Dad Hid Me Behind the Last Row of Chairs

Chloe Bennett

The seam inside my loafer had worked loose, and I was trying to tuck it under my heel when Dad caught my elbow.

The party had started at seven. Five minutes in, Gerry Holloway already had a seating problem: his daughter Trish was visible.

At the Lakeshore Inn in Fort Wayne, about 120 guests had gathered for my identical twin’s promotion. Amber’s uniform carried a new silver oak leaf on each shoulder. My green cardigan carried a loose thread.

Dad steered me toward the back, smelling of the aftershave he’d worn when we were children and Amber always got buckled into the car first. She was seven minutes older. Apparently, at thirty-seven, I was still supposed to wait my turn.

He told me nobody needed to hear about my records office job. People would picture a copier. When a woman in silver mistook me for Amber, he explained that I was the office daughter, then patted my arm.

I kept my ginger ale and took the wall.

Beside my chair sat my grocery-store tote. Inside was a brown clasp envelope containing Amber’s packet, which I’d reviewed at 5:40 that morning. My initials were the last before it went up the chain. Three people knew whose desk it had cleared; none belonged to my family.

Mom took the microphone and explained that only one of her two daughters had wanted to become somebody.

Amber followed with, “Love you, Trish. Somebody has to keep the stapler company.”

Laughter traveled all the way to my corner.

At 8:17, Lieutenant General Pruitt entered alone. Three stars on his shoulders quieted the room.

“Before anybody toasts, I came to shake one hand,” he said. “Whoever reviewed Lieutenant Colonel Holloway’s packet at twenty to six this morning.”

He pointed past Amber and Mom toward me.

Dad began to stand.

“Ms. Holloway, come tell your father what you found on page nine.”

Page Nine

I set my glass on the nearest table before my hand could advertise what the rest of me was trying to conceal.

Then I picked up the tote.

Dad stepped into the aisle as I reached him. He put out his hand, palm down, the way he used to stop me crossing a street.

“Trish, leave the bag. You don’t need to bring your things up there.”

“The page is in it.”

“Oh.”

It was the smallest word I’d ever heard him use.

He moved aside.

Amber had risen from her chair beside the podium. Up close, her left shoulder board was crooked. My fingers actually lifted toward it before I stopped them.

Habit is embarrassing. You can be furious with someone and still want to straighten her clothes.

Pruitt stepped away from the microphone.

“May I explain the record issue?” he said to Amber. “No personal information.”

She looked at him, then at me.

“Yes, sir.”

He turned to me.

“Only the relevant page, please.”

I opened the envelope. The copy I’d brought for Amber had its identifying numbers covered. I’d meant to hand it over privately as a keepsake, proof that every correction was complete. I had even put a sticky note on the front: For your files. Congratulations.

I folded that note underneath.

“Page nine listed a required course as incomplete,” I said.

Amber’s forehead creased.

“I finished that.”

“You did. Your completion was in the supporting record. It hadn’t carried into the final summary.”

Colonel Brandt came closer, his hands at his sides.

“The flag would have held her off the release list,” he said.

“Yes.”

Dad gave a little laugh.

“Well, there you go. A typo.”

Pruitt looked directly at him.

“A hold on an officer’s promotion.”

Dad’s mouth stayed open a moment longer than it needed to.

I kept my finger on the page.

“The supporting certificate was there. I checked the dates and the course, got the discrepancy confirmed, and corrected the final record. Then I signed the review.”

At 5:40 that morning, I’d been doing the last check, not deciding whether my sister deserved her rank. She had earned it. My responsibility was making sure a bad entry didn’t take it away.

Pruitt put one hand on the podium.

“Ms. Holloway has authority over the final records check. She can’t award a promotion. She can stop an inaccurate record from going forward. This morning, she did exactly that.”

Amber looked down at page nine.

“If it hadn’t been corrected?”

“Your name would have been held pending correction,” I said. “It was caught before the list went out.”

