We weren’t even planning on taking pictures that day. I just wanted to get out before the vendors packed up early. My husband threw on his old jacket, I grabbed my phone, and our son was already wearing the hoodie he refuses to take off.
He was in a good mood too, goofing around, flexing next to a display of pumpkins like he was posing for a magazine. It felt easy – rare, but easy.
Then a man walked by. Probably early 40s, carrying a paper bag of groceries, coffee in his other hand. He smiled at us, slowed down, and then said, “Can I ask how old he is?”
We’ve had that question before, so I gave the usual answer.
But this man didn’t move on. He stepped closer and said, “I had a brother who looked just like him. Same big smile. We lost him two years ago.”
My husband and I both went quiet. Our son kept grinning, unaware, and asked if he could toss an apple up in the air for the next picture.
Then something
The Part That Usually Gets Skipped Over
I want to back up a little, because the farmers market wasn’t even supposed to be our Saturday plan.
We’d originally talked about driving out to my mother-in-law’s place, about forty minutes north. But she’d called Friday night and said her back was acting up, which is code for “I’d rather not have company but I don’t want to say so directly.” My husband, whose name is Ray, he just nodded at the phone and said “okay, we’ll come next week” and hung up without making a thing of it. That’s how he handles her. Gracefully, which is more than I’d do.
So Saturday morning opened up. Nothing planned. Nowhere to be.
Our son, Marcus, he’s twenty-two. He has Down syndrome and the kind of energy that makes strangers assume he’s performing for them, when really he’s just like that. That’s just Marcus. He woke up at seven-fifteen and had already eaten breakfast and reorganized the pantry by the time I came downstairs.
He’s been on a farmers market kick for about three months. He likes the guy who sells smoked sausage near the back entrance, and he likes watching the bread guy slice samples with the big wooden-handled knife. He’ll stand there for a full five minutes watching that knife go back and forth. Something about the rhythm of it.
Ray found the jacket he always wears, the brown Carhartt with the fraying collar that I’ve tried to throw away twice and he keeps rescuing from the donation bag. Marcus had on his gray hoodie. Ohio State logo, cracked and faded. He’s had it since he was seventeen and it doesn’t fit right anymore but good luck having that conversation.
We left the house at nine forty.
What the Market Looks Like on a Good Day
The farmers market we go to runs along two blocks of a closed-off street downtown. It’s not fancy. Concrete underfoot, metal pipe frames holding up the canopies, a couple of generators running in the back making that low hum you stop noticing after ten minutes.
But on a fall morning when the light comes in at that low angle, the whole thing looks better than it is. The squash stacked up in their orange and green piles. Jars of honey catching the sun. A woman selling dried flowers who always wears the same enormous green hat.
Marcus made a beeline for the sausage guy, name’s Dale, big guy, gray beard, apron permanently stained. Dale knows Marcus by name and always has a sample ready before we even get there. He handed Marcus a toothpick with a piece of smoked kielbasa and they talked for maybe four minutes about whether the Bears had any shot this season. Dale’s opinion was no. Marcus’s opinion was also no but delivered with more sadness.
We moved down the row. Ray bought two loaves of the dark rye we like. I got a bunch of kale I probably won’t use and a jar of apple butter I definitely will.
And then we got to the pumpkins.
There was a whole display, a farmer named Gus who drives in from about an hour out and sets up this elaborate arrangement every fall. Big ones, small ones, some of those weird warty gourds. Stacked on hay bales and old wooden crates.
Marcus looked at them for about two seconds and then turned sideways and hit a bodybuilder pose, bicep flexed, chin up, completely serious expression. Ray started laughing. I got my phone out.
That’s when I took the first picture.
He Slowed Down
The man came from the direction of the bread vendor. Paper bag tucked under one arm, coffee cup in his right hand. He was wearing a fleece vest, jeans, boots that had some actual mud on them. Dark hair, a little gray at the temples. He looked like someone’s dad, someone’s neighbor.
He smiled at Marcus first. Marcus was still posing.
Then he looked at us, me and Ray, and he slowed his walk and said, “Can I ask how old he is?”
I said twenty-two.
The man nodded. He had that look people get sometimes, the one that’s not pity exactly, but something adjacent to it. Something softer. “Twenty-two,” he said, mostly to himself.
