Yael.”

“I almost did.”

“I know. I saw your hand.” She opened one eye. “Don’t.”

Monday I was in the Driftless lot at 7:52, which with a prosthetic and that lot is a sport. Kendrick met me at the door with coffee and the copy of the signature card.

The woman at the desk was named Beatrice, sixty-something, with a cardigan the color of a stop sign, and she’d done the bank’s milk loans since I was in diapers. She pulled the account up and looked at the screen and then at me over her glasses.

“You’re Justin’s girl,” she said. “The one with the leg.”

“The one whose name is on that.”

She turned the screen a little so Kendrick couldn’t see it. Bank rules. Then she turned it a little more so I could.

“You’re owner number two on this since April 2008,” she said. “Never closed. Never removed.”

“What’s the balance?”

“Sixty-three thousand eight hundred twelve dollars and forty cents.”

I said it back to her. She nodded.

It was the milk-check overflow. Dad had been parking the farm’s spare money in an account with my name on it for eighteen years, I suppose because nobody looks at a dead daughter’s paperwork.

“Am I allowed to withdraw it?” I said.

Beatrice looked at the clock, at Kendrick, at the signature card in my hand with the balloon D.

“Honey,” she said, “you’re allowed to close it.”

So I did. Every cent into my own account, and the account with Dad’s name and mine on it shut at 8:19 a.m. Beatrice printed the closing slip and pushed it across with two fingers like a winning ticket.

“Your grandpa sold us milk for forty years,” she said.

“So I heard.”

At 9:05 Kendrick was at the clerk’s window at the Vernon County courthouse with the signature card, the eleven requests and a motion asking the judge who’d approved my settlement in 2007 to look at it again. He’d written it Sunday night after I dropped him off. He said the judge would want Dad in a courtroom explaining “medical needs” one line at a time.

At 9:40 Yael’s audit started at the extension office without a cent of the $57,500 back in the foundation. I wasn’t there. I’d already decided that was Yael’s to sign for.

At 11:15 my phone rang. Dad.

I let it ring four times.

“What did you do,” he said. No hello. Same as the porch.

“I closed my account.”

“That was the farm’s money.”

“It was in my name. You told me so yourself when I was fifteen. ‘So they know it’s yours.'”

I heard Mom in the background, then the phone being grabbed.

“You come out here,” Mom said. “You come out here and you look at us and you tell us to our faces.”

So I did.

The screen door

The four of them were in the yard when I pulled in at noon, the way people stand outside after a barn fire. Dad, Mom, Yael. And a fourth person, a man in a sport coat I’d never seen, who turned out to be from the 4-H foundation board, there to collect Yael’s keys and the checkbook.

Grandma was in my passenger seat with a bag of frozen peas on her knee. She’d insisted. She said she wanted to see it with her own eyes, because her eyes were the only part of her still under warranty.

I got out. Dad came at me across the gravel.

“You’ve ruined this family,” he said. “You’ve ruined your sister. The board is going to the sheriff. The bank’s calling the operating loan. That account was the cushion. Without it we lose the herd by spring.”

“How many head?” I said.

“Ninety-one.”

“How much in the cushion when I closed it?”

He knew. “Sixty-three thousand.”

“Eight hundred twelve dollars and forty cents,” I said. “I counted the forty cents.”

Mom came down the porch steps. “You did this over a pail at a fair.”

“No,” I said. “I did it over a seed-corn bag.”

She stopped. She looked at the porch rail again, the way she had on Friday.

The 4-H man cleared his throat and held out his hand to Yael. She put the foundation checkbook in it. Then a ring of keys. Then she looked at Dad.

“You told me it was my heifer money,” she said. “All those years. You said Grandpa left it for me.”

“It was for the family,” Dad said.

“It was hers.” Yael turned to me, and for the first time in seventeen years she looked straight at me. Her face was red and wet. “I didn’t know. I swear to God, Dani, I didn’t know.”

“You knew I ate in the mudroom,” I said.

She took that like a slap and didn’t argue.

Then Dad did the thing I’d been waiting for since Friday. He dropped to his knees on the gravel, right in front of the 4-H man and his wife and his younger daughter.

“Please,” he said. “Put it back. I’ll sign anything you want. Put it back and I’ll tell the judge I’m sorry, I’ll tell him whatever, just don’t let them take the cows.”

I looked down at him. Bag balm and Copenhagen. Sixty-one. Hands that held my leg money for eighteen years.

“Get up, Dad,” I said. “The concrete’s wet. Somebody could slide.”

Then I got back in the car.

It took four months. The judge put Dad on the stand in March and asked him about each of the eleven requests one at a time, and Kendrick told me Dad got to number four before he stopped answering. The court ordered him to repay the settlement with eighteen years of interest. The herd went at auction on a Wednesday in April: ninety-one head, the red four-wheeler, the skid steer. Yael kept her job at the feed mill and lost the foundation, and paid the $57,500 back to the kids herself, $400 a month, a check every first Tuesday. She wrote me once. I haven’t written back yet. I might.

Mom never called.

Seven minutes slow

The first Saturday in May I drove out to Grandma’s old house on County Road N with a stepladder and a cardboard box.

It’s mine now. She signed it over in February at Kendrick’s office, with a regular pen, and made him put the funeral-home one in the trash in front of her.

The box held the cuckoo clock. I’d taken it to Maple Ridge in November so she’d have something in that room that was hers, and she’d sent it back with me last week and said it belonged on its own nail.

The nail was still there over the table where she’d taught me to balance a checkbook. I climbed the ladder. My socket squeaked on the second rung like it always does.

I hung it. I set it by my phone. Then I pushed the minute hand back seven minutes, because she’d never forgive me if I didn’t.

Out in the yard Grandma sat in a lawn chair in her blue cardigan with her knee up on a cooler, watching me through the screen door.

I came out and stood on the porch. The bag from that night is still in her closet. I checked. Two jeans, three shirts, an inhaler that expired in 2011.

“Well?” she said. “Is it right?”

“It’s seven minutes slow.”

“Good,” Grandma said. “Now get in before the moths do.”

For more family betrayals that leave someone feeling abandoned, read about a husband who packed a bag and left, a Thanksgiving spent alone, and a dad who chose his birthday party over his daughter’s wedding.