Her hand went to the oak leaf on her shoulder.

The room had grown so quiet I could hear the ice swan draining into its tray. For what Dad must have paid for that bird, it could have had the decency to melt silently.

Pruitt held out his hand.

“I was invited here to congratulate your sister,” he said. “Brandt told me the final correction had cleared. Before I left, I asked who had done the work.”

I shook his hand.

“Thank you for checking what somebody else assumed was right.”

“You’re welcome, sir.”

No announcement that I secretly outranked everyone. No promotion materializing out of the ceiling. Just my actual job, described accurately in front of people who had spent an hour laughing at it.

It was enough to make my knees unreliable.

Pruitt released my hand. Brandt offered his next.

Dad moved up beside me so quickly his sleeve brushed the envelope.

“That’s our Trish,” he said. “Always had an eye for details. We raised both girls to work hard.”

His arm started around my shoulders.

I stepped out from under it.

He tried again, this time with a smile meant for the room.

“She never tells us anything. We had no idea she had that much responsibility.”

“You told me not to mention my job.”

“Well, now, that’s hardly what I meant.”

I looked at him.

He lowered his hand.

Mom came forward, still carrying her glass. Pam could make a walk across a room look like a visit to someone else’s sickbed, and she was giving it everything she had.

“Honey, your father’s proud. We’re both proud.”

The microphone was between us. She reached for it.

I put my hand on the stand.

For once, she waited.

“I’d like to finish,” I said.

Dad leaned closer.

“The general has thanked you. Don’t make this awkward.”

Behind him, Amber looked at the sticky note protruding beneath the page.

She pulled it free.

For your files. Congratulations.

She read it twice.

“Trish,” she said, “you brought this for me?”

I nodded.

Her face changed. The smile she’d worn for the photographs disappeared, and she pressed the note against the envelope.

Dad touched her elbow.

“Let’s get the music back on. We’ve had a lovely surprise.”

I kept my hand on the microphone stand.

“I haven’t.”

The Microphone Between Us

Dad’s fingers tightened around Amber’s elbow. She took her arm away.

“Trish, please,” Mom said. “People are listening.”

“Yes.”

I had spent most of my life helping her avoid that particular inconvenience.

Dad looked toward Pruitt, who stood beside Brandt without offering him a rescue.

“We tease each other,” Dad said. “That’s all this was. She’s always been the quiet one, and Amber’s always been out in front. Different personalities.”

I nearly asked whether my personality had requested the back wall.

Instead I lifted the microphone out of its stand.

My hand shook. I let it.

“I came here to celebrate my sister,” I said. “I didn’t come here to be the joke.”

Mom set her glass down on the podium.

“Oh, Trish. Nobody thinks you’re a joke.”

“You said only one of us wanted to be somebody.”

“You know what I meant.”

“I know what you said.”

Dad exhaled through his nose.

“Your mother gets emotional. She was talking about ambition. The Army. Service. You can’t compare every word people say and turn it into an insult.”

“I don’t have to compare it.”

Amber moved beside me.

Dad turned to her with relief, as though the sensible daughter had arrived to remove a raccoon from the reception.

“Tell her,” he said. “You know how we talk.”

Amber held the envelope against her uniform.

“I know how we talk about her.”

Mom reached for her wrist.

“Don’t start.”

Amber didn’t move away, but she didn’t take Mom’s hand either.

“She brought me a congratulations note.”

“Of course she did,” Dad said. “She’s your sister.”

“And I made her stand in the back while I got a laugh out of her.”

“You didn’t make her stand anywhere.”

Amber looked at me.

“Did you?”

I nodded toward Dad.

“He did.”

Dad straightened his jacket.

“I asked her to keep a low profile because people were getting confused. They have the same face. You saw it yourself.”

Brandt looked from Amber’s uniform to my cardigan.

Nobody supplied the laugh Dad was waiting for.

“The clothing is a clue,” I said.

