My father has been dead eleven years.
Yesterday a letter came to my mom’s house in HIS handwriting.
The postmark was from last month.
“Jenna, don’t touch that,” my mom said, and she took it out of my hands before I got the envelope turned over.
She never remarried. Shane Hodges got a folded flag and a closed casket in 2015, and she still keeps his coats on the left side of the hall closet like he’s coming back for them in the fall.
I drove up from Louisville that morning because she’d asked me to help her sort the mail she’d been ignoring for three weeks.
She put the envelope in the drawer under the TV remotes and asked if I wanted coffee.
The return address was a P.O. box in Somerset, Kentucky. My dad was from Tulsa. He died in Helmand Province.
I let it go until she went to take her shower.
Then I opened the drawer.
There were nine more.
Same handwriting, all of them, postmarked across four years, every one slit open along the top and put back in order.
The last one had a phone number written on the back flap in pencil, in my mother’s handwriting.
I went through the bank app on her tablet while the water was still running. Four hundred dollars a month, same transfer, since January 2016. Recipient initials D.H.
My chest went tight.
When she came out with a towel over her shoulder I had the letters spread across the coffee table on top of the church bulletin.
“Who is D.H.,” I said.
She stood in the doorway and didn’t move for a long time.
Then she said, “YOUR FATHER CAME HOME, JENNA. He just didn’t come home to us.”
Her hand went to the back of the recliner and she lowered herself into it like her legs had quit, and the towel slid off onto the carpet.
I couldn’t get air in.
“There was no body in that casket,” she said. “They told me there was, and I signed for it anyway.”
She picked up the oldest letter and held it against her chest without opening it.
“Sit down,” she said. “There’s a reason I never let you see him.”
What She’d Been Carrying Since Before I Graduated High School
I sat down. On the end of the couch closest to the door, which I noticed and didn’t move.
She didn’t look at me. She looked at the stack of envelopes on the church bulletin, which had a photo of a sunrise on the front and some verse about peace I wasn’t reading.
She said she got the first call in March of 2015. Not the official one, not the casualty notification officer at the door with his dress uniform. That came later. This was a different call. A number she didn’t recognize. A voice she did.
“He said he was hurt,” she told me. “He said it was bad. He said there were things he couldn’t explain to me, things that had happened, and that if the Army said he was gone I needed to let them say it.”
I asked her what that meant.
She said she didn’t know, not at first. She thought maybe he’d lost his mind. She thought maybe someone was playing a cruel joke. She hung up. He called back four minutes later and said one thing she wouldn’t repeat to me, something only the two of them would know, and after that she believed him.
She signed the paperwork three weeks later. Accepted the flag. Stood at the grave.
“I cried at that funeral,” she said. “I cried real tears. Because in every way that mattered to anyone watching, he was gone.”
She’d been sitting on this for nine years.
Nine years of his coats in the closet, of the flag in the shadow box in the bedroom, of me calling her on his birthday so she wouldn’t be alone.
“You let me grieve him,” I said.
“I know.”
“I was seventeen.”
She didn’t say anything to that.
What the Letters Actually Said
She handed me the oldest one.
The envelope was soft at the edges from being handled. The postmark said February 2016, a Somerset P.O. box, the return just a number and a street.
The handwriting was my dad’s. I’d know it anywhere. He used to leave notes in my lunch bag through seventh grade, stupid jokes, the handwriting big and slanted right, and this was the same. Older somehow. Tighter. Like he’d been practicing keeping it small.
It said:
Linda. I’m okay. I know that doesn’t cover it. I know nothing covers it. I’m in Kentucky for now, working, staying low. I’m not in danger. I want you to know I’m not in danger. The money will come the first of every month. I don’t expect you to do anything with this. I just needed you to know I’m still here.
D.
That was it. No explanation. No sorry. No I love you, though maybe that was the whole letter.
I put it down and picked up the second one. Same year, four months later.
Linda. I heard about Jenna’s graduation. I know you had the party at Connie’s. I hope she got the red one.
I looked up. “The red what?”
Mom was quiet a second. “Dress,” she said. “I told him you were looking at dresses for graduation. He meant the sundress. The one with the straps.”
I bought that dress. I wore it to my graduation party at Aunt Connie’s. I thought my mom had talked me into it.
She had. Just not the way I thought.
The Thing He Couldn’t Tell Her on the Phone
I read all nine letters that afternoon. Mom made coffee and didn’t stop me. She sat in the recliner with her feet pulled up and watched me read, and I didn’t look at her between letters because I didn’t trust what my face was doing.