Then he didn’t keep walking.
He shifted his grocery bag, took a breath, and said, “I had a brother who looked just like him. Same big smile. We lost him two years ago.”
I said I was sorry. Ray said it too. Both of us automatic, because what else do you say in the first three seconds.
The man’s name was Gary. He told us that a minute later, after Marcus came bounding over and introduced himself first, hand out, very formal, the way he does with people he senses are important somehow.
Gary shook his hand and said “Gary” and Marcus said “I’m Marcus, I like your vest” and Gary laughed, a real one, and said “thank you, man.”
His Brother’s Name Was Donnie
Gary’s brother was thirty-eight when he died. Heart failure, which Gary said came fast and without much warning. “He’d had some issues we knew about,” Gary said, “but you never think it’s going to be that fast.”
Donnie had lived with their parents most of his life, then with Gary and Gary’s wife for the last six years. Gary said it matter-of-factly, not like he was asking for credit. Just the situation.
“He loved grocery shopping,” Gary said. “I know that sounds weird. But every Saturday he wanted to come to the market. He’d make a list. He’d bring his own bag.” Gary held up his own paper bag. “I still come every Saturday. I don’t know why. Maybe I’m waiting for it to feel normal again.”
Marcus was listening. He does that, Marcus. People underestimate how much he’s actually tracking.
He said, “What was his favorite thing to get?”
Gary looked at him. “Apples,” he said. “Honeycrisps. He’d eat one before we even got home.”
Marcus nodded like this was very serious information. Then he turned to me and said, “Mom, can we get apples? Can I toss one up for the picture?”
I said yes.
Gary watched Marcus run over to the apple stand, which was three stalls down. Just watched him go, this big kid in a cracked Ohio State hoodie, weaving through people with total confidence.
“He’s something,” Gary said. Not to us specifically. Just out loud.
What Ray Did Next
Ray is not a talker. Never has been. He’s the kind of man who stands next to you at a party and makes you feel like the conversation is going fine even though he’s said maybe nine words. He communicates mostly through proximity and the occasional well-placed “hm.”
But he put his hand on Gary’s shoulder.
Just for a second. One hand, firm, no words attached to it.
Gary looked down at Ray’s hand and then back up and his jaw did the thing jaws do when someone is holding something in. He nodded once.
That was it. That was the whole exchange.
Marcus came back with a Honeycrisp apple, already holding it up like he was about to throw a pitch, huge grin, hoodie slightly askew.
“Okay,” he said. “Take the picture.”
I took the picture.
After
Gary stayed another few minutes. He told us Donnie used to flex next to the pumpkins too, which none of us knew how to respond to, so we all just stood there for a second and then Marcus said “great minds” and Gary laughed again.
Before he left, Gary said something I’ve been turning over since. He said, “I used to wonder if he knew how much we loved him. Like if it registered the way it was supposed to.” He paused. “I think it did. I think he knew. But I still wonder.”
He said it to no one in particular. Or maybe to Marcus. Hard to tell.
Marcus looked at him and said, “He knew. Moms and brothers are obvious.”
Gary said goodbye. He walked back toward the parking lot, paper bag under his arm, coffee in his hand.
We watched him go.
Then Marcus asked if we could get smoked sausage again because he wanted to say bye to Dale before we left, and we said yes, and we did, and Dale said the Bears still had no shot, and Marcus still disagreed, and we drove home with two loaves of rye bread and a jar of apple butter and a Honeycrisp apple Marcus ate in the car before we hit the highway.
I still have the picture. Marcus mid-toss, apple blurring in the air, face wide open.
I don’t know Gary’s last name. I don’t know anything else about Donnie except that he liked Honeycrisps and made a list before grocery shopping and had a big smile.
But I think about them both more than makes sense for two people I met for eight minutes on a concrete sidewalk next to a pile of pumpkins.
—
If this one got to you, pass it along to someone who might need it today.
For more unexpected encounters and family drama, check out My Stepmom Told Me to Eat After the Family – She Didn’t Know My Brother Was Standing Right There or read about what happened when My Parents Showed Up Uninvited to My Cookout – and Danny Was Already There.