It escaped before I could stop it.

Someone near the front gave a surprised little laugh, then went quiet. Dad’s face reddened.

“There. That’s what I’m talking about. She can give it out, but nobody can say anything to her.”

I handed Amber the microphone.

“I’m not doing this all night.”

Her fingers closed around it.

For a second I expected her to give it back to the bandleader. She could still save the party. Put on the smile, say sisters were complicated, get everybody clapping.

She faced the room instead.

“I need to correct something.”

Mom shut her eyes.

Amber swallowed.

“My sister works in the records and awards office. I knew that. I never asked what she actually did there.”

Dad shook his head.

“Amber, you don’t owe anyone—”

“Let me finish.”

He stopped.

Thirty-seven years, and there was the sentence he could obey.

“I made a joke about her job because I knew people would laugh,” Amber said. “I was counting on it.”

She looked at me.

“I’m sorry, Trish.”

I couldn’t answer right away. My throat hurt, and I resented that nearly as much as everything else.

Pruitt glanced toward Brandt, then stepped back. Neither man was going to turn this into an order my family could obey without meaning it.

Dad tried one more time.

“Fine. A joke went wrong. She’s apologized. We all apologize. Can we please enjoy what we’ve spent months putting together?”

He held his hand toward Amber.

“Come here. Let’s get a picture of the family with the general.”

Amber stayed beside me.

“Not yet.”

Mom’s eyes filled.

“You’re humiliating your father.”

Amber looked at her.

“You were holding the microphone when you did it to Trish.”

Mom pressed her lips together. A tear slid down her cheek, and my hand twitched toward my pocket for a tissue.

I left it there.

Dad stared at Amber as if somebody had replaced her while he was speaking.

“This is your promotion party. We did all this for you.”

“I know.”

“The flowers. The room. These people. And now you’re letting her turn it into—”

“She didn’t ask him to come.”

Amber’s voice cracked on the last word.

“I called her a stapler keeper. She was sitting there with something she’d brought to give me.”

The brown envelope bent under her fingers. She loosened them and smoothed the crease against her jacket.

Dad looked at me.

“Are you satisfied?”

“No.”

“What do you want, then?”

I could have given him a list starting in elementary school. I could have made everybody in that room wish the fire alarm would go off.

I wanted one thing I could still use when the general went home.

“Don’t introduce me as the other one again.”

He looked toward the guests, then back at me.

“You’re taking that out of—”

“Her name is Patricia,” Amber said. “You helped choose it.”

Dad looked down.

Mom picked up her glass, then put it back without drinking.

Amber lowered the microphone but didn’t switch it off.

Dad’s words carried.

“I shouldn’t have said that.”

“Or sent me to the back,” I said.

He rubbed his forehead.

“Or sent you to the back.”

Mom wiped beneath one eye.

“And I shouldn’t have said what I said about you wanting to be somebody.”

I waited.

She looked at me rather than the room.

“You work hard. I know you do.”

I nodded once.

Dad reached for my shoulder again.

“We’re still your parents.”

“I know exactly who you are.”

The Chair Beside Amber

His hand fell.

For once, he had nothing ready.

Amber returned the microphone to the stand and turned to the bandleader.

“Give us a minute, please.”

Then she took the envelope from under her arm and offered it to me.

I shook my head.

“It’s yours.”

She held it with both hands.

Pruitt stepped forward.

“Lieutenant Colonel, congratulations on your promotion.”

“Thank you, sir.”

“Ms. Holloway, thank you again.”

He shook my hand a second time. Dad stayed where he was. No photograph with his arm around me, no smiling proof that we’d always been this kind of family.

Brandt moved with Pruitt toward the other guests. The general’s presence had opened the conversation; he wasn’t going to live in our house afterward. What happened next belonged to us.

Mom picked up her purse from the front table.

“Gerry, I think we should go.”

Dad looked at Amber.

“After all this?”