The letters were short. Never more than a page. He wrote about weather sometimes, about the land around Somerset, about a dog he’d apparently acquired. He asked about me more than anything else. What I was studying. Whether I was still running. Whether I’d kept up with the girl from high school he’d always liked, Becca Pruitt, who I had not.
He never explained.
Not in any of the nine letters. Not once did he write the words that would tell me what actually happened in Helmand Province in October 2015, what made a man fake his own death and move to a lake town in Kentucky and send four hundred dollars a month to his wife for nine years and never come home.
The tenth letter, the one from last month, was still sealed. My mom had put it in the drawer before she opened it.
She handed it to me without me asking.
I opened it.
It said:
Linda. I have cancer. It’s in my liver. The doctor says six months, maybe less. I’m not writing to ask for anything. I’m writing because I thought you should know, and because there’s a decision to make that isn’t mine. Jenna should know I’m alive before I’m not. But that’s yours to decide. It’s always been yours. I just ran out of time to stay quiet.
D.
I read it twice. Then I put it face down on the coffee table and looked at the ceiling for a while.
“How long have you had this,” I said.
“Three weeks,” she said. “That’s why the mail.”
The Number on the Back of the Envelope
The phone number was written in my mom’s handwriting on the back flap of the second-to-last letter. Not the one from last month. The one before it, from about eight months ago.
I asked her when she’d written it.
She said she hadn’t written it. She said she’d copied it from somewhere, and that she’d been looking at it for eight months without dialing it.
I picked up my phone.
“Jenna,” she said.
“I know,” I said.
I dialed anyway.
It rang four times. I was preparing for voicemail. Then someone picked up and didn’t say anything, just breathing, and I said, “Is this Shane Hodges,” and the breathing stopped.
Then a voice I hadn’t heard in eleven years said, “Jenna.”
Just that. My name. The same way he used to say it when I came in past curfew and he was sitting at the kitchen table in the dark. Not angry. Just. There.
My mom had her hand over her mouth.
I said, “You have cancer.”
He said, “Yeah.”
I said, “In your liver.”
He said, “Yeah. Six months was optimistic. I think it’s less now.”
I asked him what happened in Helmand. He was quiet long enough that I thought he wouldn’t answer. Then he said it wasn’t something he could explain on the phone, that there were things he’d done and things that had been done to him and that the simplest version was that coming home would have put us in danger. That the death was the only way to make us safe. That he’d spent nine years making sure whatever had followed him out of Afghanistan stayed pointed at him and not at us.
I don’t know if I believe that. I don’t know if it’s true or if it’s a story a man tells himself after he runs.
But I know his voice. I know it’s him.
What I Did With the Next Four Hours
I didn’t drive back to Louisville. I sat in my mom’s living room until it got dark and she turned the lamp on, and we didn’t talk much, and she made soup she didn’t eat.
I called my husband, Greg. Told him I needed another day. He asked if everything was okay. I said no, and he said okay, and that was enough.
I looked up Somerset on my phone. Two hours from my mom’s house. About two and a half from Louisville.
I read the letters again, the ones I hadn’t memorized yet. The one where he mentioned a dog. The one where he said he’d watched the Kentucky Derby alone and it made him think of the time we watched it at my uncle’s and I’d bet five dollars on a horse because I liked its name and won forty-two.
I remembered that. I was eleven. The horse was called Gentleman Jim or something like it. I’d spent the forty-two dollars on a poster for my room.
He’d watched that race alone in a house in Somerset and thought about me winning forty-two dollars when I was eleven.
I don’t know what to do with that.
My mom fell asleep in the recliner around nine. I covered her with the blanket from the back of the couch, the old green one that’s been in this house my whole life.
His coats are still on the left side of the closet.
I stood there for a while with the closet open, not touching them. They still smell like him, or I think they do. Maybe that’s just what I want.
I’m going to Somerset on Thursday.
I haven’t told my mom yet. I haven’t decided if I’m telling her before I go or after.
I don’t know what I’ll say when I see him. I don’t know if I’ll hug him or scream at him or just sit across a table and look at his face until I figure out what’s still my father and what got left behind somewhere in Helmand Province.
He said six months. He said less.
I’m going Thursday.
—
If this hit you somewhere you weren’t expecting, pass it along. Someone else might need to read it.
For more tales of the unexpected, you might want to check out I’ve Sat Next to This Man at the VA for Twelve Years. I Never Knew His Name., or read about He Said He Needed Air. He Left Me. Twenty-Two Years Later He’s in the Next Room. And if you’re in the mood for another twist, don’t miss My Mom Left Me Nothing. Then the Notary Pushed a Second Envelope Across the Table..