“You can stay,” Amber said. “But Trish is sitting beside me.”

He glanced at the chair next to hers. His jacket hung over its back.

That was his seat.

For a moment, nobody moved.

Then Amber lifted his jacket and handed it to him.

It wasn’t a dramatic object. A navy jacket, slightly warm from the room. But Dad took it as though she had handed him something far heavier.

“You’d move your own father?”

“I’m moving a chair.”

She pulled it out.

I stood there with my tote against my leg, angry enough to leave and tired enough to sit on the carpet.

“Trish?” she said.

I sat.

My feet thanked me before the rest of me knew what to do.

Mom remained beside Dad. She looked at Amber, then at me.

“Will you call us tomorrow?”

“No,” I said. “I’ll call when I’m ready.”

Dad opened his mouth.

Mom touched his sleeve.

They left together, without stopping for the photograph Dad had wanted. Amber didn’t follow them to the door. Neither did I.

For several seconds she stood beside my chair.

Then she sat down.

The band began again, carefully, as though a trumpet could make an apology.

A fresh ginger ale arrived. I held the glass between my palms while Amber put the envelope on her lap.

“You don’t have to stay,” she said.

“I know.”

“I mean it.”

“I know that too.”

She stared toward the door our parents had used.

“I saw you back there.”

“Yes.”

“I saw Dad talking to you.”

I waited.

“I could have come over.”

“Yes.”

She nodded, biting the inside of her cheek.

There was nothing I wanted to do with her tears. I couldn’t use them. I didn’t want to punish her with them either.

“Don’t tell me you didn’t mean it,” I said.

She looked down at the envelope.

“I meant to get the laugh.”

That answer hurt, but at least it stood still when I looked at it.

“You got it.”

“I know.”

Around us, people resumed talking. The woman in silver passed our chairs, stopped, and turned back.

“Patricia,” she said, “I owe you an apology too.”

“Trish is fine.”

“I’m sorry, Trish.”

“Thank you.”

She didn’t touch my arm or tell me how lucky I was to have such a sister. She simply went on her way. I appreciated her more for that than she probably knew.

Amber leaned back.

“Will you let me buy you another drink?”

“This one’s full.”

“Right.”

She looked so lost that I nearly helped her out of it.

Instead, I took a sip.

We sat through a whole song without speaking.

Then she set the envelope on the chair between her knees and bent toward it.

“Can you show me?”

“Page nine?”

“All of it. What you checked.”

I studied her face.

“Now?”

“If you want to.”

I put down my glass and opened the clasp.

We kept the pages low, between us. I showed her the completion date and the wrong entry, the place the confirmation belonged, the review line at the bottom.

She asked questions. Actual questions, with room left afterward for my answers.

By the time I finished, my ginger ale had gone flat.

Amber touched the sticky note.

“Can I keep this on the front?”

“That was the idea.”

She pressed it down carefully.

Later, when I stood to leave, she stood too.

“I’ll walk you out.”

At the back of the room, I collected the tote from beside the chair where Dad had put me. Amber waited while I checked beneath it for anything I’d dropped.

No forgotten glass. No envelope.

Nothing of mine needed to stay against that wall.

We crossed the lobby together. Through the glass doors, the parking lot lights shone on our identical faces.

Amber stopped before the exit.

“Can I call you tomorrow?”

“You can text. Ask first.”

“Okay.”

She pulled the envelope closer to her chest.

I looked at her shoulder.

“You’re crooked.”

She went still, then glanced down.

“The left one?”

“Always.”

“Will you?”

I set my tote on the floor. She bent toward me, and I straightened the silver oak leaf with two fingers.

Then my sister held the door while I went through first.

Family gatherings can bring out the worst in people – especially when someone decides you don’t belong. Read about another family slight in “My Mother Sent Me Away From My Own Lodge”, “My Mother-in-Law Put Thirty People in My Bay Room”, and “My Husband Gave His Mother the Office I Bought”.